2 ms·
My definition of success is group identity become decoupled from economic deprivation. Vietnamese went from being one of the poorest groups in the country in th
by rayiner 4y ago
My definition of success is group identity become decoupled from economic deprivation. Vietnamese went from being one of the poorest groups in the country in the 1980 census to having median incomes comparable to whites.
Obviously I'm not denying that political participation never works. But Obamacare or child labor laws are society-wide improvements. I'm talking specifically about disadvantaged groups organizing as a way out of their disadvantaged predicament. On that front, organizing has had limited success. For example, you mention eliminating de jure segregation, which was obviously great. But black-white income gaps are pretty much the same today as in 1965.
- tptacek 4y agoThis argument only makes sense if you ignore the status quo ante of the civil rights movement, or of the labor movement. Which is the one sentence response I should have written originally.
- rayiner 4y agoThe civil rights movement was obviously important for black Americans. But it also arose from, and in response to, economic and historical circumstances specific to them. De jure segregation didn’t arise out of ordinary racism or xenophobia. It arose out of an effort to resist the integration of a formerly enslaved minority. It has only incidental relevance to minorities of immigrant origin. Countries like Canada that never had slavery or segregation or an organized civil rights movement ended up in the same place as america with respect to Chinese or Vietnamese immigrants.
- tptacek 4y agoSure, but that's not the argument you made. If all you're arguing is that some organizing efforts are more important than others, that's a banal truism.