4 ms·
The meta-lesson for anyone reading this, is that changing people's minds when they are grounded in self-interest belief, is next to impossible. Bartle knew he w
by ggm 4y ago
The meta-lesson for anyone reading this, is that changing people's minds when they are grounded in self-interest belief, is next to impossible. Bartle knew he was on a fools errand, and went into it with low expectations.
It's interesting to see exemplifiers of the kind of 'this contradicts my interior logic so I shall ignore it' behaviour from the participants. They look very plausible.
I think AGW denialism and pre-AGW fury, the people trying to deal with religious objections to evolution had this in spades: no amount of good logic and reasoning can overcome somebody who is determined to recast what "time" means to make the fossil record align with God's work over 6 days. (nobody ever asks what contract gave him a day off on the 7th)
The "we don't want to pay tax" movement, loves in-game NFT type value transfer precisely because they believe there cannot, will not be any intrusion of tax levying bodies into the space. Contrariwise, the people I know in the forensic accounting space say they really like the naievity of people who forget "the cloud" is shorthand for "somebody else's computer" which naturally, is subject to MLAP requirements these days.
Sharing your goods in runescape is not invisible transfer of wealth, and speaking to each other in runescape is not secret communication. 12 year olds know this. Maybe grown-ups need to remind themselves of it from time to time?
Maybe people need a reminder REAMDE is fiction? Plot devices don't always translate into real-world well.
I am also reminded of Varoufakis' work on in-game economics and inflation.
- akira2501 4y ago> is that changing people's minds when they are grounded in self-interest belief, is next to impossible. If all you take are short-term measurements, then this would seem to be true. In my experience, the longer-term results are more achievable then popular thinking might suggest.
- ggm 4y agoDeath-bed conversions argue to your side of the deal, for sure. Richard Francis Burton was a disbeliever right up until he died in trieste, when his wife miraculously declared he'd changed his mind. hence, buried in hallowed ground. Less facetiously, I do think de-radicalisation works, and so a long term commitment to listening, being accepting of difference but encouraging wider thinking might work to bring committed anti-vaxx and AGW denialists back into the fold, but it demands a patience I probably lack. A geologist friend said its a life burden to commit to trying to change people's minds in his field (paleo) few can endure. He'd rather talk to people he doesn't have to argue with. I don't know Web 3.0/NFT proponents have the time free to engage in a long-term de-programming exercise. They'd be very busy actualising their net worth, one tik-tok at a time.
- hanniabu 4y ago> changing people's minds when they are grounded in self-interest belief, is next to impossible This applies to all the web2 naysayers as well
- msla 4y agoFrom what I can tell, Web 2.0 came to pass, whereas Web 3.0 has not, which rather changes the discussion around each of them. Or am I wrong about what Web 3.0 is?
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoWell after "Web 2.0", there was a lot of talk about "Web 3.0", some fifteen years ago [1]. And then now the crypto people have created a term "Web3", ostensibly completely unaware of the use of the term "Web 3.0" from the past which meant something completely different. I assume these people were too young 15 years ago to remember. But "Web3" means stuff with blockchain and similar. [1] https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=%22web%203.0%22 https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=%...
- klyrs 4y agoWait until you learn about an even older term, 5th gen computing. With all the hullabaloo about ML, I've been waiting for that one to make a comeback...
- msla 4y agoI'm still waiting for someone to give us the next generation beyond VLSI. SDSI, for Super-Duper Scale Integration, maybe. Anyway: Fourth-Generation languages were "Steal ideas from Lisp", Fifth-Generation languages were "Steal ideas from Prolog", so Sixth-Generation languages will be "Steal ideas from everyone the ML model was trained on". Github/Microsoft is ahead of the curve on this sort of thing, as usual.
- Ensorceled 4y ago
- junofan 4y agoI dunno, the model is compelling from a business perspective because you don’t have to pay to make content up front. Instead, charge royalties on user-generated content revenue. Roblox already does this well. I wouldn’t dismiss the whole thing out of hand.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tmpz22 4y ago> the model is compelling from a business perspective So is alchemy
- reidjs 4y agoAre you talking about the web3 platform, alchemy? https://www.alchemy.com/ https://www.alchemy.com/
- josephg 4y agoIt works for Roblox because the game is the content. Likewise for Mario Maker, or WC3 custom maps. It works because players evaluate the content based on how fun it is. But if I'm building something like Diablo I'll have a carefully crafted progression system for my game. If the "content" is in-game items then the best items will be the most powerful - that is, the ones which let players skip to the end of the game. And if my game's progression system can be completely ignored because someone owns a space laser they bought in another game for money, it ruins the game for everyone. - The art becomes a non-cohesive mess. - The players who don't have a space laser feel like their in-game progression has suddenly become meaningless. Clearly the real progression is being able to afford items with real money out of the game - and they don't play diablo to feel poor. - And the player who has the cool space laser has all the struggle and progress taken away from them. A sense of fulfillment is created by struggling at something then eventually succeeding. You can't feel fulfilled if you don't first struggle. (Thats what the middle of a game is for.) If you skip that by spending real money, its not fun. Even pay-to-win games have loot box mechanics and a money based progression system for the people who pay. You can make the art be cosmetic only, but that has its own set of problems. Fashion is valuable in part because of scarcity. Fortnite, Team Fortress and Dota2 create that scarcity by controlling what assets are included in the game. Scarcity is ruined if anyone can mint another NFT of the same jpeg with a single pixel changed. And you have the obvious problems of people drawing "adult content", and so on. It works for VRChat, but most of VRChat's content is off limits to most players (on devices like the Quest) because of how non-child friendly it can be. An in-house art team could easily be cheaper than the moderation team you'd need. Virtual worlds with cryptocurrency derived items seems to be a lot of smoke and not a lot of fire. Given how many people are excited by the idea, and how much money there is to be made if someone gets it right, I find it telling that there still aren't any compelling games built on these concepts.
- fswd 4y agowhat does the acronym AGW stand for? Can't figure out if you mean global warming or the story of Genesis.
- codetrotter 4y agoI figured it means Anti Global Warming
- toomuchtodo 4y agoAnthropogenic Global Warming. Refers to the increased warming of the Earth's atmosphere due to human activity.
- UIUC_06 4y agoI'm not a denier of AGW. However, I think you're wrong to lump all those people in with anti-Darwinists. AGW comes freighted with Green baggage, and some of the people who reject it are largely rejecting the Green baggage. They suspect, not without good reason, that the "cures" for AGW are measures that Greens wanted anyway. And calling them "denialists" just insures that they'll never listen to you. Some of them are, of course, religious objectors who think the world was created in 6 days. The task is to separate those people from the rest.
- Aloha 4y agoSome of the solutions are things the greens have largely rejected, like nuclear energy. The largest rejectors of nuclear energy are the environmentalists, some of which are very anti-climate change.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoI just want to point out that there are many shades of "Green" (though today, unlike in the 70s(?), perhaps none of them are critical of the AGW concept) : https://www.resilience.org/stories/2014-10-09/what-shade-of-green-are-you/ https://www.resilience.org/stories/2014-10-09/what-shade-of-...
- ggm 4y agoYes. I would agree my pejorative language doesn't help. But if I can draw an analogy, this is also a function of polarised debate in the wider sense: it's impossible for anyone now to express views positive of Palestinian self-determination because the 'overton window' of tolerance for the idea, is consumed by the meme of 'you must be a self hating jew' for anyone who is jewish, and 'you must hate jews' for anyone else. So, 'because you are green I oppose all the things you believe in because I hate the green/left agenda' is a form of denialism of the legitemacy of the underlying concern. Finding the bridge to "I agree it exists, I just disagree about solutions, like I want nuclear and you don't but we agree the problem exists' is now almost unsayable for some people. An observation I've made to others is that old school feminism is really tainted now for a younger cohort. They reject all the achievements of their aunts, mothers, grandmothers, because of a disagreement over the non-binary status in gender/sex. The language used here is (to me at least) comparable to the language used in the 'hate the greens' thing.
- btilly 4y agoThere is a variant on the halo effect which explains a lot of this. We have a tendency to choose sides. Once we do, we easily remember the good things about our side, and have a hard time believing the bad things. This is exactly reversed for the other side. It takes active work to remain balanced. So if you're on the side of technology, it is easy to talk about all the ways it improves our lives. And easy to discount the environmental impacts. Conversely if you're opposed to technology, you can easily quantify the harms. But will have an unduly rosy image of the benefits of natural things. Likewise it is hard for those who have lined up with web3, crypto, and so on to even hear well-informed and reasoned skepticism.