4 ms·
> The lost source was still easily lethal. From https://www.aap.com.au/news/search-for-radioactive-capsule-in-outback/ https://www.aap.com.au/news/search-for-r
by gus_massa 4y ago
> The lost source was still easily lethal.
From https://www.aap.com.au/news/search-for-radioactive-capsule-in-outback/ https://www.aap.com.au/news/search-for-radioactive-capsule-i...
> Dr Robertson said the unit emits about two millisieverts of radiation per hour, which is the equivalent of having 10 x-rays in an hour.
Form https://xkcd.com/radiation/ https://xkcd.com/radiation/
> 2 millisieverts: Head CT scan
> 50 millisieverts: Maximum yearly dose permitted for US radiation workers
> 100 millisieverts: Lowest one-year dose clearly linked to increase of cancer risk.
> 400 millisieverts: Dose causing symptoms of radiation poisoning if received in a short time.
So if you keep the source for a day in your pocket, you reach the limit of radiation of a radiation worker. It's not wise, but that number is still quite conservative. I guess it's not lethal, but I definitively would not try to do that.
A few days or a week? It looks like a very very very bad idea.
If I were in charge, I'd also try to recover it as soon as possible. The idea is to minimize the health risk and the radiation received by people. And if some moron decides to open it, the health risk and cleanup would be much worse.
From the same article:
> “It emits both beta and gamma rays, so if you have contact or close to you, you could either end up with skin damage, including skin burns … and if you have it long near you it could cause acute radiation sickness,” Dr Robertson said.
It sounds definitively dangerous, but not all dangerous things are lethal (in a short time).
- dTal 4y ago>So if you keep the source for a day in your pocket, you reach the limit of radiation of a radiation worker You're missing the part where 2 millisieverts / hour is the dose at a distance of 1 meter. If you put in your pocket, you would rapidly sustain radiation burns. You're also missing that a dose sustained over a short period is much more deadly than a dose dragged out over a year. In the latter case, the body will be repairing the damage as it happens, mitigating the effect.
- gus_massa 4y agoWhere did you get the distancie of 1 meter? It's very hard to get any data from the press. I think you are right. Let's make some back of the envelope calculations. The frontal surface of a person is 1m^2 approximately. The surface of a sphere of 1m is 4/3*pi*(1m)^2 ~= 4m^2. The silly proportion is 2msV/1m^2*4m^2 = 8mSv, but 1m is not far enough to assume the sphere is almost flat. Let's duplicate it to 16mSv (8 idiots can form a round at 1m, shoulder to shoulder and absorb almost all the radiation). May I round it to 20 mSv? If someone put it in the pocket, s/he will get half of the radiation, that is 10mSv/hour. [Before you find more errors in my comment, I agree that it's more complicated. The front pockets of the pants are probably the worst area. Holding it in a closed hand would double the radiation. Anyway, if you have a more accurate calculation, it is welcome.] A Chest CT scan is 7mSv and it takes like half an hour, but it's more evenly distributed. My guess is that you can get some nasty radioactive burns as warned in the press article, but in a short time it's not lethal as clamed by the GP.
- dTal 4y agoHere you go, a primary source: https://radiationserviceswa.com.au/missing-radioactive-source-in-western-australia/ https://radiationserviceswa.com.au/missing-radioactive-sourc... excerpt>>> The risk with radiation sources dramatically increases within 1 m – we can calculate the dose rate using the ‘inverse square law’: At 1 cm, the dose rate will be 10,000 time higher …. 16,650 mSv/h (or 16.65 Sv/h) At 1mm (ie, if you were to pick the source up with your fingers), the dose rate would be 1,665 Sv/h – this will cause some serious damage to your fingers and surrounding tissues. >>> I'm a little suspicious of their inverse-square calculation, though, as by their logic the dose rate would be infinite at a distance of 0m (skin contact). That's clearly not the case.
- gus_massa 4y agoThanks for the link. It looks like the get the official data at 1m and decided to extrapolate, but those calculations don't make any sense. The inverse square law is only a good approximation when the source and the target are small (or other special configurations, for example when one of them is a sphere).
- Pxtl 4y agoRight. If a "weak" thing like this ends up in a place where somebody is near it constantly - like a workplace desk, or in somebody's home? It may take months but they will accumulate a lethal dose.
- gus_massa 4y agoI agree. Something like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kramatorsk_radiological_accident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kramatorsk_radiological_accide... linked in another thread.