16 ms·
For the same price, you can get twice the space for 1/4 the endurance, thrice the space for 1/8th the endurance, and now four times the space for 1/16th the end
by userbinator 4y ago
For the same price, you can get twice the space for 1/4 the endurance, thrice the space for 1/8th the endurance, and now four times the space for 1/16th the endurance. Most people don't realise that is a horrible tradeoff, because NAND flash marketing and terminology like "TLC" or "QLC" is intentionally deceptive and manufacturers have been very secretive about the true endurance specifications, as well as trying to overprice SLC out of production. If more people knew the truth of what they were trying to do, we wouldn't be in this situation.
- newZWhoDis 4y agoCan you explain your point further? Are you talking about competitors?
- wmf 4y agoWhile NAND endurance has certainly gone down, FTLs got much better during the same time so that SSD endurance is still fine for most people. And if the stock endurance isn't enough, a little overprovisioning is probably better than dropping back to very expensive MLC.
- userbinator 4y agoIf the number of firmware bugs in SSDs we've seen over time is any indication, I don't think things are really getting better... SLC needs almost no FTL. 100K endurance. Very low raw error rate that can be handled with basic ECC.
- wahern 4y ago> as well as trying to overprice SLC out of production. Is it even possible to buy SLC drives any more? For the past 5+ years the only outlet I've been able to find that even advertise SLC is https://www.delkin.com/ https://www.delkin.com/, and you need to speak to sales to even get a price. I just assumed they and any other similar suppliers bought giant lots of chips at the tail end of SLC production and jack up the price on every new order as their supply dwindles. Or maybe they cobble together drives from the tiny SLC chips used for cache on modern SSDs?
- userbinator 4y agoIs it even possible to buy SLC drives any more? Yes, small ones for industrial use. They're extremely expensive, however. Looking at the raw NAND flash prices, SLC seems to still be around $4.60USD/GB, or roughly the same as it was over a decade ago, while MLC is already <$1USD/GB despite only a doubling in capacity. TLC and QLC seems to be down in the $0.10USD/GB. You can still buy raw SLC NAND flash in the smaller capacities of few GBs; this one is only 512MB, at the price mentioned above: https://www.newark.com/micron/mt29f4g08abaeawp-it-e/flash-memory-4gbit-40-to-85deg/dp/80AH7778 https://www.newark.com/micron/mt29f4g08abaeawp-it-e/flash-me... If the pricing was sane, SLC drives would be only 4x more expensive as QLC ones for the same capacity, but that's not what we're seeing today.
- Wowfunhappy 4y agoDo you think the pricing difference could be due to economies of scale?
- wmf 4y agoIn theory an SSD could run TLC NAND in SLC mode with just a firmware change but I'm not aware of any such drives.
- namibj 4y agoSamsung 980 Pro, the original, does that when sufficiently empty, to offer around iirc 10% nominal capacity of SLC-mode write buffer (given they are TLC, that would be around 30% of the NAND).
- wtallis 4y agoEnmotus partnered with Phison to produce a QLC SSD that mapped the first several GB of logical blocks to SLC. This was sold bundled with Enmotus's SSD caching software, but it could also be treated as simply having a SLC partition and a QLC partition that are largely independent.
- renonce 4y agoMany TLC drives have SLC cache so if you limit usage of the drive you may effectively use it in SLC-only mode. This does not say anything about its endurance however. If you want endurance, better mirror your data to HDD.
- emodendroket 4y agoIs it a horrible tradeoff though? I can think of many situations where that would be a somewhat compelling alternative to a spinning platter.
- HyperSane 4y agoIt isn't a bad tradeoff for most read workloads.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoFor most people this isn't a horrible tradeoff. For example, my desktop which I use pretty heavily, I've averaged 24 GB writes per day. With 500 drive writes of a TLC drive, my ssd will last me roughly 50 years at current rate. If I had to chose between a 300 GB SSD that will last me 400 years or a 1TB ssd that lasts 50 years, I'll take the TB one any day of the week.