3 ms·
edit: Just because I'm stating this fact, doesn't mean that I endorse it. Please, just because you agree that the world unfortunately is this way, don't downvo
by kristopolous 15y ago
edit: Just because I'm stating this fact, doesn't mean that I endorse it. Please, just because you agree that the world unfortunately is this way, don't downvote me as if I'm the cause of the current state of affairs. I'm not old enough or powerful enough to be so.
Is the author a constitutional lawyer? Because if not, I really can't trust any of this.
The reason that constitutional lawyers exist is because this short document is deceptively sophisticated and every interpretation of every stanza has seen its day in court almost every generation since its authorship.
Just reading something and assuming that the legal ramifications are clear and apparent without knowing the extensive history of the actual legal ramifications belongs more in the world of political opinion than anything remotely approximate to legal standing.
It's almost as if a corpus of court proceedings a 100 meters long should be affixed to every word in order to gain an appreciation for what is legally pursuant via the constitution.
- baddox 15y agoI'm not sure I can agree with everything you're saying. Was the Constitution written with the expectation that later generations would consider it "deceptively sophisticated" and that only "constitutional lawyers" should be able to make sense of it? Was it purposefully written so that later constitutional lawyers could interpret it in new ways that seem counter-intuitive to everyone else? I don't think so.
- zachrose 15y agoI do.
- kristopolous 15y agoOf course not. But that's what's happened. And as a result, the barrier to entry in knowing the true meaning is now quite high. I'm not placing a vote of approval of this reality; just stating that it exists. It aggravates me too.
- baddox 15y agoThen where did the supposed complexity come from?
- burgerbrain 15y agoWhat does the US constitution have to do with fundamental rights?
- kristopolous 15y agoWhat's a fundamental right, who protects it, and is there any document that enumerates said rights so that parties don't disagree?
- burgerbrain 15y agoIf find yourself wanting for a piece of paper to enumerate your rights for you (I know I certainly do not), you can do a hell of a lot better than the US constitution. That document is primarily just a set of rules for a government, not a declaration of rights. For starters, check out the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. It is an easy read and meant for all people, not just those who happen to reside in a specific geographic area. My rule of thumb though? If you think a piece of paper is something that grants you a right, then it's clearly not a fundamental right.
- kristopolous 15y agosee federalist papers number 51 and 10 to see the thoughts on the constitution and human rights. Items covered include civil rights, religious freedoms, minority rights, the tyranny of the majority, balancing the power of conflicting classifications of rights, etc ...
- tomjen3 15y agoI would love to read those papers, but there is no way I can -- the language is simply too complex and they use too many 'old' words. Do you know any good collection of them with footnotes and explanations?
- kristopolous 15y agoI actually don't find them difficult but mostly because I've read a lot of stuff from the era. It's kind of like Shakespeare, it's hard initially but then you get in the swing of things. There's also plenty of civics style booklets with explanations.
- lisper 15y agoNo, I am not a lawyer. The idea that only lawyers can be qualified to comment on the law is myth promulgated by lawyers. There is a reason that the first three words of the Constitution are "We the People" and not "We the Lawyers."
- kristopolous 15y agoah, it was "We the [non-native][male][land-owning][non-enslaved] people [between specific longitude and latitudinal points][that aren't corporations, at least, for another hundred years][unless you are a slave owner, in which case multiply your the number of slaves you own by 0.6 and then add it to you (aka, +1)]". We have been actively struggling and expanding just that alone for generations now.
- kbutler 15y agoThe interesting thing about using court rulings to interpret the law is that legal precedent is only created when some lawyer is on the wrong side of a case... [Yes, that's a slight oversimplification.]