3 ms·
So, back to your initial claim: Does nuclear have about the same price as two weeks of LiIon?
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
So, back to your initial claim: Does nuclear have about the same price as two weeks of LiIon?
- ben_w 4y agoYes. Sorry, I thought that was obvious, given that time factors out. Two [minutes, hours, days, weeks, months], to a reasonable approximation doesn't change the price of electricity. It's like asking in which fuel tank petrol costs more per litre, the big one or the little one.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoBut to charge that lion you need some other source of energy. So costs should be Lion + power plant which is charging it. You don't need to charge nuclear power plant, obviously.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThe cost of wind or pv is a rounding error in this context.
- defrost 4y ago@Schroedingersat specifically for yourself (if you don't have this already) as you appear to have a good handle on actual real world mining issues and an interest in renewable energy .. For anyone else with an interest .. South Australia ( small Australian state with some heavy industry ) has had prolonged periods of getting by on just battery backed renewable energy (wind, solar) with minimal baseload generation support - as part of a larger interstate grid they've exported excess energy to larger neighbouring states. The Tesla built battery pack facility details are: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hornsdale_Power_Reserve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hornsdale_Power_Reserve https://hornsdalepowerreserve.com.au/ https://hornsdalepowerreserve.com.au/ https://www.cefc.com.au/where-we-invest/case-studies/sa-big-battery-a-game-changer https://www.cefc.com.au/where-we-invest/case-studies/sa-big-... and there should be enough actual real world details there to plug into any models people are making about wind + solar + battery at latitudes of 33° from the equator.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoYou also forget, that that lion battery will need to be changed as it will get cycled up. But I guess that such detail is also a rounding error.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThat's...the entire point of the comment you completely missed. LCOS + LCOE is much smaller with a LiIon battery, and there are many better options for 95% of the storage needed.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoOnce in a 10 years rebuilding a nuclear power plant? You are the one missing the point here.
- ben_w 4y agoHow often something needs to be serviced is a different question to how much it costs each time you do. The installation cost of a battery storage system, spread over the lifetime of that system, is a bit less than the the cost of a nuclear plant spread over the lifetime of the nuclear plant. Adding to that number the cost of a renewable power supply to charge that battery, spread over the lifetime of the power supply, makes it swings and roundabouts.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoYes. Replacing a battery is exactly as hard as building a nuclear reactor. Frequency of replacing parts is precisely the only thing related to cost.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoOf course, we are rebuilding nuclear reactors every 10 years from ground up. And of course that "just changing few MWh in batteries" is the cheapest part of whole battery storage.
- ben_w 4y agoYes, and? Cost for renewable is $a/kWh, for batteries is $b/kWh for installation and $(b/c)/kWh for delivery where c is the effective number of cycles the battery lasts for. a+(b/c) ~= the cost per kWh for nuclear, thought of course I'm painting in broad brushstrokes here and averages hide details.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoSo what is your math saying? That battery storage which needs to be replaced every 10 years because it will cycle out + needs to have additional power plants which are providing the power for it is in the end more expensive than just nuclear power plant? I agree.
- ben_w 4y agoNo, and I have no idea why you're failing to understand me.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoOK, let me try to explain a bit better what my problem is with what you're saying. You build a nuclear power plant, and it is capable of outputting X megawatts as a sustained output. The same plant that produced 100 (or however many) megawatts this now will also produce 100 megawatts next minute, or hour, or month. Same with solar or wind, except that it's not quite as consistent as nuclear. (On the other hand, you have to refuel nuclear plants from time to time.) LiIon is different. It doesn't produce electricity, it stores it. You measure it in megwatt-hours, not in megawatts. The battery that you stored your first minute of standby power in is a physically separate battery from the one you store the next minute's standby power in. Two hours of standby power costs 60 times as much as two minutes, because you need 60 times as many batteries. The only way your statement makes sense is if the cost of the batteries to store two months of power is only a rounding error compared to the cost of generating the electricity. That possibly might be true, but if you're claiming that, I'd like to see your source...
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThe op's point which you failed to comprehend is the less often you cycle a battery the longer it lasts. So the overnight cost per joule delivered is constant. You could object to the amount needed up front, or use some reasoning based on discount rate, but you didn't. Also it would be wrong even if you did because the energy needed for the infrequent long duration events is a small fraction of the total and doesn't need storing inna chemical battery. Even using gas for it for centuries would release less emissions than the emissions released whilst building the nuke instead of something reasonable.
- ben_w 4y agoWorked example, albeit simplified: If you use, say, 1 kilowatt constantly, then the minimum you need overnight is a 12 kWh battery, while a battery that lasts a week would be 168 kWh. Let's say that particular battery lasts exactly 1095 complete cycles. The 12 kWh battery gets replaced every 3 years. The 168 kWh battery gets replaced every 42 years. The cost per night is the same.
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago