4 ms·
WiFi: “beamforming” only begins to describe it (2014)
- SergeAx 4y agoThe whole WiFi ecosystem today seems like answers in a search of questions. What we really need is not speed, but connection quality, interference resistance and, maybe, in the third place - range. For speed we have copper or optic fiber.
- peter_d_sherman 4y ago>An ideal "isotropic" antenna (my favourite kind, although unfortunately it doesn't exist) picks up the signal equally in all directions, which means the region it "scoops" is spherical. It would be interesting to see (and test!) a spherical antenna -- if one does/could exist... Also -- what might be interesting might be getting two spherical antennas of the exact same size in resonance, over a distance between the pair which is some exact whole number multiple of their diameter... Or across pairs of such spherical antennas... or pairs of pairs... Anyway, a very interesting article!
- elin05 4y agoHow does antenna gain work as a receiver? Receiving antennas don’t radiate energy and thus have no constructive/destructive phenomenon to exploit.
- lolc 4y agoReads like a good intro into how beamforming works. One detail I found dubious is this part about bigger antennas: > To stretch our non-mathematical metaphor well beyond its breaking point, a "bigger sphere" will contain more signal as well as more noise, so just expanding the size of your region doesn't affect the SNR. That's why, and I'm very sorry about this, a bigger antenna actually doesn't improve your reception at all. In my understanding that is incomplete because it ignores amp noise. When your antenna is larger, you get more signal (yes including more noise), so you need to amplify it less before the signal can be sampled. That means less amplification noise and the effective SNR is better. Thus antenna gain, not just antenna directionality, will improve reception.
- themitigating 4y agoSo I'm curious as to why UHF and VHF require larger antennas. My parent's house was about 100 miles from the WTC and the antenna was massive. People in the city though used smaller sized ones.
- h2odragon 4y agoVHF requires larger antennas than UHF. most of the reason bigger TV antennas were a thing was the "bigger is better" illusion. They make fancy stacks of elements and pt "+28 Dbi" numbers on the box but at any specific frequency those could be outperformed by a simple single cut wire. (they weren't utter horseshit: considered across the whole band they could be better for being bigger, but thats a technical and theoretical "win") There are places where "more metal harvests more signal" in antenna design, but they're little dots on a broad map, not where you'd expect them to be. Herringbone antennas at WiFi freqs are fun.
- ryanianian 4y agoThe single cut wire will only be better at its resonant frequency. The TV antennas are designed to cover their entire bands.
- sgtnoodle 4y agoYagi arrays are a real thing, and they do take up a lot of space.
- pcl 4y agoUHF and VHF (that is, Ultra High Frequency and Very High Frequency) are the 3GHz-300MHz range and the 300MHz-30MHz range, respectively. That translates to a 10cm-1m wavelength for UHF and 1m-10m for VHF. Minimal effective antenna size for a basic wire antenna is 1/4 the wavelength, so you end up with big antennas for low frequency / large wavelength. https://udel.edu/~mm/ham/randomWire/ https://udel.edu/~mm/ham/randomWire/
- derstander 4y ago
- pgorczak 4y agoOne addition on receiver side amplification: it is done all the time. Each piece of equipment has a noise floor that can be higher than the one in the signal (think weak signals but with a good SNR). A low noise amplifier at the receiver can improve the signal in that case.
- dboreham 4y agoEvery receiver (perhaps the exception is a spark-gap receiver) has an amplifier. The article is trying to say that you can't improve the S/N ratio of a signal with an amplifier. You can always make it worse though. The aim is to make it less worse.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoWe experimented with decentralized networks during our university classes and one of the professors described this, basically you can form a phased array with loads of small senders in perfect timewise sync, sending slightly delayed. Its very energy intensive though. The sending and the high resolution clockworks. (Similar to gps recieving). Funny sidenode: We found out that almost every building has a huge central antenna, called elevator ropes & shaft. Attach a wifi router to that and everyone in the building can overcrowd that one central wifi. Good times.
- h2odragon 4y ago> very energy intensive utterly unrelated (but fun) anecdote: Had a "phased array" CB antenna setup consisting of 3 antenna elements, carefully placed and spaced on a mobile ground plane, and very carefully cut and coiled lengths of Big Chonky cable too hook them all up to the radio. It worked well; did Chicago to Colorado once on legal 4watt power. But then someone gave us a "1000w linear amplifier" to try. This turned out to be a bad idea. the third antenna element glowed red a few seconds after key up and then the harness joints de-soldered. Best we could figure the SWR changes induced by the antenna whips moving around weren't big enough, at 4w input power, to even notice. but when stood up to larger potential the tiny misalignment caused by the tips of the whips waving were enough to result in significant direct power loss.
- yellow_lead 4y ago> We found out that almost every building has a huge central antenna, called elevator ropes & shaft. Very fun idea :)
- RicoElectrico 4y ago> high resolution clockworks. (Similar to gps recieving). There has been a paper about access arbitration to a Wi-Fi network using FM RDS data for timing https://hackaday.com/2015/11/11/improving-wifi-throughput-with-fm-radio/ https://hackaday.com/2015/11/11/improving-wifi-throughput-wi...
- mlaang 4y agoI've made a shadertoy doing essentially the same thing, but forming directed beams. Two beam version: https://www.shadertoy.com/view/NtyXDm https://www.shadertoy.com/view/NtyXDm One beam version: https://www.shadertoy.com/view/st3XWX https://www.shadertoy.com/view/st3XWX
- readyplayeremma 4y agoThat is really cool! What a fun way to visualize beamforming!
- mlaang 4y agoThanks.
- nemacol 4y agoI would like anti-beamforming so I can create a wifi shadow and mess with people on my network.
- wnkrshm 4y agoYou'd need to be connected to their wifi hardware to do that, since you wouldn't get interference between your beams and theirs without having two coherent sources.
- labcomputer 4y agoAlready exists, it’s called MU-MIMO in the 802.11 world. Edit: Just to expand on this a bit… typically, the nulls of an antenna’s radiation pattern are sharper (in terms of dB per degree) than the peaks (and this is true for both phased arrays and traditional antennas). In other words, you can shape the beam to put one receiver in a very deep null while only slightly reducing the RSS at the other receiver. Do that for two beams at once, and each receiver gets (almost) as much power (from the intended beam) as they would if the beam were steered directly at it, while getting very little power from the other beam. Adding more elements to the TX side enables a greater number of and deeper nulls.
- nemacol 4y agoVery interesting - I will do some reading on that. Thank you for the info!
- rasz 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27133079 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27133079 : https://ans.unibs.it/projects/csi-murder/ https://ans.unibs.it/projects/csi-murder/ enabled by https://github.com/open-sdr/openwifi https://github.com/open-sdr/openwifi Both partially funded by EU's Horizon2020 program. Openwifi talk at FOSDEM 2020 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8q5nHUWP43U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8q5nHUWP43U
- nemacol 4y agoVery interesting. I will check out those links. Thank you. :D
- mjb 4y ago"Beamforming" (and the author is right to be skeptical of that term) is some really cool magic. My understanding of the history is that a lot of the technology comes from military radars. Development there was driven by power and compactness, and the relatively novel need (at the time) of building a radar that could both track targets and scan for new targets at the same time. Before that, you'd have a scan radar (antenna turning round and round), and a tracking radar (antenna pointed at the target). With beam forming tricks you can scan without moving the antenna, and then quickly jump back to get some additional tracking data. These days track-while-scan is easier because we can use computer models to do things like track interpolation, but back when this stuff was being developed that was much, much harder. Twenty years ago when I was doing my PhD work, we were working primarily on passive radars (technically something called Passive Coherent Location (PCL)). With passive radars you have some transmitter of opportunity (a TV tower, or cell tower, or somebody else's radar), and want to observe the energy from that transmitter bounce off other things. One thing that's hard about that is that the transmitter is usually closer than the target, and the target doesn't reflect all its energy, so the returns from the target are many order of magnitude weaker than the direct return from the transmitter. So you need to design your antenna or antenna array very carefully to get only a small amount of the transmitter power (don't want to saturate your analog side), while getting as much of the target power as possible. You can do that with static antennas with "manual beamforming", but dynamic approaches allow you to correct for things like multi-path and changing atmospheric conditions. Our particular work was in very low cost versions of this, with the end goal of spreading transmitters all around ("netted radar"). Good for cost, good for sensitivity, good for counter-stealth, but meant a very limited budget for any station. With the technology available now for building antenna arrays, we could have done so much better than we did back then. Amazing how the technology has changed in just a couple decades. This seems to have been driven by consumer products. Wifi, cell phones, bluetooth, etc. The miniaturization, cost reduction, power reduction, etc. The technology came originally from big military radars, but what's driven the revolution seems to be the volumes and demands of consumer products. That's definitely going back into military and high-end civil technology, which is going to drive even more interesting requirements. A fun case study in technology. (I have no non-public information on military radar technology, US or otherwise.)
- 4y ago
- 5960154000 4y ago[flagged]
- H8crilA 4y agoAESA radars are the apex predator of the electromagnetic spectrum, with often over a thousand individual tx/rx modules. If you want to see a funny take on it: https://www.reddit.com/r/NonCredibleDefense/comments/zvt9ao/1956_individual_transmitreceive_modules_would/ https://www.reddit.com/r/NonCredibleDefense/comments/zvt9ao/... PS. Do not ever approach a radar, it can boil you alive!
- mjb 4y ago> PS. Do not ever approach a radar, it can boil you alive! "Fun" related story. For a year or so in grad school I was in charge of the microwave and radar lab. The safety folks came for an annual inspection, and I toured them around the lab. Lots of "this can cook you from across the room", "this makes 50kV", "this seemingly normal 220V 50Hz outlet is actually 115V 400Hz". That kind of thing. A week later we got the inspection report. It recommended we upgrade our requirement for closed shoes to include steel toe caps. No other safety measures or signage needed.
- KRAKRISMOTT 4y ago> It recommended we upgrade our requirement for closed shoes to include steel toe caps. Are you sure that's a good idea when you work near high powered microwave equipment?
- Arrath 4y agoOh that's good.
- derekdahmer 4y agoCan multiple APs work together to do beam forming or do all there antennas have to be in a single AP?
- mmis1000 4y agoWifi APs always operate independently. Even it has the same ssid and same local network. Each ap still talk to client by themselves. The illusion you moves between AP is done by 'disconnect to one and connect to other'
- lxgr 4y agoYou'd have to synchronize transmission times to a very high degree of precision. I'm not sure if that's within the realm of something like PTP, even if the APs are connected via wired Ethernet.
- misterdata 4y agoNot sure about WiFi but the idea exists in the 5G standard as ‘coordinated multipoint’ (CoMP)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]