3 ms·
I am not confident at all, because I don't see any law of nature or society that dictates that we shall always come up with new meaningful jobs whenever we rend
by int_19h 4y ago
I am not confident at all, because I don't see any law of nature or society that dictates that we shall always come up with new meaningful jobs whenever we render some of the old ones obsolete. It's true that we've done so before, but that was also when our economic development seemed exponential; surely we know better now? In any case, without a clear understanding of the mechanism, who's to say it's not just luck and/or survivor bias?
Alternatively, we can come up with meaningless jobs. Which is, of course, just UBI in disguise and with more incidental waste.
- logicchains 4y ago>because I don't see any law of nature or society Human wants are unlimited, there'll always be something people want that machines aren't able to provide (until machines can do absolutely everything humans can do, at which point they'll be sentient and probably won't want to work for free).
- arbitrary_name 4y agoYou forget about the nature and quality of work. These people in an office adding things manually probably had a job that was safer, more dignified and healthier than, say, an worker in an Amazon fulfillment center. If we are able to replace white collar work like this, i believe we will 'hollow out the middle': low level manual work will remain, as will highly paid engineering and coding roles and certain other areas, perhaps sales executives or others. But the opportunities for many people unable or unable to meet the conditions or skills demanded by those roles, however, will be reduced.