3 ms·
> We believe that it is morally and legally acceptable for a human to look at copyrighted artwork and even mimic it in the process of learning how to become a b
by gus_massa 4y ago
> We believe that it is morally and legally acceptable for a human to look at copyrighted artwork and even mimic it in the process of learning how to become a better artist (sales are where the morality breaks down and especially with impersonation).
I agree, even computers can do that, but what is the license of the output? (Both human generated output and AI generated output.)
The problem is that someone made one of the Ai draw a few Mickey Mouse versions, and claimed that the license of the AI said that the output was public domain, so everyone can use the AI-created drawings of Mickey Mouse freely. (I guess Disney disagree.)
- williamcotton 4y agoWell copyright law isn’t interested in if someone intended to publish infringing works rather that it is an infringing work, so that persona’s claim that “any output is in the public domain” is legally incoherent. Expand this a little bit in the opposite direction…imagine if Stable Diffusion was made illegal. Someone accuses me of using this illegal tool for an image that doesn’t look like anyone else’s image as far as the court is concerned for copyright. I put the image on my website. If the image itself is not at all infringing, then what is the evidence that Stable Diffusion was used? Should the police be issued a warrant to search my private property for proof that I used Stable Diffusion without a shred of evidence? This frames the conversation about copyright within the legal structure and not some unrelated philosophical structure.
- gus_massa 4y ago> so that persona’s claim that “any output is in the public domain” is legally incoherent. I fully agree. Anyway, I found the original link https://twitter.com/eze3d/status/1601695610498781184 https://twitter.com/eze3d/status/1601695610498781184