4 ms·
> How [is an AI artist] taking in data and producing an output different than a human learning a skill and making prose/code/art? There may be a misalignment i
by godelski 4y ago
> How [is an AI artist] taking in data and producing an output different than a human learning a skill and making prose/code/art?
There may be a misalignment in intent of the claim and interpretation of the claim. As someone that researches generative modeling I actually think there is an important aspect to this question, but I do not think that this question has anything to do with how the brain or the machine learn art. It has to do with legality and morals.
So I'll break it down. We believe that it is morally and legally acceptable for a human to look at copyrighted artwork and even mimic it in the process of learning how to become a better artist (sales are where the morality breaks down and especially with impersonation). The question is "where is the nuanced difference between a machine using that data and a human using that data to learn?" This doesn't depend on the learning techniques just like how no one cares if one person learns differently than another person. Obviously no one thinks AI art should impersonate real artists nor do they think people should sell this work if it contains copyrighted material. That's in line with the human artist values (fine to draw Mickey Mouse, not fine to sell a drawing of Mickey Mouse and worse to sell that drawing and claim it is official Disney art).
This is a very important question because we need to create laws about how we can train these systems and how we handle the data that they produce (two very different things!). The line between human and machine is a lot thinner than people think (think digital painting and CGI), and it doesn't matter that stochastic algorithms learn differently than humans learn. The question is about how/if learning material can be used and if machines should be treated differently. And if so, why.
But this is way more than one sentence.
- AmericanChopper 4y ago> This is a very important question because we need to create laws about how we can train these systems and how we handle the data that they produce This is a rather prejudiced statement. AI does pose some interesting questions about copyright, but the most obvious question is whether the existing laws are sufficient. You go on to ask that question, but this statement presupposes the answer is that they’re not.
- mLuby 4y agoIn that sentence, prejudiced is a pejorative way to say opinionated. I assert that existing legal systems do not suffice. Human governments and courts have shown themselves to be near-sighted, slow, and even corrupt when it comes to rapidly advancing lucrative technology (except perhaps when that tech is a weapon).
- AmericanChopper 4y agoPrejudiced is exactly the correct word to use, as you’re stating a preconceived judgment. Expressing an opinion would be different, you’re simply stating a controversial point of view as if it were a fact, and attempting to reframe the debate based upon the presupposition.
- mLuby 4y agoThat's the technical meaning, not the more relevant culturally loaded meaning. If I say someone "voted in a prejudiced way," it's technically true if they'd already decided how they'd vote before they did so, but most people would understand my meaning to be that their vote was motivated by bigotry of some kind.
- AmericanChopper 4y agoThe meaning is perfectly clear from the context of my comment. The comment presupposes a judgement for what is probably the most controversial question in the entire debate.
- williamcotton 4y agoIt’s not pejorative, it’s a little stuffy and old fashioned, like someone just finished reading an essay by Edmond Burke or something, but in that context it is hardly akin to the other meanings. Oh, and I assert that anyone who doesn’t think our legal system can properly decide who if anyone is being wronged by these tools is just plain ignorant of the law.
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoI think that's a trivial question which is almost entirely about economics and business culture and says a lot more about the concept of property as a moral right than it does about machine learning. It's trivial because the real question is "Can AI produce creative work which is at least culturally equivalent - and perhaps even better - than the best human creative work?" I'm fairly sure the answer to that question is "Yes". Because as soon as you go past modelling content and start modelling psychology, aesthetics, politics, and the dynamics of culture itself, the question answers itself. With fast-enough processing and a large enough dataset, why wouldn't Behavioural/Political/Cultural AI be possible, perhaps with different AI systems using culture and human affect itself as a memetic battlefield? Of course then we're very much not in Kansas any more, Toto. The danger - actually the likelihood - is that AI becomes an irresistibly seductive mechanised sociopath, able to automate everything, including politics, culture, and everything else that makes humans human. But what about ethics, you ask? How much AI research is asking that question at all, never mind taking it seriously?
- godelski 4y ago> But what about ethics, you ask? > How much AI research is asking that question at all, never mind taking it seriously? I think quite a lot of us (speaking as a researcher) are in fact asking ethic questions. But I think there is nuance we're making decisions on that others don't get. I think there are also nuances that many artists get that we researchers don't. Unfortunately I think we're frequently speaking past one another, and worse, we like sensationalism and so this is even being encouraged. That makes us to talk in bubbles because we feel like we're not being heard and get understandably frustrated. But this is a societal issue and as such we need a lot of points of views to resolve and the bubbling effect will prevent us doing this in a useful manner. Communication in the global era is harder than we're primed to think because communication in local groups has far fewer issues and when there are issues they are often quickly resolved.
- gus_massa 4y ago> We believe that it is morally and legally acceptable for a human to look at copyrighted artwork and even mimic it in the process of learning how to become a better artist (sales are where the morality breaks down and especially with impersonation). I agree, even computers can do that, but what is the license of the output? (Both human generated output and AI generated output.) The problem is that someone made one of the Ai draw a few Mickey Mouse versions, and claimed that the license of the AI said that the output was public domain, so everyone can use the AI-created drawings of Mickey Mouse freely. (I guess Disney disagree.)
- williamcotton 4y agoWell copyright law isn’t interested in if someone intended to publish infringing works rather that it is an infringing work, so that persona’s claim that “any output is in the public domain” is legally incoherent. Expand this a little bit in the opposite direction…imagine if Stable Diffusion was made illegal. Someone accuses me of using this illegal tool for an image that doesn’t look like anyone else’s image as far as the court is concerned for copyright. I put the image on my website. If the image itself is not at all infringing, then what is the evidence that Stable Diffusion was used? Should the police be issued a warrant to search my private property for proof that I used Stable Diffusion without a shred of evidence? This frames the conversation about copyright within the legal structure and not some unrelated philosophical structure.
- gus_massa 4y ago> so that persona’s claim that “any output is in the public domain” is legally incoherent. I fully agree. Anyway, I found the original link https://twitter.com/eze3d/status/1601695610498781184 https://twitter.com/eze3d/status/1601695610498781184
- williamcotton 4y agoThe problem is that this is not a question that a court would ask about these tools and since copyright is a legal invention it is kind of pointless. It’s the kind of conversation to have in the context of art (better yet if your contribution to the conversation is art itself) or the philosophy of language, although the question could be a little less “stoned in a Freshman dorm” and more informed by the actual discourse of those specialties as these questions are sort of old hat. If you want to ask meaningful questions of these tools and copyright you need to study the law, plain and simple.
- protocolture 4y agoI largely believe that AI artwork should be treated 1:1 the same as human output. That is, in a non ideal scenario, if it creates are that wouldn't normally be subject to copyright, then the process (call it learning, call it mapping, call it baking for all I care) is largely irrelevant. In an ideal scenario, no artwork would be owned and we wouldn't have this discussion at all but alas. I don't see how valuing AI output is some kind of nihilistic devaluing of the human race, unless you already hold some kind of preconceived negative idea of machine learning models. Remember these models are built by humans. Its human ingenuity that's scaring the pants off the art industry at the moment. TALL men and women and others of INDUSTRY and BUSINESS are making COOL THINGS with VALUE.