4 ms·
As long as the websites are up, publish "quotes" that appear to represent alleged "gains" and the amount of withdrawals remains reasonably low. Like any Ponzi
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
As long as the websites are up, publish "quotes" that appear to represent alleged "gains" and the amount of withdrawals remains reasonably low. Like any Ponzi scheme.
NB. "Withdrawals" here means what the article calls "redemptions". It means recovering the fiat currency that one surrendered in order to participate in the Ponzi scheme.
Bitcoin could have "collapsed" weeks, months or years ago, but how would anyone know. A Ponzi scheme can be undetectable until the victims try to withdraw their funds.
As long as websites publish a purported "quote" then people reading may continue to believe it. People can argue about the "value" of BTC until they are blue in the face (watch for the replies to this comment) but until they actually withdraw the funds they committed in real money to participate, let alone any purported gains, it is all speculation. There are no guarantees because crypto is unregulated.1
These crypto entities are not required by law to disclose anything. How does anyone verify if what they disclose is actually true. If someone believes BTC is truly worth what is published on CoinMarketCap, then they should try cashing out and prove it.2 The ones who cash out early will get their money, but if enough people try to cash out in a short period, then the Ponzi scheme will be exposed. The schemers cannot cover the withdrawals. Most BTC owners will lose their real money.
But then, who wants money when one has BTC. If one believes in crypto then perhaps one believes money (fiat currency) is ultimately useless.
Tether had to be sued by the NY Attorney General for it to release basic information. Ths sad reality is that the only effective means to getting information about what crypto schemers are doing has been to bring civil or criminal proceedings against them.
1. With respect to the US, crypto is unlike shares of stock, the issuance and trading of which must comply with securities laws. Tether is not registered with the SEC.
2. "Cash out" here means convert to real money (fiat currency). The article refers to this as "redemptions".
- pcthrowaway 4y agoTether?... withdrawals? Not sure what you mean here. Do you mean conversion? With BTC, 99% of users could withdraw their BTC from the exchange and it would have relatively little effect on price (although there might be volatility). Trading for USD would impact the price, and I'm suspecting that's what you mean by "withdrawal". But trading anything into anything else devalues it relative to the other thing. You could say the same thing about a stock. If everyone holding Alphabet decided to try to sell it tomorrow, the price would crater, because that's how markets work. This not the same thing as a Ponzi scheme.
- rcme 4y agoTether supports redemptions of USDT to USD: https://tether.to/es/redeem-tethers-to-your-bank-account/ https://tether.to/es/redeem-tethers-to-your-bank-account/
- lmm 4y agoThey claim to, if you meet their verification requirements, and if you're requesting enough. What's the betting that their account verification would happen to have some technical issues during any crisis?
- arcticbull 4y agoThey claim to but nobody has posted proof that they got their money. Their terms of service at tether.to/legal says they can basically deny or indefinitely delay redemptions arbitrarily, and the only people who backed up Tether's claims publicly are SBF and Trabucco and I'm not sure I believe them anymore.
- SilasX 4y agoIf someone didn’t get their money when they tried to redeem, they would definitely scream bloody murder about that. So far, no such party has.
- arcticbull 4y agoThey're simply not incentivized to do that. If they did their USDT would actually become worthless. If they said nothing and simply exchanged it to the next fool, they get their money. Contractually, Tether doesn't allow redemptions from most people. New Yorkers are excluded thanks to the NYAG settlement. US persons are (or were when I checked) blanket excluded in their terms. Of the remainder, only their 'customers' as defined at their sole discretion are eligible for redemptions. Then, you have to meet minimum transaction size requirements ($100K I believe) and also pay their fees. What individual would bother doing all that when they can hit 'sell' on Coinbase? So once the retail rubes are ruled out, you've really only got gigaholders whose fate is so tied to USDT's continued existence and value that pantsing the emperor leaves them rekt.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago"Withdrawals" could also mean "swaps", e.g., From the article: "Like other stablecoins, its value depends on a simple notion: Investors expect that Tether the company will swap $1 for one tether, or one tether for $1. Central to that is the assertion that Tether has enough reserves to redeem all the roughly 68 billion tethers in existence." Or "withdrawal" could mean "exchanage", e.g., "3. Putting your savings in Tether Tether is usually worth $1, and you can earn far more interest lending it than you would with the best high-yield savings accounts. Based on that, doesn't it make sense to put your savings in Tether instead of the bank? Not quite. While they may seem safe, Tether and other stablecoins are a much riskier place for your money than a bank account. Tether makes no legal guarantee that 1 Tether can be exchanged for $1. Most banks offer FDIC insurance that protects up to $250,000 per account in the event of a bank failure. Tether isn't FDIC-insured, so if the company behind it fails, you'd have no protection. There have also been controversies with Tether and its reserves in the past. Tether Limited used to claim that every Tether was backed by a U.S. dollar, but that turned out to be false. In a recent reserves breakdown, Tether Limited revealed that 2.9% of Tether was backed by cash. https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/cryptocurrency/articles/the-5-biggest-mistakes-you-can-make-when-buying-tether/ https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/cryptocurrency/articles/the-... Also "withdrawals" could mean withdrawals by the Tether company from their own bank accounts to cover redemption requests from Tether customers. "As long as people believe that Tether is fully backed, or that Tether and Bitfinex probes won't impact the price of bitcoin, the game can continue. But if too many people start dumping bitcoin in a panic and rushing toward the fiat exits, the truth - that there isn't enough cash left in the system to support a tsunami of withdrawals - will be revealed, and that would be especially bad news for Tether execs." https://amycastor.com/2021/07/26/the-dojs-criminal-probe-into-tether-what-we-know/ https://amycastor.com/2021/07/26/the-dojs-criminal-probe-int...