3 ms·
I think it's fine to acknowledge that luck plays a role in life, but unless you think there's a way to trade your time and life force in a direct effort to beco
by sokoloff 4y ago
I think it's fine to acknowledge that luck plays a role in life, but unless you think there's a way to trade your time and life force in a direct effort to become more lucky, it's not particularly practical as a way to guide your actions.
That is, unless you take something like the view of "I am a great believer in luck, and I find the harder I work, the more I have of it."
My spouse and I work hard to ensure that our family has that kind of luck. That our kids get a safe, stable, secure home, nutritious food, adequate exercise, exposure to a variety of novel (to them) experiences. We copiously support and nurture their educational efforts. We display love and tolerance for each other, but also demonstrate and uphold high standards in areas that we think matter. We spend less than our means and save for our family's future and invest for our retirement and their current and future education.
Given all that, maybe our kids are just plain lucky after all and luck is responsible for everything that they'll ever do. I can't stop you from believing that, but I don't and we don't live our lives as if it were true.
- yogthos 4y agoIt seems to me that people are completely missing the point of the article here. The point it's making that if luck is a dominant factor in success, then being poor isn't a personal flaw. People aren't poor because they're lazy or don't have ambition, it's because they got dealt a shitty hand in life. Once this basic fact is recognized, then it necessarily dictates that we should structure a society in a way where everyone has access to the necessities of life. Things like food, healthcare, education, and housing should be universal rights that are guaranteed for everyone.
- sokoloff 4y agoI tend to agree that a basic (non-luxury, sustenance-level) of those should be provided via taxation and government wealth transfers. I have no problem if Bezos or Musk eat better food, live in a better house, can pay for elite education, or have access to better/more comprehensive medical care than I do.
- yogthos 4y agoThing is that people like Musk and Bezos derive their opulence from exploitation of people who have to sell labour to live. The fortune Bezos amassed is created through labour of people his enterprise employs. People piss in bottles working in Amazon warehouses so that Bezos can eat better food, live in a better house, pay for elite education, and have access to better/more comprehensive medical care. The reason this is the case is because people like Bezos own the means of production and ensure that labour and resources are directed towards their benefit first and foremost. These people simply won the birth lottery and now they get to rule over the rest of the people because of that. If you don't see that as a problem then I really don't know what to tell you.
- sokoloff 4y agoThat's why providing people with a baseline of government dormitories, government rice, cheese, and beans, government medical care, and government education is critical to prevent the worst of the possible exploitations. Once that baseline is guaranteed, it's a much cleaner argument that Joe freely decided to work in a job moving heavy things around because he valued having a more pleasurable existence, rather than saying it was because he didn't want to slowly starve to death. No one wants to wake up at 4 AM and farm the land, to clean other people's shit out of a septic tank, or to wipe an incontinent 90 year old's ass. But all of those things need to be done and if we look at the history various economic systems, it seems like there's a lot to be gained in societal wealth, comfort, and advancement from one particular flavor over the others that we've tried. Giving everyone a safety net I believe is good and prevents exploitation. Giving everyone a hammock I believe is bad and prevents societal advancement.
- yogthos 4y agoSure, providing universal basic services is a good start. However, the bigger question is what basis is there for private ownership of the means of production. Seems to me that a much fairer system would be to have a mix of cooperative and state ownership. The state could own all the essential industry that's required to provide the basic services such as food, healthcare, education, housing, and so on. Meanwhile, any nice to have things could be produced by cooperatively owned companies that compete on the market. Cooperative ownership would ensure that the profits are fairly distributed amongst the workers avoiding the problem with wealth accumulation. This model has been shown to work very successfully at scale already. A couple of great examples to look at are Mondragon and Huwawei. These are huge companies that employ thousands of people and have excellent track record of profitability and resilience. https://www.mondragon-corporation.com/en/about-us/ https://www.mondragon-corporation.com/en/about-us/ https://www.huawei.com/en/facts/question-answer/who-owns-huawei https://www.huawei.com/en/facts/question-answer/who-owns-hua...