4 ms·
It's an interesting legal question. If a human cannot publicly use a copyrighted image without a license, why / how a non-human can? If some image are free to
by nine_k 4y ago
It's an interesting legal question.
If a human cannot publicly use a copyrighted image without a license, why / how a non-human can?
If some image are free to use with attribution, how can an ML model track and provide such attribution?
- madeofpalk 4y ago> If some image are free to use with attribution, how can an ML model track and provide such attribution? Easy - if they cannot provide attribution, they cannot use the image to train an ML model.
- anileated 4y agoIt’s not interesting or complicated in any way: because a non-human has no free will and is operated by a human, the human (or in this case OpenAI/Microsoft/etc.) is ultimately infringing. If and when the non-human is granted human rights, this can be revisited.
- Glyptodon 4y agoHumans use copyrighted images without licenses all the time. Even trivial things like sharing a photo of a book cover can qualify.
- snickerbockers 4y agoYes but do you pass it off as your own original artwork that you created all by yourself, or do you present the book cover in a way that makes it obvious that you are taking a photo of somebody else's book?
- Glyptodon 4y agoSo it's what you do with the output and not the output itself that matters, right?
- snickerbockers 4y agoNo, its the part where you misrepresent somebody else's creation as your own. if its not alright for a person to do then its not alright to automate it. stop trying to play dumb semantic games, its not nearly as clever as you think it is.
- Glyptodon 4y agoI don't think it's being clever. If someone prompts an AI generator and acts like they created the output, that's on them, not on the AI generator.
- snickerbockers 4y agoIt would be on them if the AI generator was forthcoming about how it "created" the image. If a company like MS is advertising that they have a program that creates new content, but that program actually has a known tendency to output content from it's training set then they bear responsibility, especially if that program is being run remotely on their servers.
- snickerbockers 4y ago> If some image are free to use with attribution, how can an ML model track and provide such attribution? That's a problem for the people who create the models to solve. This is what's so frustrating about the ML/AI community, they think the onus is on everybody else to overcome problems created by their products.
- nine_k 4y agoExactly. I'm interested in approaches to a solution.