4 ms·
> If it were the case, there would be no society with drugs and polyamory. There are virtually no societies that embrace drugs and polyamory. Some highly indiv
by rayiner 4y ago
> If it were the case, there would be no society with drugs and polyamory.
There are virtually no societies that embrace drugs and polyamory. Some highly individualistic societies tolerate both in the sense that they condone pursuit of individual satisfaction without regard to social utility. But virtually no society treats those things as virtuous, pro-social behaviors.
> What you call anti-social, some other group call it life.
You can call it “life” (I.e. the pursuit of personal satisfaction) but it’s still anti-social. Using drugs or having multiple partners might feel good to you individually, but it has only negative externalities on society at large. That’s pretty much the definition of anti-social.
> A christian taboo or an american indulgence is not a universal construct.
These rules aren’t “Christian” taboos. Drug use and polyamory are frowned upon across the Middle East, Asia, and Africa. Even within Islam and Mormonism, polygamy is a historical practice that is sometimes tolerated for certain people but downplayed by the mainstream.
Nor are those rules a matter of preference. Quite the opposite: they are nearly universal across diverse societies and cultures because they are rooted in physical, economic, and social realities. In that sense it’s similar to the rules that apply to economic transactions. Most societies discourage or ban various types of financial misconduct because they undermine the trust that enables markets to function. SBF’s financial crimes aren’t bad because some stone tablet says so. They’re bad because such conduct has a negative effect on society at large.
- haswell 4y ago> Using drugs or having multiple partners might feel good to you individually, but it has only negative externalities on society at large. That’s pretty much the definition of anti-social. Using sweeping terminology to dismiss drugs is problematic. Does your definition of anti-social drugs include legal drugs like alcohol and caffeine, partially illegal drugs like marijuana and psilocybin, etc? In what way is having multiple partners inherently harmful to society? You are stating these things as if they are self-evident truths, but that is far from the case, such sweeping claims need some pretty hefty backing. > Drug use and polyamory are frowned upon across the Middle East, Asia, and Africa. The prevalence of a social reflex is not sufficient to justify it (see: racism). Setting aside the overly broad definition of "drug use", why would such a default state about polyamory be inherently correct, both through history and into the future? One could speculate that such intuitions are primarily about one's personal notion of right and wrong, and for most folks that includes a deep sense of commitment to their partner. For the monogamist, the very idea that their partner could be participating with other partners is incompatible with their value system, and therefore they would never except that in a partner. And that's perfectly fine. But there are arguably social configurations that are perfectly compatible with polyamory. As long as all parties involved are on board, I see no further social harm unless you place particularly high value on procreation. As it often goes with religious arguments, one need not impose those beliefs on others, nor is the existence of people with other belief systems a problem purely on the basis that they are non-conforming.
- random314 4y ago> There are virtually no societies that embrace drugs and polyamory. There is this tiny sect you might have heard of called Hinduism.
- bhupy 4y agoWhat? I was raised a Hindu, and Hinduism absolutely does not embrace drugs and polyamory...for any charitable definition of those terms.
- random314 4y agohttps://english.webdunia.com/article/writer-s-corner/is-shiva-a-drug-taking-god-117030100010_1.html https://english.webdunia.com/article/writer-s-corner/is-shiv... Come on. And Gods in Hinduism are polyamoous except Rama. All of this is well known.
- bhupy 4y agoSociety tends to develop and outgrow its mythology — lots of religious texts contain practices that no modern society would engage in (see: the Old Testament). Nobody that's actually raised in modern mainstream Hindu society is conditioned to accept drug consumption or polyamory. The only way one might draw a contrary conclusion is if they were from the outside looking in, merely studying the mythology and totally ignoring what modern Hindu society has looked like in the last 100 years leading up to today. I was raised in an extremely orthodox Hindu household, worshipping all of the Gods of Hinduism. Polyamory/polygamy is unheard of — if anyone in one's local temple engaged in it, they would be the subject of everyone's gossip. Ditto drug use...
- random314 4y agoMy reply was in a narrow context, where American Christian ideals are projected as Universal human ideals.