5 ms·
Deciding that one's life is all about luck is a miserable way to live. It means one has no agency, no choice, no way to make one's life better. Because it's all
by WalterBright 4y ago
Deciding that one's life is all about luck is a miserable way to live. It means one has no agency, no choice, no way to make one's life better. Because it's all luck, that means there is no point in trying. The outcome of this is self-fulfilling - misery.
I don't understand why it's such a popular attitude these days.
A while ago, I noticed something interesting. None of my friends believes their lives are all about luck. They all believe they have agency, and are constantly taking responsibility for their lives and acting accordingly. They're a lot of fun to be around.
The great thing about taking responsibility is one can do something to fix issues in their lives.
The other ones, the ones who say it's all luck, it's always someone else's fault, why me, etc., aren't any fun to be around. No thanks.
- lm28469 4y ago> Deciding that one's life is all about luck is a miserable way to live People who think their entire lives is the sole result of their hard work and intelligence make my life more miserable
- sokoloff 4y agoThat is unlucky.
- WalterBright 4y agoI didn't say hard work and intelligence. I said choice. Where you are in life is the sum of a million choices you made.
- kashunstva 4y ago> Where you are in life is the sum of a million choices you made. Surely one's starting conditions, all of which predate conscious choice, have some impact on where one finds themselves in life. I'm approaching my 60's and have made some good decisions (and some not-so-good ones, too) but where I find myself today is the result of those decisions overlaid on a foundation of where my family of origin positioned me. Not necessarily in financial terms, but in terms of habits of mind that enabled good decisions in the first place. So I'm happy to celebrate my perspicacity and where it has taken me, but how far along I started on the curve, as with all of us? - that's pure luck.
- WalterBright 4y agoYou can blame your parents for your situation in life while you're a child. As an adult, it's on you.
- Dracophoenix 4y agoIf your parents did something so impactful in your past that you have to live with the consequences of those events for the rest of your life, blame shouldn't end at childhood. They too were agents in your life whether you desired it or not. It's not as though childhood and adolescent scars disappear upon turning 18. With that said, I agree with your general point on choice.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- willis936 4y agoThe self-made man is a myth that enables abusive power structures. It's a push towards a more egalitarian society. Simple as that.
- nickpp 4y agoSince men are inherently unequal (differing in so many ways, including their so-called luck) it follows that equality of outcome is a myth. That is why you’ll need power and abuse to ensure an equalitarian society. Which is quite easily verified using historical examples.
- WalterBright 4y agoYup. The only way to make everyone equal is to hammer everyone into the mud.
- willis936 4y agoEqual opportunity does not mean enforced equality.
- WalterBright 4y agoIt does in today's Progressive atmosphere.
- _0ffh 4y ago>Deciding that one's life is all about luck is a miserable way to live Yes, it is to externalise your locus of control. This has been shown to result in bad outcomes regarding all kinds of things, including obesity, overall health, psychological well-being, academic, and professional success. Self-victimisation is not a good thing at all, and should not be encouraged.
- chronofar 4y ago> Deciding that one's life is all about luck is a miserable way to live. It means one has no agency, no choice, no way to make one's life better. Because it's all luck, that means there is no point in trying. The outcome of this is self-fulfilling - misery. It likewise can be a recipe for misery to ignore the role of luck in your own life and the lives of others. It's not only inaccurate (sub luck out for the mechanisms by which the world turns), it attributes an unreasonable level of burden of consequence on the decision maker, one they can never hope to live up to and one no one around them will ever live up to. Of course as with many things the most reasonable course of action is something in between. To both acknowledge the ways in which we understand the world works and how much of that is outside your control, and then take very real ownership of the things that are in your control (namely your actions), and take special care to note how taking control of the things you can over time ends up compounding in unforeseen ways such that you end up "luckier" (the meeting of hard work and opportunity and all that). If anything this just seems to once again show that any extreme along nearly any axis is not only inaccurate but detrimental to mental health. Nuance and acknowledgement of opposing ideals, and realizing they're compatible and not actually opposing at all, is where one finds truth and solace.
- WalterBright 4y agoYou also get to choose your reaction to circumstance. For example: Bob and Tim fall down the stairs, each breaks a leg. Bob says, oh I'm so unlucky! My leg broke! Woe is me! Tim says, oh I'm so lucky! I could have broken my head instead of my leg! Next time I'll be more careful.
- Rury 4y agoEven that's not always true. Circumstance could be someone knocks you into a coma, and you subsequently take a turn for the worse, all in which you didn't choose it to happen nor able to choose a reaction to the circumstance.
- avgcorrection 4y ago> Because it's all luck, that means there is no point in trying. This is fallacious. Doing or not doing X has just the same consequences no matter whether “you” really did them or not. The outcomes of things happening in the world are still the same. If you change your mindset to this one (all luck) and notice that you “don’t even try”, then that is a reason to revert that mindset. (Who or what really reverts the mindset is a philosophical question.) Cause and effect is still, you know, the same as it ever was. > The outcome of this is self-fulfilling - misery. Jumping to a conclusion. Some people seem to do just fine with such an attitude. Some do worse.
- lumb63 4y agoWhy not both? I believe that I have no conscious free will. I do not think I have ever consciously “made a decision” in my life. They all ultimately arise from unconscious processes. My brain, at least, seems to be a complex system mapping certain sensory and biological inputs to outputs. Just because of that, does not mean I don’t have agency. In contrast, that is my agency. I was lucky enough that my parents instilled senses of responsibility and hard work into my brain. In that way, I suspect, the transformation in my unconscious mind that maps those inputs to outputs considers things such as responsibility. It automatically (from the perspective of my conscious mind) prefers me being accountable, me doubling down in the face of challenges, etc. I agree with you that I’m sick of seeing “it’s always someone else’s fault”, the “I can’t do it because I don’t have X”, etc. crowd. None of us can control everything, but we all ought to control what we can in an effort to improve our lives. How do we folk who are imbued with responsibility and a strong work ethic transfer that from our brains, and use that to transform the cognitive processes of others’ brains? I assume this is what happens when raising a child, and it’s easier because their brain is more impressionable. But it is certainly possible in adults, too. Emotionally moving books and stories, and ordinary people we meet can change our perspectives on life. Experiences can change our lives. The crowd we keep can influence us in certain directions. I suspect that transfer is the missing link that would allow someone who thinks “it’s all luck” to become someone who recognizes that they have agency in absence of luck.
- GAN_Game 4y ago> Deciding that one's life is all about luck is a miserable way to live. It means one has no agency, no choice, no way to make one's life better. Because it's all luck, that means there is no point in trying. The outcome of this is self-fulfilling - misery. Regardless of the effects of luck, I should point out how far from scientific observation this is. One can examine the evidence of, as this article says, luck, in society. Or, one can talk about magical thinking, and if one doesn't believe some received hegemony it will lead to misery. It sounds close to Christian fundamentalism - believe in the received divine word of the Bible or suffer eternally. The evidence based scientific method has less value in observing human society than in observing the orbit of planets and such, for a variety of reasons. The picture gotten from social science is less clear than from natural science. It is better than the alternative though. If one observed society, and the class structure of society, and the forces of production and relations of production - and the changes to the forces of production and resulting changes to relations of production - one would have an evidence based observation of society. Including the luck of being born into one class or the other. We can look at Mark Zuckerberg, who went to the Phillips Exeter high school (current yearly tuition - $47000 a year and up). His company bought Instagram for $1 billion, founded by Kevin Systrom who went to Middlesex high school (current yearly tuition - $55000 a year and up). We can then look at people who did not pay $47000 for their freshman year in high school (or its mid 1990s equivalent). > None of my friends believes their lives are all about luck. They all believe they have agency, and are constantly taking responsibility for their lives and acting accordingly. I'm sure Zuckerberg and Systrom believe they have agency - I believe they have agency. I'm sure when Bill Gates and Paul Allen left the Lakeside prep school they had agency. These are in fact people who were upper middle class and actually went out and worked. Plenty of heirs inherit their billions, live as "rich kids of Instagram" as shall their kids. Or you can take the advice if this poster - forget evidence in the world and engage in magical thinking or face misery. In fact my experience is the opposite in my cohort. We see luck of birth and class structure as bearing on relations if production. My friends are fun to be around in a manner smarmy, entitled trust fund kids are not fun to be around.
- WalterBright 4y agoI don't know any trust fund kids. I suggest reading a biography of Steve Jobs. Not a trust fund baby. Audited a couple classes in college only. Lower middle class parents. Started in a garage. Sold his Volkswagon to finance Apple. Outdid all of the ones you mentioned.
- naasking 4y ago> Deciding that one's life is all about luck is a miserable way to live. It means one has no agency, no choice, no way to make one's life better. No one serious is saying life is all about luck, but there's been a long-held view that bad outcomes are solely due to bad choices and good outcomes solely due to bad choices. It's a good thing to recognize that there's a significant degree of luck involved in both directions, and that you're not a stupid fool for not foreseeing the 2008 financial crisis, for instance, or that you're not a flawless genius for making a few fortuitous business decisions. It can return a sense of control/agency back to people who've had a string of bad luck despite seemingly careful planning, and should humble people who've had a string of good luck so they don't get too big a head.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- adversaryIdiot 4y agoyou might be privileged
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nickpp 4y agoMost of the people born healthy and living in the West are.