8 ms·

Show HN: Find similar podcasts

33 points by wenbin 4y ago

gus_massa 4y ago
How are you classifying them to get the similarity? It it a manual process or you are using the description of each podcast?
jdbiggs 4y ago
I tried to do this a while back. People just don't want that kind of search in a standalone site, needs to be a feature on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
RajT88 4y ago
Better question: What's a good podcast downloader these days? All the ones which seem to be current and still function require an account, or have stupid limitations like only downloading files in batches. I was so displeased last time I wanted to scrape a full podcast, I banged out something in powershell which I've been using since.
- prteja11 4y ago
  Overcast for iOS
- pksebben 4y ago
  I've been on pocket casts for years and found very few reasons not to love it
poisonarena 4y ago
I know this doesn't work because I typed in the Adam Friedland show and then the response I got back was all horrible comedy/cringe podcasts they would make fun of
timdiggerm 4y ago
I am not sure that this works very well. I put in "BibleProject" and "Alastair's Adversaria" which are both Christian Theology podcasts, and I got back "Erotic Short Stories: Read by Mia Hart" as the top result which... I just doubt that's a similar podcast.
- super256 4y ago
  Me too. I really enjoy MRKT Call from Risk Reversal Media. They also repost their MRKT Call podcasts into their „on the tape“ podcast podcast. But when you enter one of those two, it doesn’t show the other one.
- yunwal 4y ago
  I’m getting really tired of this “launch an AI product with no QA and have users point out your mistakes” approach. It’s very clear that this site doesn’t work. Anyone who uses it for 2 seconds can see it. Why launch it right now?
maupin 4y ago
I typed in a game club let's play type podcast (Playthrough) and one of the results was a woodworking podcast...
reidjs 4y ago
If you live in the Bay Area check out the "Bay Area Weekend" Podcast
jmduke 4y ago
To echo others: I love the concept for this, but I do not think the current implementation is successful. I put in The Lowe Post (a fairly popular ESPN basketball podcast) and got: 1. another basketball podcast (nice!) 2. a podcast about outdoor camping 3. a podcast about Ohio State University sports OP: what I'd _really_ love in this vein is a way to go from "here's a podcast I like and listen to, give me a list of podcasts in which the host or guests of the host also appear." I suspect that may be a difficult set of structured data to assemble, but I think it'd be very valuable.
- ESMirro 4y ago
  Apple Podcasts is the only platform I know of that provides this sort of functionality and support even there is hit & miss.
martopix 4y ago
It worked well for me. I put in three podcasts that I listen to, and the first two results are two more podcasts that I listen to. There were a lot of my favourites in the whole list. Maybe I'm predictable?
ok123456 4y ago
I put in "Chapo Trap House" and "The Adam Friedland Show" and it recommended "The Rachel Maddow Show"????
donniefitz2 4y ago
Not sure about this. I searched for my own podcast, The GMRS Podcast, and the suggestions were all over the place. The Tournament Poker Podcast being number one followed by a Magic The Gathering podcast and some automotive stuff. Needs work.
zote 4y ago
Nice work, I put in my favourite podcast and did get some really good suggestions , granted there were some (a few) results that weren't very similar. It feels like something that could be a part of a listening app.
georgel 4y ago
It's asking me to subscribe and pay before I get any recommendations. Hard pass.
amadeuspagel 4y ago
Just to counter a possible bias of people pointing out only weird results: I looked for podcasts like "conversations with tyler" and got other podcasts produced by the mercatus center, other podcasts about economics, other wide-ranging podcasts. Nothing weird, at least among those I recognized. I added "lunar society" and I discovered a podcast about design called 99% Invisible, which looks interesting.
- pkd 4y ago
  99PI is one of the best podcasts around. I enjoy almost all episodes.
gus_massa 4y ago
Try to change the title form [Show HN] Find similar podcasts to Show HN: Find similar podcasts
- deleted 4y ago
  [deleted]

33 points by wenbin 4y ago

How are you classifying them to get the similarity? It it a manual process or you are using the description of each podcast?

jdbiggs 4y ago

I tried to do this a while back. People just don't want that kind of search in a standalone site, needs to be a feature on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

RajT88 4y ago

Better question: What's a good podcast downloader these days? All the ones which seem to be current and still function require an account, or have stupid limitations like only downloading files in batches. I was so displeased last time I wanted to scrape a full podcast, I banged out something in powershell which I've been using since.

prteja11 4y ago
Overcast for iOS
pksebben 4y ago
I've been on pocket casts for years and found very few reasons not to love it

poisonarena 4y ago

I know this doesn't work because I typed in the Adam Friedland show and then the response I got back was all horrible comedy/cringe podcasts they would make fun of

timdiggerm 4y ago

I am not sure that this works very well. I put in "BibleProject" and "Alastair's Adversaria" which are both Christian Theology podcasts, and I got back "Erotic Short Stories: Read by Mia Hart" as the top result which... I just doubt that's a similar podcast.

super256 4y ago
Me too. I really enjoy MRKT Call from Risk Reversal Media. They also repost their MRKT Call podcasts into their „on the tape“ podcast podcast. But when you enter one of those two, it doesn’t show the other one.
yunwal 4y ago
I’m getting really tired of this “launch an AI product with no QA and have users point out your mistakes” approach. It’s very clear that this site doesn’t work. Anyone who uses it for 2 seconds can see it. Why launch it right now?

maupin 4y ago

I typed in a game club let's play type podcast (Playthrough) and one of the results was a woodworking podcast...

reidjs 4y ago

If you live in the Bay Area check out the "Bay Area Weekend" Podcast

jmduke 4y ago

To echo others: I love the concept for this, but I do not think the current implementation is successful. I put in The Lowe Post (a fairly popular ESPN basketball podcast) and got: 1. another basketball podcast (nice!) 2. a podcast about outdoor camping 3. a podcast about Ohio State University sports OP: what I'd _really_ love in this vein is a way to go from "here's a podcast I like and listen to, give me a list of podcasts in which the host or guests of the host also appear." I suspect that may be a difficult set of structured data to assemble, but I think it'd be very valuable.

ESMirro 4y ago
Apple Podcasts is the only platform I know of that provides this sort of functionality and support even there is hit & miss.

martopix 4y ago

It worked well for me. I put in three podcasts that I listen to, and the first two results are two more podcasts that I listen to. There were a lot of my favourites in the whole list. Maybe I'm predictable?

ok123456 4y ago

I put in "Chapo Trap House" and "The Adam Friedland Show" and it recommended "The Rachel Maddow Show"????

donniefitz2 4y ago

Not sure about this. I searched for my own podcast, The GMRS Podcast, and the suggestions were all over the place. The Tournament Poker Podcast being number one followed by a Magic The Gathering podcast and some automotive stuff. Needs work.

zote 4y ago

Nice work, I put in my favourite podcast and did get some really good suggestions , granted there were some (a few) results that weren't very similar. It feels like something that could be a part of a listening app.

georgel 4y ago

It's asking me to subscribe and pay before I get any recommendations. Hard pass.

amadeuspagel 4y ago

Just to counter a possible bias of people pointing out only weird results: I looked for podcasts like "conversations with tyler" and got other podcasts produced by the mercatus center, other podcasts about economics, other wide-ranging podcasts. Nothing weird, at least among those I recognized. I added "lunar society" and I discovered a podcast about design called 99% Invisible, which looks interesting.

pkd 4y ago
99PI is one of the best podcasts around. I enjoy almost all episodes.

gus_massa 4y ago

Try to change the title form [Show HN] Find similar podcasts to Show HN: Find similar podcasts

deleted 4y ago
[deleted]