4 ms·
There isn’t a trust nobody solution to the guardianship issue. Your solution just means trusting the individual. That seems reasonable on the surface, but resu
by Retric 4y ago
There isn’t a trust nobody solution to the guardianship issue. Your solution just means trusting the individual. That seems reasonable on the surface, but results in unpleasantness due to degenerative diseases like Alzheimer's etc. It’s an extremely vulnerable population that constantly get targeted by scammers who prey a people with diminished mental capacity.
To be clear I am not saying government is the right solution, just that the problem does exist. Not just because people get taken advantage of but because taxpayers gets stuck taking care of people who have lost everything.
PS: Being able to trust children is one solution that works at the individual level, but it unfortunately doesn’t scale.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIn my example I'm not trusting the individual but individual may be trusting themselves. I think that is a crucial difference morally, legally, and politically. It is one thing to give up your own autonomy because you don't trust yourself, which is entirely reasonable. It is another thing to give up everybody's personal autonomy because you don't trust yourself. Giving the government the power to strip someone's rights and place them in guardianship I'm sure avoid some elder abuse and suffering. My point is that I don't think it is ethical for those who want this protection to make that decision for everyone.
- Retric 4y agoArguing about the ethics is one way to shape policy, but it doesn’t make problems disappear. Every day people do lose the ability to make informed decisions without preparing for that change. How and why we respond to that doesn’t change the underlying biology.
- s1artibartfast 4y ago100% agree it doesn't change the biology. Ethics just determines the acceptable collateral damage from our policy solution. How many beneficial guardianships are an acceptable trade for one abusive guardianship? Maybe the answer is absolutely 0 and this should be off limits for policy.