2 ms·
What is your alternative, along what axis do you think that alternative is better, and why do you think it's better? I'll take one aspect - tourism. If Lake P
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
What is your alternative, along what axis do you think that alternative is better, and why do you think it's better?
I'll take one aspect - tourism. If Lake Powell never happened, Glen Canyon would have been there all these years, in all its beauty. That's true. But far fewer people could have enjoyed Glen Canyon than enjoyed Lake Powell, and Lake Powell had its own beauty. So along that axis, saying that Lake Powell should never have happened seems rather elitist.
- ghaff 4y agoThere are lots of lakes. Take away the other supposed (or even real--hydropower) benefits of the dam and it's pretty hard to justify the Glen Canyon Dam on recreational benefits. (And the same reasoning applies to building roads into lots of places.) IF there are other compelling benefits, I'm open to there being recreational benefits to dams--whether puttering around on lakes or whitewater paddling benefits to controlled releases. But I'm much less open to the idea that we should build ecologically disruptive dams, especially in unique areas, for that purpose.
- kbutler 4y agoThere are actually very, very few lakes in this region - and lots of canyons (every one of which is unique!). Water management is the compelling benefit, but that does require realistic management based on actual flows.