8 ms·
St. John’s Reading List: A Great Books Curriculum
- jrdunson 4y agoMortimer J. Adler mentions in his books... that at Saint John’s, the students were learning how to read well, and analyze arguments well. At one point in his career, he did a speaking tour, presenting at several college campuses – he was really impressed how the students from St. John's were able to analyze his arguments well, ask in-depth questions related to his material, even challenge him on some points. He has two really good books… * How to Read a Book and How To Speak How To Listen.
- Balgair 4y agoI'll add The Syntopicon as a really good book that Adler wrote (kinda). 1. It's 2 volumes, so not just one book 2. He wrote it with the help of 11 others 3. It's more of a reference manual than a book 4. It's keyed to 58 other books All the same, The Syntopicon, I feel, is up there with the first Dictionary or Encyclopedia. A titanic effort that helps synthesize the world into a manageable tome. Getting and being able to use a copy is honestly difficult. But, dear Reader, worth it at any price. The depth and breadth is amazing and the way he links his 'great ideas' makes traversing the entire history of western thought easy, especially with modern tools. It's obviously Adler's magnum opus and it shows. If you'd like to grab a copy, let me know.
- gorgonical 4y agoI'd be interested in a copy. How can I reach you?
- Balgair 4y agoHey gorgonical. Do you have an email that I can contact you with?
- gorgonical 4y agoSure. gorgonical@fastmail.com.
- leemck 4y agoI went to SJC Santa Fe in '65-'68. About fiften years ago I was reading child development books. I discovered this wonderful thinker Jean Piaget. I think Piaget's first book translated into English caused a great deal of excitement, especially at the University of Chicago. Piaget's book "The Language and thought of the Child" I conjecture was the inspiration for organizing a school around a great books list and also for teaching mathematics by the demonstration and discussion method. At St. John's the freshman math tutorial meant each student stood up, drew a triangle, lettered the corners, and recited the proof and discussed and explored the ideas and assumptions. For myself at St. John's the great books seminar became a very slow process of analyzing and trying to restate writings. By the end of the Junior year, my final academic review called a Don Rag I can say It Did Not Go Well ("what happened Lee?"). Regarding the math side of things, a few years later I got a technician job at Cal Tech and I was allowed to enroll in Cal Tech a calculus class. By November I was dreaming of flying, I swooped on updrafts of assumptions and bold substitutions and clever identities. I couldn't solve the winter mid term exam problem but to this day I am grateful that I saw and did the two extremes of math. These days, I don't do much Calculus, but I do and think about knot theory and coiling. I keep stumbling across pi/2 as I coil or fold air hoses or ropes. Why must three utility pipes connecting to three houses cross? Why are the computer wires always a tangle"? Regarding the Great Books, I recommend the Meno and then the Socratic big 5. These books are still a source of puzzlement to me. A final question: What happens in the brain when a student stands up and does a proof at the black board? Why do opera singers stand up to sing? Why is standing up to walk a neurological milestone in the development of the child?
- transfire 4y agoHighly recommend this school.
- sys32768 4y agoTried to get my oldest to go here. She reads super fast with high comprehension and loves to debate, but she's so terrified of going into debt that she's now in a state college taking computer science and saying Chat GPT is way more helpful than her professor for understanding or fixing code.
- wyclif 4y agoShe should check out Phind if she hasn't already: https://phind.com/ https://phind.com/
- transfire 4y agoYes, the cost is unfortunate. They do have grants and scholarships that can save a few thousand per semester, but that’s still not enough if you don’t have at least some college funds set aside.
- jdmoreira 4y agoSmart kid. I would even skip the whole state college thing as soon as she can be dangerous enough to get a job.
- yamtaddle 4y agoIf it's cheap enough, the paper's worth it just to never worry about having to explain your lacking a degree. Even if you rarely actually have to, it's always in the back of your mind. A potential question that you'll need to be ready to reframe positively, plus that constant worry that you're receiving extra scrutiny, just... go away completely. It'll also be very handy if one ever wishes to leave the US—most countries one might want to live and work in will be much more likely to let you in with a degree, and especially a CS degree. I went back and finished mine. Removing that stressor from interviews was worth it, even if that was basically the only benefit, which it was—nearly all the benefits I can point to from college came from the humanities degree I nearly finished, years before completing the CS degree. For the CS degree, perhaps two or three hours worth of instruction or material have proven either useful or edifying since. But, I'm glad to have the paper.
- adamsmith143 4y agoHave always been fascinated by this school, had a hankering to do to their Graduate program which is a shortened version of their undergrad Curriculum.
- codybontecou 4y agoHuh, this is neat. If you click on a book's subject(s), it will then take you to the specific topic and a reading list tailored to it. For example, this is their Mathematics reading list: https://www.sjc.edu/academic-programs/undergraduate/subjects/mathematics https://www.sjc.edu/academic-programs/undergraduate/subjects....
- tgv 4y agoExcept that list is ... eclectic, to put it politely. If you want to learn maths, I wouldn't recommend Aristotle, Descartes and Darwin. Perhaps I don't understand what "The information presented is for illustration purposes only and may not reflect the current reading list" means, and why one would link that page anyway.
- ticviking 4y agoThe Great Books approach involves reading the actual historical development of a subject and seeing not only what the state of the art is but how we got from here to there.
- spekcular 4y agoI believe the person you're replying to understands that. The claim is that this approach is really bad way to learn math. As someone who has learned and taught a lot of math, I agree with that claim.
- viscanti 4y agoIt appears to be a liberal arts program. Is this substantially different, with respect to the rigor of mathematics, than most other comparable programs? They might cover more calculus (maybe at a theoretical level?) than most liberal arts programs.
- spekcular 4y agoYes, it is substantially different with respect to content than standard undergraduate mathematics programs. It covers a few historically important texts and does not teach (if those texts are any indication) most of what is usually taught in an undergraduate math degree. (A poster above writes: "Freshman math was almost entirely the study of Euclid and Nicomachus.")
- Sevii 4y agoHad a great experience at St. John's. Unfortunately, transferred to a state engineering school due to financial reasons.
- mistrial9 4y agoI have read many of these works listed. I don't like this database-looking list format; too many books there. Some of them are quite challenging. Freshman Reading: Homer - Illyad, Odyssey ... ok! if you read the Odyssey in your own native language (not greek), you probably will enjoy it, but how are you going to know about the grand themes unless someone tells you about it? seems sad in a way that these great works are reduced to a list item
- BeFlatXIII 4y ago> how are you going to know about the grand themes unless someone tells you about it? For that matter, St. John’s students self-select to be the kind of students who would appreciate being guided to discover the major themes. Most other students need to be told them and then think themes are pretentious puffery because they lack the life experience to recognize or appreciate them.
- karaterobot 4y ago> Freshman Reading: Homer - Illyad, Odyssey ... ok! if you read the Odyssey in your own native language (not greek), you probably will enjoy it, but how are you going to know about the grand themes unless someone tells you about it? Isn't there a class instruction, supplementary reading, and discussion component for these books? I assume so. But I think a lot of people — even freshmen! — could just read these books and get something from them anyway.
- skottk 4y agoTalking about them in a small class of people who read the same thing at the same time, led by 1 or 2 professors who are practiced in _not_ acting like more than advanced students, is _really_ different from just reading the book. I'd read _Pride and Prejudice_ many times before the seminar on it, and I could not have predicted what other people saw in the book and wanted to talk about with a pile of postit notes, a ball of red yarn, and ten hours in front of a big wall.
- rebolyte 4y ago> how are you going to know about the grand themes unless someone tells you about it? SJC grad here. The Program encourages you to encounter the works for yourself and see what _you_ think the themes/ideas are. You’re lightly discouraged from reading the translator’s preface, since they share their own opinions. Different students bring different translations of the material, and additionally the language class that lasts all 4 years of undergrad is basically asking what translation is, is it possible.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- uncletaco 4y agoI stayed at St. John's one summer and I remember they had a "final" where they had to solve geometric problems by actually drawing the proofs on a chalk board, shapes and all. I watched that girl go through the whole process while studying and I was fascinated.
- skottk 4y agoThat's what you do literally every day in math - take turns going to the board and working through proofs. Ptolemy is Waterloo for anyone who has trouble drawing big circles.
- adamgordonbell 4y agoIt seems like this kind of program was popular in Canada at some point. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Books_programs_in_Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Books_programs_in_Canada
- wk_end 4y agoA former partner of mine was a St. John's alum (and champion), so I heard a lot about and thought a lot about their undergraduate program. Of course this is a wonderful list of brilliant works. I don't know if reading nothing but primary sources is the most efficient way to become a critical thinker or knowledgeable (e.g. reading Euclid might be a treat for those who know geometry, but is it the ideal way to learn geometry?), but it certainly sounds like a great way to become cultured and a great way to spend four years, given the chance. My feeling was also that such a heavy emphasis on classical (Western!) thought and works does its students a bit of a disservice. This is a little dramatic, but I'd say a very serious view in the postmodern, post-WWII academy is that the culmination of 3000 years of Western culture, in the country that was considered by many to be at the height of Western civilization, turned out to be the Holocaust, and that so deeply fetishizing "the canon" is problematic for that reason and others. Without dismissing the greatness of anything on this list, it's unfortunate that it's not until the third or fourth years that you start to see stuff from outside the European tradition, in very limited numbers, often just as electives. There seems to be a decent selection of works reckoning with American slavery, which is good, but if I recall and AFAICT not much about European colonialism, the Holocaust, CIA-backed coups in South America, the horrors of Stalinism, rising Asian powers, the postmodern condition, any post-sexual revolution gender politics...a robust knowledge of the Greeks is all well and good, but I don't know if that's enough to be a well-rounded citizen of the world, these days.
- tgv 4y ago> a very serious view in the postmodern, post-WWII academy is That's just a load of edgy nonsense to get attention. Unfortunately, it seems to have worked.
- daseiner1 4y agoWhich part, exactly, is “””edgy”””?
- tgv 4y agoDo I really need to spell it out? Or do you consider it all equally edgy? The obvious candidate is "the culmination of 3000 years of Western culture [is] the Holocaust". Although, I must admit, the weird mixture of other points also makes good candidates. E.g., the relation between education and "CIA-backed coups in South America" is one which seems to spring from a conspiracy theory. And, it completely ignores the achievements of "Western thought", as well as the barbaric actions that have taken place elsewhere, from Turkey to Japan, while simultaneously suggesting their thinkers should be read.
- amykhar 4y agoI love this. Of course I'm reminded of Good Will Hunting and want to break out my library card and get this expensive education on a budget.
- Balgair 4y agoI think all of books on the list is on archive.org Fun part of archinve.org is that they have a lot of copies of these books. I remember reading a copy of Rhetoric by Aristotle and it had a lot of marginalia. Turns out that it was a scan of John Adam's personal copy. It was pretty cool to read the thoughts and underlines of a founding father on such a foundational work.
- skottk 4y agoClass of '87 here. Most valuable takeaway is that you can read almost _anything_ directly or in translation. You don't need to read a summary of Hegel, you can read Hegel. You don't need to read an article about a Supreme Court case like Marbury v. Madison, you can read the case itself. When you go into technology, you're then willing to dive into the guts of the actual docs instead of waiting for a book or blog post about it. Another way it prepares you for tech-- understanding philosophy is the skill of drawing incredibly fine distinctions between things. Designing software is also the skill of drawing incredibly fine distinctions between things. Having years of experience in arguing these incredibly fine distinctions was a huge leg up fr me when I was getting started, and remains useful to this day. I think that the careers of my graduating class are primarily in software, law, academia, and medicine. Funny things about it - there are a lot of places where your undergrad experience just doesn't overlap with that of people who didn't go there. Everyone studies the same thing at SJC, so if I meet a Johnny who went there years after me or years before, I can tell them what I did for my senior thesis and they'll have a similar reaction - why the hell did you do that? It's also _extremely_ small, so if they went there during the same years I did, I almost certainly know them. The original-works thing works gangbusters on philosophy, science, and literature, and breaks down a little in math. You spend a frustrating amount of time doing Ptolemaic astronomy, because it's an excellent classical treatment of trigonometry. You study Newton for calculus, but you don't actually learn anything that the modern world thinks of as calculus from Newton, so you study supplemental materials that teach you derivatives and integrals over algebraic expressions. It's culturally pretty liberal on the inside, although it's bizarrely worshipped by some right-wingers who didn't go there because of the curriculum's focus on works from the European tradition.
- yamtaddle 4y ago> Most valuable takeaway is that you can read almost _anything_ directly or in translation. You don't need to read a summary of Hegel, you can read Hegel. You don't need to read an article about a Supreme Court case like Marbury v. Madison, you can read the case itself. I think what's under-appreciated is that, a fair amount of the time, for these sorts of enduring classics, reading the original is both better and easier than reading later takes on the same material. If you read the later derivative works and go back, often you'll find they've misinterpreted certain parts in strange ways, or left out things that seem important, and the original is not-uncommonly also both an easier and more entertaining read.
- aug_aug 4y agoI look at this list, especially the "Freshman" list, and feel like public school really let me down, lol.
- dinkleberg 4y agoSame. If I could do it over again, I’d much rather go through a program like this than the engineering program I went through. Nothing I learned is relevant to world of software (even the software classes I took lol). I’ve had to go through all the classical liberal arts education knowledge through my own independent study.
- Animats 4y agoIt's an interesting approach. They do like the classic sources. I've at least skimmed more than half of those titles, long after college. It's amusing that they have students read Pikkety's "Capital" before Marx's "Capital". You don't want to learn geometry from Euclid. You read Euclid after you already know geometry, to see how he built it up. Similarly, you don't want to learn calculus from Newton. Or physics from Aristotle. What you're seeing there is people trying to figure something out before the tools for the job were developed. There are great papers in engineering, where a theoretical advance changed the world. They're not well known. These should be as well known as the "Great Books". * Maxwell's paper "On Governors". In a few pages, he invents feedback control theory. People were building steam engine governors but didn't understand stability and lag. It's a milestone in that it's one of the first times abstract math met practical engineering and the result worked. * Shannon's discovery that telephone toll switches could be reduced from needing O(N^2) relays to O(N log N) was one. Suddenly, combinatorics went from a useless abstraction to a huge financial win for AT&T. * "Rational Psychrometric Formulae", by Willis Carrier. Least click-bait title ever. Basis of air conditioning. It's how you make an air conditioner and control both temperature and humidity at the cold end, rather than getting cold, humid air out. * Von Neumann's Report on the EDVAC. That's better known. It's how to make a CPU. He got all the basic architecture right, except for index registers.
- dwighttk 4y agoI graduated before Piketty wrote Capital, but that sounded weird so I looked. All the "Elective Work(s)" at the bottom of Junior and Senior years are part of the Junior/Senior elective preceptorials which not every student reads and that list changes every year. The Program definitely doesn't have you read Piketty before Marx.
- thwayunion 4y agoThose are excellent suggestions. I think we are probably at the point where you could do a Great Books curriculum in Computer Science. Would be interesting to put together that list: 10-20 foundational primary texts in Algorithms, Programming/Software Engineering, Logic, AI, and Computer Architecture. But, as you note, it'd probably be a terrible way to actually learn how to engineer software. More intellectually satisfying, though :) > It's amusing that they have students read Pikkety's "Capital" before Marx's "Capital". I get why it's amusing, but it also makes sense. Marx's "Capital" is kind of a beast. Pikkety's is written more-or-less toward a modern general audience. If I were sequencing these books in a student's intellectual development, Pikkety definitely comes before Marx.
- swhalen 4y agoDo they genuinely expect someone in their third year of undergraduate study to read and even partially understand Newton's Principia Mathematica? It is famously unintelligible to modern readers, even those with knowledge of physics.
- mistercheph 4y agoAs can be detected by the disdain that other commenters have shown towards even the suggestion that someone might read the Principia Mathematica as opposed to a more modern treatment of the same subject, it is a lack of interest more than a lack of capacity that makes it unintelligible for modern readers. It is utterly comprehensible to any reader who has time, paper and pencil, and a copy of Euclid.
- dabiged 4y agoNot an alum, but in an effort to improve my written and spoken english, I picked up the list and read the about 80% of the content. I was kind to myself and skipped any book that I absolutely found a slog (there were only a few, Aristotle's metaphysics and some early of the dark age Christian philosophy). The book list is really good at telling you to skip the really irrelevant bits of ancient books. I found that reading so much ancient literature: 1. It ruined a lot of popular Hollywood movies for me as a lot of the modern stories are retellings of very old ones. 2. I finally got a whole lot of cultural references in modern literature that I missed previously. Many modern authors will name a character in a text as a callback to some old story (rocinante in 'the expanse' comes to mind). 3. I thought reading so much content would improve my reading speed, but since most of what i read was in weird greek prose, conversational aristotlean, iambic pentameter, or ye ole english it really didn't.
- stbullard 4y agoRE 3: as an SJC alum, I found my reading speed slowed drastically both during and after four years spent reading and discussing these books. I found myself thinking while reading more often, making more connections within and between works. That said, reading alone misses the meat of “The Program” (always capitalized!) - it’s the searching, pointed, urgent discussion of a work with others who share a common language (from all having read and discussed the earlier works in the Program) that provoked deep thought and reflection, held me to account for intellectual rigor, and built up my faculty for critical thinking.
- dabiged 4y agoIt was extremely disappointing to finish a book which truly altered the way you saw the world, and not have a cohort of people to share it with.
- voisin 4y ago> That said, reading alone misses the meat of “The Program” (always capitalized!) - it’s the searching, pointed, urgent discussion of a work with others who share a common language (from all having read and discussed the earlier works in the Program) that provoked deep thought and reflection, held me to account for intellectual rigor, and built up my faculty for critical thinking. Is there anywhere online that achieves anything close to this for this curriculum for people who can’t attend full time in person? An HN for SJC curriculum?
- garrisonj 4y agoI wanted to find the list without the fancy styling and found this: https://fs.blog/great-books/ https://fs.blog/great-books/ Much easier to copy and paste.
- briga 4y agoWhile this is a good list of books, I find it hard to believe that a curriculum could cover them in any sort of detail. Imagine trying to cover Proust or Dante or Gibbon in the week or so you have until moving on to the next book. A little absurd
- Balgair 4y agoPer what I have heard from graduates, they agree that the pace is fast, but that you get used to it.
- zozbot234 4y agoI'm all for learning more about the historical roots and overall development of Western culture, but one should keep in mind that the sheer amount of notable works that have been described as "classics" and "Great Books" is absolutely humongous; this list is of course highly selective and will necessarily be missing a lot of interesting stuff. In general, most people will probably want to focus on the narrower subtopics that specifically draw their interest, and perhaps explore the interconnections among works in that area.
- earthboundkid 4y agoOkay but they’ll never beat Navy at ultimate frisbee.
- QuarterReptile 4y agoCroquet? Edit: I take it back. Apparently Navy is in the habit of losing the croquet match.
- wyclif 4y agoThe reason Johnnies always win the croquet match is because they practice. I'm not sure if Navy cadets have time to do that.
- lakeshastina 4y agoWas a little disappointed to see so little from the east in terms of recommended books. The Bhagavad Gita and ZhuangXi made the list, but nothing in terms of other important works by the Buddha, or Yoga or the epics like the Mahabharata. If someone were to read some of the Upanishadic works, it would be really interesting to see their influence on the works of Plotinus, etc.
- stbullard 4y agoThe College offers a Master’s degree in Eastern Classics, applying the same approach to a literary tradition which, while it intersects with and interacts with the Western tradition, easily also stands on its own: https://www.sjc.edu/academic-programs/graduate/masters-eastern-classics/reading-lists https://www.sjc.edu/academic-programs/graduate/masters-easte... The monolithic, slow-to-change Great Books list that forms the core of the St John’s undergraduate Reading List is famously and self-consciously concerned primarily and narrowly with the Western intellectual tradition that informed the Founding Fathers, etc. - so as, in the creators’ thinking, to prepare graduates for citizenship in a liberal democracy. It’s likely no one is more critical of the List than the students and faculty, who argue constantly over omissions, additions, and alterations (there is barely enough time to read all the works on the Program, so for each added, one must often be taken out). The historical context of the creation of the Reading List accounts for its significant bias towards dead white cis men, as the creators of the list were themselves white cis men at a time when the American education system was not integrated. (You may be pleased to hear that, for at least the last several decades, the college has admitted people of all colors and genders!)
- lakeshastina 4y agoYes, makes sense. It just struck me that someone who graduates from such a learning list might totally miss that eastern thought heavily influenced the Greek philosophers and the practice of Gnosis, derived from the Sanskrit root word Gnana(Knowledge or wisdom). When investigated down to the fundamentals, it is liberating to realize all the deep enquirers of all regions of the world arrived at many of the same insights regarding life. This hopefully leads to more unity, tolerance and mutual respect between people and different religions.
- WillAdams 4y agoA co-worker's son visited St. John's, since it was one he was considering, and it was sufficiently interesting that he mentioned it when we were discussing education in general. I looked up the reading list, and have been reading the texts, trying to patch up my rather spotty education --- it also makes me wonder how many of these texts would have been a part of Edmund Dante's (from _The Count of Monte Cristo_) education: https://www.goodreads.com/review/list/21394355-william-adams?ref=nav_mybooks&shelf=abb%C3%A9-faria-s-books https://www.goodreads.com/review/list/21394355-william-adams... I wish that there was better accessibility of the texts --- a lot of them are not on Librivox, and not all are on Project Gutenberg either. One notable example of technology aiding accessibility of a text though is "Joyce's Java version" of Euclid's _Elements_: https://mathcs.clarku.edu/~djoyce/java/elements/elements.html https://mathcs.clarku.edu/~djoyce/java/elements/elements.htm... and one can't help but wonder what other texts could be better presented using modern technology.
- wyclif 4y agoTry Internet Archive or Google Books. I think most of them can be found there, though maybe not in the corresponding editions.
- troupe 4y agoYou might also like this version of Elements: https://www.c82.net/euclid/ https://www.c82.net/euclid/ As far as finding books, places that sell used books often have these types of books for very inexpensive.
- WillAdams 4y agoNice! Looking forward to reading this. It would be great to have a list of such books/topics which have been re-presented in improved versions. The wonderful physics text: https://www.motionmountain.net/ https://www.motionmountain.net/ is an excellent example of this. A more prosaic example is this presentation as PDFs of Bertrand Russell's _The Principles of Mathematics_: https://people.umass.edu/klement/pom/ https://people.umass.edu/klement/pom/
- rahimnathwani 4y ago
- Glyptodon 4y agoBrother of an acquaintance was going there when I was thinking about college (Santa Fe campus). Before talking to him, I was pretty interested. After, I kind of had the impression there was more weed than reading and didn't apply. (No idea if it was just his circle really. And don't take as huge opinion on weed, even second hand the smoke can get to my nose pretty badly.)
- freework 4y agoI live in Santa Fe, and have gone by this campus many times since theres a pretty cool bike trail that runs behind the campus. I got curious once and looked up what it's like to study there and discovered the "great books" curriculum. These days I'm in my 40s and have a successful computer science career, so there is nothing to gain from enrolling in this program, but if I were to ever enroll in school again, it would probably be this program or one like it. When I was in school, what I really hated most about it was how common it was for professors to make the class about them. In a program like St. Johns, the curriculum is set in stone, and so there is very little room for the professor to inject himself into the class. When I was in undergrad in the early 2000s, if you disagreed with the professor, you'd be seen as being disrespectful or disruptive and your grade would suffer. I have a feeling that wouldn't be a problem at St. Johns.
- manesioz 4y agoRemarkably missing many works of Christian theology... No St. Augustine, Aquinas, St. John of Chrysostom, Calvin, etc.
- wyclif 4y agoYes, it's missing crucial works like Cur Deus Homo and On the Incarnation by St Athanasius as well as some of the ones you mention, but I think some of those are in the curriculum if you look a little harder. One needn't be a Christian to benefit from such works; they are foundational to Western civilisation.
- a_techwriter_00 4y agoConfessions is on the program Sophomore year, as are excerpts from Summa Theologica. I vaguely remember one of the differences between the campuses being that Annapolis students read some Calvin and Santa Fe students read something else, but I don't remember what it was.
- bandrami 4y agoAugustine, Aquinas, and Anselm are all on the list. Most of Sophomore year is spent reading late antique and medieval Christian writings.
- dhosek 4y agoIt’s a bit better than I expected although it does seem odd that everything in the first two years is very Eurocentric. It’s only in the third year are students exposed to anything by Asian authors (and there’s some cheating there in that the Dao de jing is listed twice—no, wait, three times!) and those are all under the category of elective works. I’m frankly unconvinced of the value of reading historical works of science or mathematics, especially those written before modern notation came into usage—without additional explicatory apparatus, the text would be exceptionally opaque.
- yinser 4y agoExtraordinary.