55 ms·
No doubt, but how relevant? If you could somehow go through my brain you'd also find the occasional piece of art and literature - I've memorised a few good poem
by roenxi 4y ago
No doubt, but how relevant? If you could somehow go through my brain you'd also find the occasional piece of art and literature - I've memorised a few good poems and songs. And I can recognise certain paintings on sight which would be difficult if they weren't accurately encoded in my mind somewhere. The fact that I have memorised them doesn't mean that I'm violating anyone's copyright if I attempted to compose poems and songs.
- haswell 4y agoThe question is, will the legal system see this software as equivalent to your brain? Anthropomorphizing this software seems problematic.
- freilanzer 4y agoI can't load your brain into RAM with a Python library yet, though.
- roenxi 4y agoAbsolutely, but that is what makes the relevancy of the fact interesting. If you could load my brain into Python, would it then become copyright infringement, despite the content being logically unchanged? Memorising a picture using a fleshy model is fine, so the raw fact that art has been found in a black box model here isn't necessarily relevant. Might be. Might not be.
- haswell 4y agoI understand what you’re saying, but if you could load Python into your brain, I suspect the laws would quickly change to reflect that new reality. The biological/evolutionary limits of humans are core assumptions of current laws, and I’d argue that the operating environment has changed enough to make those assumptions outdated. > Memorising a picture using a fleshy model is fine I imagine the fleshy model is fine not because it’s fleshy, but because it’s the model that people were targeting when writing current laws. Even if no memorization occurred, there are still big questions about why such a model should be treated like anything other than just another computer program from a legal perspective.
- pxoe 4y agowhy do people bring up humans and their brains, as if it's gonna affect how models create and store image data/derivative data in a very definitive form of bits on a disk? just as a distraction?