7 ms·
> without mentioning a single reason why Finland selected the F35A There are at least three within the first tenth of that long article alone that I read, name
by defrost 4y ago
> without mentioning a single reason why Finland selected the F35A
There are at least three within the first tenth of that long article alone that I read, namely:
* the most boring factor, simply the sheer amount of F-35s sold is a huge benefit. As has been stressed from the outset, Finland can’t afford to be the sole operator of an aircraft
* Lockheed Martin provided a unique tailored solution to Finland – one described in their BAFO-press statement to “includes many opportunities for the Finnish defense industry related to the direct manufacture and maintenance of the F-35 that have not been offered before.”
* Which brings us to what has been the most controversial aspect of the program: cost. The acquisition cost has come down nicely,
I'll grant it's a badly written article for clarity and it's hard to pick the details out from the noise and fluff but it's simply incorrect to claim that not a single reason was mentioned.
( other than on the technical grounds that more than "a single reason" was provided in the article. )
- wkat4242 4y agoAre there any jet fighters available to buy that Finland would be the only operator of? I'd assume all other options would be operated in their country of origin at the very least (eg Gripen in Sweden, Rafale in France...) Those don't have stealth of course and having Russia as a direct neighbor it's much more likely they'll see combat against an advanced military (much more do than western Europe) so I can imagine they wanted that advantage even though it's not perfect.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> any jet fighters available to buy that Finland would be the only operator of? The concern isn't being sole operator at time of sale, but decades down the road. The Gripen, for example, is used by Sweden, South Africa, Hungary and Czechia [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saab_JAS_39_Gripen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saab_JAS_39_Gripen
- phillc73 4y agoI'm such a fan of the Gripen. It's significantly cheaper to operate than the F-35, with around 4 to 5 Gripen flight hours for the same cost as one F-35 flight hour. While it doesn't have stealth capabilities, it does have over the horizon radar, can carry the Meteor air-to-air missile which has a 100km range and was specifically designed to operate in a "distributed and de-centralised" manner; that is from rough, but still paved, runways and highways. I really wish they'd send a couple of squadrons of Gripens to Ukraine, because I think they'd be the perfect aircraft for that theatre.
- sofixa 4y agoYep, and especially for smaller countries with smaller air forces and budgets, having more Gripens makes more sense than having fewer but more expensive F-35s. The risk of not being able to properly maintain them down the line and ending up with 3-4 operable planes is too high for the advantages of stealth (which IMO comes more into play when on the offence, which Finland probably won't be anytime soon). Agree about Ukraine too. Sending highly sophisticated jets that will take months to learn is wasting Ukraine's time - Gripens, maybe Mirage 2000s, MiG-29s make the most sense.
- oblio 4y ago> maybe Mirage 2000s Stopped being produced 15 years ago. > MiG-29 Ukraine can't get new ones. > Gripens Could be an option, but available only in low numbers. The Ukraine war will be won through stocks and new production. Ukraine can't afford a dead-end platform. Especially because "sending highly sophisticated jets that will take months to learn". The F-16 is probably the best option, still being made, but much more importantly, available in large numbers, thousands of them out there.
- mschuster91 4y ago> The Ukraine war will be won through stocks and new production. Or on the diplomatic table. While I agree it is a good thing to send Ukraine all we reasonably can, it is a nonzero probability Putin gets into hot water and ousted - bad health, pissed-off bureaucracy, domestic protests once he's forced to conscript people in central (ethnic) Russia.
- gggggg5 4y agoNote that Czechia, Hungary and South Africa have much older Gripens which are not relevant to this conversation. Czechia is moving to the F-35 instead of ordering the Gripen E. Only Sweden and Brazil ordered the new Gripens.
- actionfromafar 4y agoI think it's a little bit relevant because it still gives a hint of how SAAB performs as a partner, which is very important for such an advanced weapons system, but I'll upvote you.
- jmnicolas 4y agoFWIW Czechia asked Gripen to keep its plane until 2030.
- gggggg5 4y agoYes. But those are the old Gripens, not at all relevant in this conversation.
- syedkarim 4y agoTangent: Why is Brazil buying a modern fighter. Don’t they have the capacity to produce something of their own?
- gggggg5 4y ago> Don’t they have the capacity to produce something of their own? Not really, and even if they did, it might not be worth the effort. Instead they got a super attractive technology transfer deal from SAAB.
- fnrslvr 4y agoYeah, this. Smaller countries can easily wind up holding the bag with less-widely adopted defence procurements, and without a wider community of users investing in the platform and its parts ecosystem it can become a sustainment nightmare. For example, Australia became the sole operator of the F-111 from when the USAF retired it in 1998, until the RAAF retired it in 2010. The Australian Army also found itself in the position of sole operator of the ARH variant of the Eurocopter Tiger, a situation which lead to severe sustainment issues and exorbitant per-hour flight costs (estimates of up to AU$34k), and eventually lead to the 2021 decision to replace them with Apache Guardians.