3 ms·
The Muppet Christmas Carol is a great film. One thing I find very striking about it is that it felt free to swing between being a Muppets movie and being a fai
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
The Muppet Christmas Carol is a great film.
One thing I find very striking about it is that it felt free to swing between being a Muppets movie and being a faithful rendition of the story according to whatever was better for the movie. There are two Marleys in the Muppet Christmas Carol, because the best Muppet personality match to Jacob Marley is a set of two Muppet characters. That's great. But then on the other end, when Dickens has produced a great piece of writing that doesn't translate well to film... Rizzo the Rat can whip out his copy of the book and just read that passage to the audience. Even better!
Someone had a vision for this movie and did an amazing job.
> I feel like since then we have somewhat lost the capability to make these sorts of movies.
Copyright is a big problem here. If you want to find the best possible version of a story, you need to let different people experiment with different ways of telling it.
- a_e_k 4y ago> There are two Marleys in the Muppet Christmas Carol, because the best Muppet personality match to Jacob Marley is a set of two Muppet characters. It also let them have the parental bonus of a character named Robert Marley. > Rizzo the Rat can whip out his copy of the book and just read that passage to the audience. The neat thing about that is that the book was basically meant as a read-aloud. Dicken's had a condensed version which he'd get up on stage and read to audiences in a dramatic way. (He'd failed as a professional actor, but definitely found another path to success!) So I love that Gonzo reciting narration passages directly from the book is even more true to authorial intent in some ways.