IMHO, neural-net AIs are sensors; they're great at surfacing things that are going on in the training data. I would speculate that ChatGPT is labeling these thi

IMHO, neural-net AIs are sensors; they're great at surfacing things that are going on in the training data. I would speculate that ChatGPT is labeling these things are differently harmful because they are differently harmful. It's a sensor, like a thermometer; albeit a very complex one. (And, like any sensor, has nuances from implementation and metric-definition: mercury thermometers & barometric pressure, wet bulb / dry bulb, etc) > Why can we not consider all groups equal? Because they aren't. (If that's a thing you find debatable, LMK!) Attempting to consider them all equal runs into problems just like you'd run into problems trying to consider all pumps at the gas station (including diesel) equal; even if, for sake of the metaphor, all the prices were equal. > why should the results be mapped against statistics I'm not sure that's answerable outside of a specific context. Personally, I think we should because it's fascinating and, I would expect, a really informative way to explore in more detail. Culturally, it's because you get better communities when you do things like give the high-accessibility seat on the train to the person with broken leg; aka, go out of your way to treat harmed people with more care. If your question is about the inverse, something like "why should language that's harmful against one group by OK when used against a group that doesn't experience it harmfully", I dunno what to say. I feel like the question kinda answers itself; sort of a "ain't broke don't fix". Or maybe your question is more: "why does this disagree with [me] about what's harmful to [me]", I dunno. Maybe the training data didn't include (enough) for the AI-as-sensor to detect that, maybe that data doesn't exist, maybe (and very cynically) that data doesn't actually point to that "conclusion" when run through the AI. Kinda like how the first time many people experience delayed-onset-muscle-soreness they think it's "I'm hurt"-pain.