4 ms·
> But why does he need students to do his own research? That's a phenomenally good question. Short answer: because of incentives in academia(). To be high up
by Beldin 4y ago
> But why does he need students to do his own research?
That's a phenomenally good question. Short answer: because of incentives in academia().
To be high up in the academic hierarchy(), you want top-ranked publications. So you work on those and score a few - good on you! However, a researcher in the same field outdid you by publishing their own work AND supervising a student. That increased their output, so they get the promotion. Now they get more means to attract phd students and postdocs, all collaborating with them, further increasing output.
The nasty thing is that this cycle has knock-on effects. Do everything by yourself and you're stagnating; collaborate and you are rewarded with more recognition, promotion, more citations, more reviewer invitations, more invites to give talks/keynotes, etc. And: more quantity and quality in those trigger more and higher-valued of those. Suddenly you're growing into a "respected member of the community" - which strengthens your position at your instituting. Stronger position locally is more local options for growth, leading to the next cycle.
TL;DR: Because the direction of academia is in the hands of managers (uni admins, politicians, grant body admins), and managers need quantifiable data... so you're incentiviced to make your numbers go up.
- thwayunion 4y agoI totally agree. Academia is a prestige game. If you just want to do science, you're better off taking a non-traditional path.
- kelipso 4y agoBenefit to that is you are training the next generation. Do research on your own, good, but have ten grad students working for you and you can basically multiply your output by ten. Note, the grad students a majority of the time won't be able to do the research without your advice, this is just a fact; there are exceptions but that's just how it is the majority of the time.
- selimthegrim 4y agoAlso, who is going to defend your scientific legacy after you pass on to the great ivory tower in the sky?