9 ms·
Eton and all the murder (2019)
- etothepii 4y agoWhile it may be the case that Mr Higgs comp in North Wales produced no murders it's also the case that no-one is counting.
- osrec 4y agoNot really. If my school produced murderers, we'd definitely know about it. It would be a big deal. Like certain notorious schools in inner city London. There were some crazy nut cases in my comprehensive school in the north of England, but even they seemed to have eventually lived fairly decent lives. Having been to university with a large number of old Etonians, I can tell you with some confidene that a significant proportion of them believe themselves to be above the law.
- fmajid 4y agoAnd sadly that belief is entirely rational and supported by the facts, the British legal system being designed with the overriding concern of protecting the aristocracy and Establishment.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- etothepii 4y agoCan you name any of these notorious schools in inner city London.
- aa-jv 4y agoI have never met an Etonian who wasn't an obnoxious, narcissistic, deprived, cretinous prig. I'd love to meet one but I don't think they escape Eton unless such characteristics are deeply inculcated.
- etothepii 4y agoThis is usually less true of the King's Scholars.
- arsdragonfly 4y ago[dead]
- sirsinsalot 4y agoI can taste the bitter spite of privilege
- Veen 4y agoYes, while some murderers go to Eton, the vast majority go to school somewhere else.
- blitzar 4y ago99.99999% of UK murderers DID NOT go to Eton.
- jefftk 4y agoI doubt there have been 10M UK murderers ever.
- LordDragonfang 4y agoIt's probably on the order of 1M, extrapolating from the current murders/year of somewhere between 500 and 1000
- onetimeusename 4y agoalso, no idea how long it's been around. Eton has existed for centuries. ...bound to be a few murderers
- Archelaos 4y ago> Eton has long had a reputation for producing people who were cruel and damaged. This could be a confusion of correlation and causality.
- tclancy 4y agoI dunno, I went to a "British-style" prep school in the US and it definitely made me a harder person than I ever needed to be. It took me a couple of decades to remove that armor and be able to connect better with people. Weird for me to come across a reference to the "Eton Fainting Game" a day after coming across it described as "The American Dream" in Blindboy's newest episode[0]. I will say the one time it worked for me in school I did have the most vivid . . . dream. [0] https://play.acast.com/s/blindboy/saint-brigid-solvent-buse-and-irish-mythology https://play.acast.com/s/blindboy/saint-brigid-solvent-buse-...
- BucketsMcG 4y agoOh no, it's absolutely by design. It's a factory for producing broken people capable of committing atrocious acts of cruelty for the Empire. Now there is no Empire, they've turned on their own people.
- drcongo 4y agoIf anyone is unaware of John Higgs, he's written several of my all time favourite books, especially his KLF book which I loved so much I bought loads of them to give out to friends. Can't recommend it highly enough: https://johnhiggs.com/books/the-klf/ https://johnhiggs.com/books/the-klf/
- globalise83 4y agoOn a side note, it is worth paying a visit to Eton to see the number of old boys killed serving their country in WW1 and WW2: the walls of the old building are literally lined with their names in the thousands.
- implements 4y agoThe whole area is a beautiful place to visit on a good spring day - and it's a quick and easy train ride from central London via Staines.
- DC-3 4y agoAn interesting example of how the old English class system wasn't just about venal entrenched self-advantage. The upper classes of old really did feel a noblesse oblige, and were killed in the trenches at considerably higher rates in the trenches. Young men of high birth were expected to be officers, and to lead by example - a job that came with a life expectancy measured in days during the darkest hours of the first world war. One doubts if the present bearers of class privilege feel a similar sense of duty.
- kodah 4y agoWith respect to fighting wars? No. The military has a couple stand out statistics, first being that most enlisted are of generational servitude while most officers are from opportunity (college recruitment). That means most people enlisted have a relative that served first. Second is that most enlistments come from the poorer part of the country, specifically the South and Midwest. The diversity of the military largely tracks those geographies. Officers similarly reflect where their volunteer pool comes from. That said, the modern upper echelon of US society have a pretty quiet yet thick disdain for military service. They'd probably never let their kids do it.
- dan-robertson 4y agoI assume things are different in the US. Attitudes to the military certainly seem different today.
- cafard 4y agoEton has been around since before the Reformation, so it has had the time to build up a list of murderers, etc.
- dghf 4y agoSure, but the article gives four examples that took place over the course of thirty years, two of which were within twelve months of each other.
- rsynnott 4y agoEton appears to be a 6 year school with a capacity of 1390. So, at most, 230 at year, so at a murder (or murderer, really) rate of 4/30=0.13 per year, that implies a murder rate of (0.13/230)*100000 = 56 murders per hundred thousand. The UK homicide rate (which includes non-murder homicide) is 1.1 per hundred thousand. 56 per hundred k is higher than _any country on earth_, so this is pretty impressive. (The absolute numbers are small enough that it could all be fluke, of course. Also I have some vague qualms about comparing murderer rate to murder rate, but I think it _mostly_ works, as most murderers only do one).
- jefftk 4y agoThanks for doing the math! Murders have been declining, right? I wonder how much of this is due to comparing historical murders with current murder rates?
- rsynnott 4y agoFor the UK they're declining from a peak in the late 90s, but they were kinda flat before that, and in in any case you're talking about a difference of under 1% either way. There was never a time that the UK's murder rate was anything like 56/100k, at least not in the last century (before the late 19th century, useful stats aren't really available, but some estimates do show _very_ high murder rates in the 19th century).
- giantg2 4y ago
- jinjukn 4y ago[flagged]
- madaxe_again 4y agoIt isn’t just Eton - it’s many or most of the old British public schools. I went to one, and the scars run deep - as does the will to power and the desire to hurt others as I was hurt. It was a brutal environment, a panopticon in which you learned to bend systems and people to your will, in which you learned you had to stab your friend in the back before they did the same to you, as the rules of the game mandate it. Discipline was relentless, and was largely enforced through cooption of pupils. You were not a name, you were a number. The purpose was to churn out colonial administrators, who now have no colonies to go and quietly exercise their depravity out of view. I’ve worked and am continuing to work on healing or soothing some of the wounds inflicted in my time at elite boarding schools - but I can’t say the same for the rest of my cohort, who are now generally busy running the U.K. or burning down rainforest for profit or whatever it is this week.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- defrost 4y agoThe documentary Tomkinson's Schooldays falls short but perhaps come closer than any other.
- blackshaw 4y agoHow old are you? I went to a posh boarding school in the early 2000s and there were many things wrong with it, but it wasn't nearly as brutal as you describe. Other pupils did unpleasant things to me (and I to them) but it was mostly just testosterone-fueled adolescent stupidity that I'm sure happens at less privileged schools too. I imagine things were worse in the past though, see e.g. the notorious practice of "fagging" https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fagging https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fagging
- shubb 4y agoAs I understand it, the Childrens Act of 1989 had a huge effect on how these places were run. It took a while for the law to filter out into practice so people who went to private / boarding / posh state schools in the 90s experienced a gradually toned down version. I suspect that in the early years, when physical punishment was banned, the psychological stuff amped up a bit. Even at a state school in the 90s, some things we thought were normal would be shocking and absolutely a child protection issue these days.
- tgv 4y ago> Of course, you can’t blame the children in all this. They are not born as sociopaths Not all of them no, but a small group is. We are not born tabula rasa. If there's any truth to the idea that leader types have more psycho/sociopathic features, then their children will have them more frequently too.
- Maursault 4y agoThough the terms are used interchangeably, it is currently believed that psychopathy generally comes from genetic factors, such as parts of the brain not developing fully, while sociopathy results from an interruption in personality development by abuse or trauma in childhood. Sociopaths have less consistent behavior than psychopaths. Psychopaths are more controlled and charming. Their manipulation is more detached. They plan ahead. Sociopaths experience anxiety and find rage far harder to control, and they have a harder time assimilating. Inconsistencies between their words and their lives are often easier to detect.
- cowpig 4y agoCan you cite a source? I'm under the impression that both of these terms are considered outdated, in that modern psychology doesn't really think "sociopathy" or "psychopathy" are good abstractions. I'm under the impression that "sociopathy" is kind of used synonymously with antisocial personality disorder but has fallen out of favour because of the pop psychology baggage it carries, and "psychopathy" is mostly used in media/criminal justice tropes.
- Maursault 4y agoThey're both ASPD, that's the clinical term you're looking for, anti-social personality disorder.
- saiya-jin 4y agoI don't think 'antisocial personality disorder' characterizes as typical sociopaths. It is accepted (and often witnessed also by me) that ie higher management layers in corporations are often inhabited by highly functioning sociopaths, they simply have much wider toolset to reach their goals compared to more 'normal' folks, which at one point leave in disgust those continuous battlefields where sociopaths feel at home. Unless nomenclature changed significantly in past decade or so.
- nobodyandproud 4y agoFantastic. Searching around about Eton has lead me to "One of Them: An Eton College Memoir" and https://www.theguardian.com/books/2021/apr/10/musa-okwonga-boys-dont-learn-shamelessness-at-eton-it-is-where-they-perfect-it https://www.theguardian.com/books/2021/apr/10/musa-okwonga-b... .
- isitmadeofglass 4y ago[dead]
- louthy 4y agoJohn Higgs wrote a brilliant book [1] about the band KLF (who famously burned a million pounds). I highly, highly recommend it - even if you know nothing about the band (or care to), it's an incredible read. [1] https://johnhiggs.com/books/the-klf/ https://johnhiggs.com/books/the-klf/
- shadowgovt 4y agoHm... Perhaps a bit off topic, but burning a million pounds is sort of a reverse-inflation move, right? Relatively speaking, it makes everyone else's pound that much more valuable?
- ElevenLathe 4y agoYes but it's probably well within the margin of how much the pound fluctuates in an hour for other reasons.
- me_again 4y agoTheoretically yes, but the amount in circulation is in the billions so it doesn't make an appreciable difference.
- OscarCunningham 4y agoRight, but the Bank of England has a mandate to keep inflation at a particular level. So they'll just print money to cancel you out (or pull some other lever with the same net effect). The BoE's profits go to the government, so in the end you're just paying the government.
- elsjaako 4y agoThere's another book where the KLF discuss burning the money, and that's one of the things mentioned. A lot of people seem angry at them for burning the money instead of giving it to charity. No one would be angry at them for spending it all on something dumb (e.g. a boat), and this way everyone else's money gets worth very slightly more.
- 4y ago
- arsdragonfly 4y ago[dead]
- balsam 4y ago>He beat the nanny, Sandra Rivett, to death with a lead pipe. One wonders if the Etonians of earlier decades were hit as hard by lead poisoning as by a misplaced sense of impunity.
- photochemsyn 4y ago"Lord of the Flies" was inspired by the British 'public' schools system (so called because prior to its creation, the children of British aristocrats were taught by private tutors). It sounds like a real horrorshow: > "Since these schools taught gentlemen not meant to sully their hands with work (perish the thought!), they never learned more practical subjects such as bookkeeping or land management. Those subjects consigned to schools that educated sons of men in trade." > "Disciplinary measures were expected to be harsh, not only as a way to maintain order but to toughen up the boys so they could perfect that famous English stiff upper lip. Punishments were brutal, often resulting in blood being drawn during caning, belting, birching, and whipping." > "Evenings and nights, the boys were left to fend for themselves often under the rule of an older boy put in charge. The boys formed a hierarchy that made the reign of terror look tame, as older boys preyed upon younger boys." https://donnahatch.com/education-and-other-forms-of-child-torture-in-regency-england/ https://donnahatch.com/education-and-other-forms-of-child-to... Apparently these public schools (Eton, Harrow, Winchester, Westminster, Rugby, Charterhouse and Shrewsbury) were intentionally designed to turn out sociopathic narcissists with a penchant for violence and cruelty - who were the kind of people that the system's architects thought were needed to run the British Empire.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 4y agoI don't think it's like this now (probably far more posh), but the public schools were also famously old and decrepit as buildings. They were incredibly drafty, dank, and probably very dark. Orwell (if his account can be trusted) also described them as incredibly filthy. It was an era when the popular idea was that forcing kids to get through awful conditions made them "stronger and better leaders". As you described, it also made them into quite troubled adults. (This is not to mention to abuse both physical and sexual that also went on in the schools.)
- barry-cotter 4y agoOrwell’s account cannot be trusted. > Of his contemporaries, Cecil Beaton wrote of the piece "It is hilariously funny, but it is exaggerated".[22] Connolly, on reviewing Stansky & Abraham's interpretation, wrote "I was at first enchanted as by anything which recalls one's youth but when I went to verify some references from my old reports and letters I was nearly sick... In the case of St Cyprian's and the Wilkes whom I had so blithely mocked I feel an emotional disturbance... The Wilkeses were true friends and I had caricatured their mannerisms (developed as a kind of ritual square-bashing for dealing with generations of boys) and read mercenary motives into much that was just enthusiasm."[32] Walter Christie and Henry Longhurst went further and wrote their own sympathetic accounts of the school in response to Orwell's and voiced their appreciation for the formidable Mrs Wilkes.[33][34] Robert Pearce, researching the papers of another former pupil,[35] made a comprehensive study from the perspective of the school, investigating school records and other pupils' accounts. While some features were universal features of prep school life, he concluded that Orwell's depiction bore little relation to reality and that Orwell's defamatory allegations were unsupportable.[15] Davison writes "If one is looking for a factual account for life at St Cyprian's, this is not the place to seek it."[36] On Orwell's claimed state of misery, Jacintha Buddicom, who knew him well at the time, also raised a strong challenge. She wrote "I can guarantee that the 'I' of "Such, Such were the Joys" is quite unrecognisable as Eric as we knew him then", and "He was a philosophical boy, with varied interests and a sense of humour—which he was inclined to indulge when referring to St Cyprian's in the holidays."[23] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Such,_Such_Were_the_Joys https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Such,_Such_Were_the_Joys
- marcus_holmes 4y agoI went to an English boarding school in the 70's when it was still part of the system that produced officers for the British Empire. Basically, they put you through hell, both institutionally and Lord Of The Flies. Bullying was normal, and vicious, and inescapable (no going home to get away from them). You dealt with it or you persuades your parents to let you leave, or you suicided. In my school of ~400 pupils we had at least one suicide a year, often more. The thinking was that if you survived all this then you would be sufficiently tough (mentally and physically) to be sent to some colonial outpost far away from everyone and everything that you knew, with no help nearby, and not lose your shit. It kinda worked as intended for most people - ex-classmates I've met since are confident and charming. But for those like me, who didn't get on with the system so well, it was years of clinical depression and therapy to heal from it. There's a name for it now: Boarding School Syndrome [0]. It manifests in adulthood as a range of symptoms, but emotional detachment is probably the most prominent. It's not healthy, and realising that almost all of Britain's most prominent politicians suffer from it (and every single British prime minister since Thatcher went to boarding school), it becomes obvious why Britain is such a mess now. [0] https://caldaclinic.com/boarding-school-syndrome-the-childhood-trauma-of-privilege https://caldaclinic.com/boarding-school-syndrome-the-childho...
- gandalfian 4y agoand every single British prime minister since Thatcher went to boarding school Hmm, it doesn't invalidate your overall point but I would guess John Major, Gordon Brown, Teresa May and Liz Truss were probably not at boarding school.
- madaxe_again 4y agoThey weren’t, and in the cases of May and Major, it undid them, as plenty of their ministers and MPs did, and it’s hard for someone who hasn’t been through that particular wringer to understand and therefore work with the mindset. Also, people who went through it will invariably look down at people who did not, as those who did not have no idea what it is to suffer, to stand utterly alone — always — and therefore their judgment cannot be trusted, as it is clouded by softness and emotion.
- reillyse 4y agoThe obvious explanation to my mind for all of the murder and crime is simply that the people who go to Eton are incredibly entitled. They grow up in a society where they are taught that they are entitled to anything and everything they want and when that doesn’t work out for them on the first pass they resort to crime.
- maximilianroos 4y agoI went to Eton 2002-2007, very much enjoyed it, and I think it made be a better person. I was very lucky to attend. There was (surprisingly?) little bullying when I was there. I wasn't in the "cool" group, but still had friends and felt broadly accepted; more so than in my prior boarding school. Any remaining hierarchy between the older and younger boys was in its final days. One anecdote I remember: where I arrived, younger boys would fill up the older boys' water jugs at lunch on request, but when I left that would have seemed very out-of-place. Re the murders: the murder surge was happening as the British class system became less relevant, offered fewer privileges for those without competency, and its status outside the UK was disintegrating. I'd be interested to see whether going to Eton increases your chance of being a murderer relative to just being at that place in the British class system. Do Harrow & Radley have a similarly high rate of murders?
- madaxe_again 4y agoYou entirely missed the party - everything changed around the turn of the millennium.
- krisoft 4y agoAny time I think about Harry Potter now with an adult mind I find the teachers there highly irresponsible. They give young kids superhero like abilities while completely and utterly neglecting their mental health. It is a small wonder that most of them turn out a-okay and there is only a single dark lord going on murderous rampage per generation. If i were running such an institution everyone would learn meditation, mindfullness, and would encourage every student and teacher to attend psychological counseling paid by the school with a therapist of their choice. Maybe real world schools should think along similar lines.
- antipotoad 4y agoIf you start poking, you find those stories have more holes than a fishing net. Best to suspend disbelief. That said, I like your suggestions. There’s altogether too little introspection on what the point of schooling should be. To my mind, better that schools impart the metacognitive skills to be a better learner, a better thinker, a more stable person, than to impart specific knowledge.
- krisoft 4y ago> If you start poking, you find those stories have more holes than a fishing net Not my intention at all. I'm using the story as a jumping off point to reflect on our reality. One sad, unloved wizarding student growing up to be an unstable adult is a personal tragedy. When that young adult decides that his problems are the existence of certain others and drums up supporters and starts killing people on a massive scale. That is a societal tragedy now. Now obviously we don't have wizard lords in our existence. On the other hand we have unstable grown up former victims of Eton. And some might interpret the course of recent British political tragedies as an outward manifestation of their games. Providing a parallel to the story. No poking holes at all.
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoNow, comes the point of reflection. Imagine, for a moment a whole class of politicians, having grown acustomed to bullying out of sight. Running a global trading empire. What do you think they will do relentlessly to there neighbours and upstart competition. Now imagine how this competition might "over" react, when cut off from vital supplies again and again, when driven into endless proxy wars and similar things, just to keep them "down and fighting". This is why there was the german prejudice against the "perfid albion", because well the people who run that empire were deeply twisted and evil. The admiration for similar evil, ala hitler was only natural.