4 ms·
The US constitution can be changed, which is why it's the second "amendment" rather than the second "article" or the second "clause".
by ben_w 4y ago
The US constitution can be changed, which is why it's the second "amendment" rather than the second "article" or the second "clause".
- dahfizz 4y agoAnd yet it hasn't. The fact that the second amendment could be removed, but hasn't, is what gives it it's legitimacy.
- ben_w 4y agoThe broader argument, as I understand it, is: 1. The 2A happened 2. Substantial gun industry developed 3. Tech changed, people increasingly concerned 4. Gun industry now big enough to lobby against any changes to the 2A Thus, #4 causes the lack of removal of the 2A. Does it have democratic legitimacy? Probably, but no more so than the 18th had. Does that contradict "(the preference of the USA is that it is) better having our children killed in school than allowing firearms producers to lose one dollar"? Not at all.
- dahfizz 4y agoThe NRA has 5 million members. Nearly half of American households have a gun. You can't just waive this off as "muh lobbying". Americans like their guns. Gun owners don't care if sig sauer loses a buck. They care about their cool toys.
- ben_w 4y agoSize tells you very little. 5 million is bigger by headcount than Big Tech, while half the households is smaller. Big tech lobbies for what serves its interests. NRA lobbies likewise. So does Stonewall, effecting change with fewer members and fewer interested parties. When it comes to guns, what makes the USA different from the rest of the world? Tradition ("we've always had the 2nd A so it must be good") and lobbying ("nothing can prevent this" says only nation on earth where this regularly happens).
- dahfizz 4y agoIn the context of democracy, size is everything. Like, by definition. If the majority of Americans want guns, then you're never going to get a super-majority to vote to take guns away. > Big tech lobbies for what serves its interests. NRA lobbies likewise. The difference is that the NRA isn't a trillion dollar corporation. Its millions of individual Americans participating in the democratic process. Do you think that people should never campaign for what they believe in? That people should not participate in the democratic process? Or do you only think that when the people in question disagree with you?
- ben_w 4y ago> In the context of democracy, size is everything. Like, by definition. But (a) not in the context of lobbying, and (b) that still demonstrates a preference for dead children over lower gun sales. > Do you think that people should never campaign for what they believe in? That people should not participate in the democratic process? Or do you only think that when the people in question disagree with you? You're putting words in my mouth there. They're free to campaign for things that I'm free to denounce as dangerous and myopic.
- tekknik 4y ago> (b) that still demonstrates a preference for dead children over lower gun sales. How in the world, when the left supports abortion, can you come to this opinion? We prioritize personal safety, not dollars.
- aaaaaA3 4y agoPassing any kind of a constitutional change in the US is by design a herculean task, you don't even need gun industry lobbying against changes.
- aaaaaA3 4y agoUS constitution can be changed in theory. Hardly so in practice.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoPortraying any of the first ten amendments as an after the fact is beyond dishonest. No version predating the bill of rights was ever run in prod. They decided that those ten features were necessary before they even released the thing.
- ben_w 4y agoI'm not American, to even partake at this level I have to Google which amendment is guns, which one is speech, and which one is self-incrimination. But Googling did reveal a few surprises like #27 being proposed during the same Bill Of Rights era of amendments, it only got ratified in 1992. And Delaware ratifying the constitution in 1787, the BoR amendments being proposed in 1789, Rhode Island ratifying the constitution in 1790, and the BoR amendments being completed in 1791. Stuff was weird back then.
- tekknik 4y agoThat doesn’t change the original argument that we allow gun ownership because we want corporations to make money.