6 ms·
This is an article about why Finland selected the F35A, without mentioning a single reason why Finland selected the F35A. No ranking, no mention of technical ad
by belter 4y ago
This is an article about why Finland selected the F35A, without mentioning a single reason why Finland selected the F35A. No ranking, no mention of technical advantages no independent benchmark of this platform still to be proven in combat anywhere. And no, bombing ISIS does not count.
- zx8080 4y agoDo you mean that decisionmakers corruption is the reason?
- lfodofod 4y agoHave any of the competitors been proven in combat anywhere?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- galaxyLogic 4y agoEverybody of course would like to read a ranking of all fighter jet planes me included. Not like who is fastest or has most ammunition but who has the best rate of survival. This could perhaps be determined by some sort of simulation. Would not make sense to put them into an actual fight really. Countries who own the planes would not want the enemy to know their weaknesses.
- KMag 4y agoRate of survival under what circumstances? Even for the simple case of pairwise one-on-one dogfights, there could easily be a rock-paper-scissors scenario where there's no single dominant plane. Also, the data would be from simulations. Outside of Ukraine, there haven't been many fighters of advanced nations shot down in decades.
- galaxyLogic 4y agoI just wonder if there are such simulations. My guess is there are. They are simulating nuclear weapons too.
- KMag 4y agoMore than 20 years ago, I wrote networking portions of such simulations. Even for the unclassified components for those simulations, many of the components were still both commercial secrets and considered munitions under ITAR export controls. Terrain maps beyond a certain resolution are classified. As I remember, the somewhat lower resolution terrain maps were still ITAR controlled munitions. Some of the radio propagation models are classified. Even half-way decent simulation outputs are likely also classified. In my case, for the most part, the simulations were used to shorten the turnaround time in the early prototyping stages, and also a fair amount for the sales team to sell military hardware to governments.
- gpderetta 4y agoAnd in Ukraine, the life expectancy of anything flying above treetop has been very very low (admittedly F35 would fare better than its competitors here).
- yobbo 4y agoThere were rumours of an Isreali F-35 targeted and damaged (but survived) by some old Russian AA system, maybe BUK? This was based on observed events and movements. Of course, we would never know, which is correct and appropriate. The topic of "spectral stealth" is complicated. It is vulnerable to systems of networked radars, among other things. It is one feature that may be very useful, but it is not a "panacea".
- red-iron-pine 4y agoRussian BUKs and S-400s in Syria repeatedly and consistently tracked Israeli F-16s. In an actual shooting war they'd have gone down, fast, and the Israelis knew it -- which is why they bought into the F-35. Price was good and, like, "stealth". There is little to suggest that the Israeli F-35 was taken down by a missile; the sources involved are not especially credible. Eurasia Times, for example, is basically Russia Today (RT) and is not really trustworthy. Most of the posts elsewhere, e.g. Quora, are from questionable accounts and aren't credible either. It's possible it happened and they're spinning it as something birds -- which is pretty lame and damning if true -- but most of the pro-shot-down points are difficult to take seriously.
- fnrslvr 4y agoYou might want to track down the information they release from multinational training exercises like Red Flag. Reportedly the F-35 has put in multiple dominant showings at Red Flag since its debut. I'm not sure how complete the information they release from these exercises is, though, and some of the aircraft involved (most notably the F-22) are notoriously restrained to keep the true capabilities of the platform secret.
- bee_rider 4y agoNot really sure what “proven in combat” looks like, the US fortunately hasn’t fought a peer in a long, long time so all of our stuff has only been tested in fairly one sided wars. If a country’s Air Force is getting in fair fights, I’d suspect either they are in pretty dire circumstances, or they have some questionable decision making going on!
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> no mention of technical advantages no independent benchmark Because those weren't the deciding factors. Cost and maintainability were. (It's implied that the planes were close enough in capability that the "gate checks" were just that. Gates. Not goals.) Finland didn't want to end up with another Betamax fleet.
- trashtester 4y ago> Because those weren't the deciding factors. I think it's the other way around. Technically, the F-35 has been superior all along, but it used to be expensive. Now, with the cost coming down, the reason NOT to pick it went away.
- iosono88 4y ago[dead]
- defrost 4y ago> without mentioning a single reason why Finland selected the F35A There are at least three within the first tenth of that long article alone that I read, namely: * the most boring factor, simply the sheer amount of F-35s sold is a huge benefit. As has been stressed from the outset, Finland can’t afford to be the sole operator of an aircraft * Lockheed Martin provided a unique tailored solution to Finland – one described in their BAFO-press statement to “includes many opportunities for the Finnish defense industry related to the direct manufacture and maintenance of the F-35 that have not been offered before.” * Which brings us to what has been the most controversial aspect of the program: cost. The acquisition cost has come down nicely, I'll grant it's a badly written article for clarity and it's hard to pick the details out from the noise and fluff but it's simply incorrect to claim that not a single reason was mentioned. ( other than on the technical grounds that more than "a single reason" was provided in the article. )
- wkat4242 4y agoAre there any jet fighters available to buy that Finland would be the only operator of? I'd assume all other options would be operated in their country of origin at the very least (eg Gripen in Sweden, Rafale in France...) Those don't have stealth of course and having Russia as a direct neighbor it's much more likely they'll see combat against an advanced military (much more do than western Europe) so I can imagine they wanted that advantage even though it's not perfect.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> any jet fighters available to buy that Finland would be the only operator of? The concern isn't being sole operator at time of sale, but decades down the road. The Gripen, for example, is used by Sweden, South Africa, Hungary and Czechia [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saab_JAS_39_Gripen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saab_JAS_39_Gripen
- phillc73 4y agoI'm such a fan of the Gripen. It's significantly cheaper to operate than the F-35, with around 4 to 5 Gripen flight hours for the same cost as one F-35 flight hour. While it doesn't have stealth capabilities, it does have over the horizon radar, can carry the Meteor air-to-air missile which has a 100km range and was specifically designed to operate in a "distributed and de-centralised" manner; that is from rough, but still paved, runways and highways. I really wish they'd send a couple of squadrons of Gripens to Ukraine, because I think they'd be the perfect aircraft for that theatre.
- ummonk 4y agoBut it did. Stealth, widespread adoption globally (resulting in a larger logistical support base and long term support), and low cost were all mentioned as features of the F-35 that made it preferable to its competitors.
- aidenn0 4y agoDoes anyone seriously think the F-35A is not technically as-good-as or superior to the Typhoon on a number of axes? If it's similar in cost to the Typhoon, it seems like a no-brainer. Of course the "If" is doing a lot of work which is why TFA was so focused on whether or not the costs in the contracts were reasonable.
- yobbo 4y agoThe Eurofighter is higher specced than the F-35 on a number points - speed, manoeuvrability, capacity, and possibly endurance - but this is not really part of the debate. The question is how they are going to be used in practice, with everything that entails. The decision also includes a gamble on how the platform develops in the future, and how adversary's capabilities develop.
- rocket_surgeron 4y agoThe F-35 has already had numerous successes operating in a high-threat anti-air environments in Lebanon and Syria (edit: and Iran) at the hands of the Israelis.
- magicalhippo 4y agoNorway went with the F-35A some time ago[1] to replace our F-16s, and we got the first planes in 2015. Since then we've gotten a fair bit of experience with it, including join exercises[2] as well as developing a landing system for our arctic climate[3]. Denmark has also gone for the F-35A[4], and recently got its first planes. If Finland joins NATO, it makes sense to combine air forces[5] in Scandinavia, in which case I can imagine there's a lot of benefits from having the same airplane as one of the other members. Obviously that w as not a direct consideration back when the decision was made, but surely some of the people involved were eyeing close cooperation in Scandinavia if shit hit the fan. Regardless, I imagine Finland has had a chat with the Norwegian Air Force about the plane, which feedback should be highly relevant given the similarities between the countries. So far from what I've read the Norwegian Air Force seems quite happy with the F-35. [1]: https://www.lockheedmartin.com/en-us/products/f-35/f-35-global-partnership/f-35-norway.html https://www.lockheedmartin.com/en-us/products/f-35/f-35-glob... [2]: https://www.tu.no/artikler/norske-flygere-har-for-forste-gang-deltatt-med-f-35-i-verdens-storste-luftovelse/461237/ https://www.tu.no/artikler/norske-flygere-har-for-forste-gan... [3]: https://www.ffi.no/aktuelt/podkaster/16-slik-har-ffi-forsket-pa-f-35 https://www.ffi.no/aktuelt/podkaster/16-slik-har-ffi-forsket... [4]: https://www.f35.com/f35/global-enterprise/denmark.html https://www.f35.com/f35/global-enterprise/denmark.html [5]: https://www.nrk.no/trondelag/luftfartssjefen-vil-ha-felles-nordisk-luftforsvar-om-sverige-og-finland-blir-medlemmer-av-nato-1.16264381 https://www.nrk.no/trondelag/luftfartssjefen-vil-ha-felles-n...
- The_Double 4y agoI wonder how much value there would be in having some level of dissimilar redundancy in (soon to be) NATO air forces. All NATO countries having fleets of the F35 makes us vulnerable to any kind of weakness or bug that adversaries are able to exploit.
- sklargh 4y agoIt is worth noting that the US operates a number of F-35s out of Eielson Air Force Base in Alaska. The weather conditions are comparable to the sub-arctic areas of Scandinavia. Heck they were figuring out how to operate in Thule this month.
- pastacacioepepe 4y agoI know the most evident reason: If you want to be part of NATO you've got to pay your dues to NATO's overlord military industrial complex.
- bell-cot 4y agoFrance - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Air_and_Space_Force#Inventory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Air_and_Space_Force#Inv... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_equipment_of_the_French_Army https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_equipment_of_the_Frenc...
- sofixa 4y agoEurofighter Typhoon is produced by 4/5 NATO member states, and there is also the Rafale by France.
- oaiey 4y agoIt is not NATO which enforces that. It is the superior spending and technology the overlord ;) is producing which makes every competing product a tough sell regards its pricing. And yes, you spent your money with friendly nations.
- psychphysic 4y agoThe main reason is one that is best not said out loud. Esp in 2021. This is a NATO buy in.
- mlindner 4y agoExcept Finland wasn't part of NATO nor had plans to join NATO when this deal was negotiated.
- actionfromafar 4y agoCan't hurt to cozy up to NATO anyways. Finland bought F18s during the Cold War.
- psychphysic 4y agoExactly, that's why it was so important.
- miroljub 4y agoMaybe because the technical selection process was not important? The decision was purely political, they wanted to please the most important NATO country, and they wouldn't achieve that goal by buying MiG or Tornado.
- TruthShare 4y ago[dead]