2 ms·
Oh, good, someone saved that. A Rust replacement for the QNX kernel would be useful. It really is a good OS. Much better suited to real-time and embedded than
by Animats 4y ago
Oh, good, someone saved that.
A Rust replacement for the QNX kernel would be useful. It really is a good OS. Much better suited to real-time and embedded than Linux.
QNX started out closed source, went open source, went closed source, went open source, and went closed source again. By which time third party developers were totally fed up with the company. GCC, Eclipse, Firefox, and Thunderbird all ran on QNX at one time. Around 20 years ago, you could run it on the desktop. I used to do that when I was working on a DARPA Grand Challenge vehicle. I could run the real-time vehicle software on the desktop, hooked to a simulator, without it missing a scheduled even while a browser was running.
I once told one of their sales reps, "Quit worrying about people pirating your product, worry about people ignoring it."
- dilyevsky 4y agoI used to work on vxworks bsps and one time out of curiosity I torrented qnx distro and ran it on my custom ppc virtual qemu board. My subjective impression from reading bootloader and some kernel-level sources was that it was much higher quality than stuff that came from windriver.
- skissane 4y ago> went open source, I don’t think it was ever, strictly speaking, open source. There was a time they offered a source code license for free to anyone who asked, but that wasn’t true “open source”, because among other reasons, you had no right to redistribute it. And then they discontinued that-which meant people who’d gotten the source that way could keep it, but anyone who had failed to take up that offer while it was available missed out, and those who had it distributing to others would be violating the license by doing so. If it had been truly open source, they could not have “turned off the tap” quite so easily.
- Animats 4y agoYes, for a while, you could look at it, but not use it.
- StrictDabbler 4y agoI'm sure you know this, but for others.. QNX is of course the OS that led to the Blackberry under RIM. RIM also had patents on elliptical curve cryptography that turned out to be more valuable than anything else they could make. It was so much money that it distorted the company towards IP rent-seeking instead of making good new stuff. So of course they focused on piracy with QNX instead of just getting it into everything. It's very much like the thing where Google keeps trying to make new products and cancels them because they aren't as profitable as the advertising business. Weirdly, QNX is my daily bread and butter. It's the leading OS for building controls and I'm logged into four QNX-based systems at different buildings this very second. One of the niches they managed to hold onto.