5 ms·
The App Store does not protect consumers
- josephcsible 4y ago> my only option would be contacting my bank and reporting them as fraud Doesn't Apple permaban you if you do this?
- danielinoa 4y agoThey only ban unprofitable apps. Scam apps that make money are typically okay since Apple gets a 30% cut.
- lapcat 4y agoI believe the commenter was referring to the consumer (i.e., their Apple ID account) rather than the developer.
- tpmoney 4y ago>Doesn't Apple permaban you if you do this? Given that Apple Support is the ones that told them to do this, it sounds like there's more to this than a simple refund of an in app purchase. IAP charges are from Apple, so they're saying Apple Support told them to file a chargeback against Apple. That doesn't make sense.
- lockhouse 4y ago> From many years of experience following Apple news, I can predict that hordes of Apple defenders will come out of the woodwork to blame the Reddit poster for failing to cancel the App Store trials in time. It's not Apple's fault if an individual consumer fails in their personal responsibility, right? You called it OP. I’m trying to understand how this is Apple’s fault or how they owe the Reddit poster a refund. Are opt-out free trials a bit of a scummy thing to do? Yes and I would never utilize one as a seller, but neither the seller nor Apple are committing fraud here. The terms of the transaction are clearly spelled out before you commit to it. Perhaps Apple could provide a short grace period with automated refunds as long as the user cancels within 3 days of payment or so? That might be a good compromise here.
- lapcat 4y ago> You called it OP. Thank you. > I’m trying to understand how this is Apple’s fault Apple: "it’s by design" > neither the seller nor Apple are committing fraud here. As the article points out, many App Store developers are in fact committing fraud, but Apple does little or nothing about that. > The terms of the transaction are clearly spelled out before you commit to it. Are they? From the article: "What is Apple's App Store refund policy? An as App Store developer and consumer, I honestly don't know!" Retail stores typically have some kind of publicly posted refund policy, unlike the App Store.
- lockhouse 4y agoYes but it was a free trial where you are told up front that you will be charged if you don’t cancel within X number of days. It is not the fault of Apple or the App Store developers if the customer waits until X+n days to cancel it. They are not owed a refund.
- lapcat 4y agoYou seem to be speaking as if this were a purely legal issue, rather than an ethical one. Trustworthy businesses don't pull that kind of crap. And as the title of the article indicates, the raison d'être of Apple's App Store lockdown is allegedly to protect consumers. But it doesn't protect consumers.
- lockhouse 4y agoNo one is forcing the App Store devs in question to use this style of free trial. It is completely possible to offer a time limited trial that just ends and forces the user to pay for the software when time is up, or other monetization strategies such as freemium, subscription, or IAP for premium features.
- lapcat 4y ago> No one is forcing the App Store devs in question to use this style of free trial. They don't have to be forced. Scammers love this pricing model.
- tpmoney 4y ago>Do you want to get out of the trial and avoid getting charged? Well, that's a problem, an obstacle course for consumers. I'm sorry what? Settings -> Apple ID & Purchases -> Subscriptions -> Choose subscription -> Cancel Subscription Or if going into the phone settings to manage your app store subscriptions doesn't make sense to you, there's also App Store -> Account -> Subscriptions -> Choose subscription -> Cancel subscription It even tells you both when the subscription renews and how long you can keep using the features for even if you unsubscribe. Once you unsubscribe that's it. Since the purchases go through Apple, unsubscribing means the developer can't pull a Comcast and "forget". I even just now grabbed and app and started a "free 1 month trial" for their service. It shows up in the same subscription list and tells me when it will renew and how much it will charge me. If I tell it to cancel the free trial, it even lets me know that I can continue to access the trial services until the end of the trial period next month. How is any of that "an obstacle course"? Yes, I agree that it would be nice if trials defaulted to not auto-renewing or you were given a choice when starting a subscription. But managing what you're subscribed to is about as simple as it gets. Maybe the author is talking about an app that you subscribe to outside of the app store (e.g. Netflix or Spotify style). Certainly I can appreciate that you can lose track of your subscription there, but I fail to see how apple has any responsibility for "not protecting" you if you don't actually go through their processes for being protected.
- diebeforei485 4y agoApple makes it impossible for apps to link to this Settings page, correct? They do for other types of settings like detailed Notiication settings.
- lapcat 4y ago> Maybe the author is talking about an app that you subscribe to outside of the app store No. > I fail to see how apple has any responsibility for "not protecting" you if you don't actually go through their processes for being protected. This seems like a strange statement to me. How is Apple protecting you if you have to look out for everything yourself and make sure you don't forget to cancel one of your possibly many trials or subscriptions on a very specific date? People forget payment dates. This is totally common and normal. It's why many business have auto-pay, so you don't forget to pay your bill on time. In this case, though, Apple is more than happy to automatically take your payment, even if you didn't actually intend to pay. I'm not sure whether this implementation has changed recently or not, but it used to be — and may still be the case — that if you started a trial with an app, and then you deleted the app from your devices because you weren't interested in the app, the trial was still active and not cancelled.
- diebeforei485 4y agoThe whole reason why "free" trials auto-charge you at the end is because they know some people will forget to cancel. That's the whole point of a free trial (except those rare cases where they don't have a way to charge you). Now, this is fine and dandy for $2.99 app. But if the app is $59, it feels predatory. I think Apple should restrict the auto-charging aspect of trials for apps if the price being charged is above some threshold - let's say $20. For such apps, the trial should just end.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoIt's strange to me that someone is willing to say this. The $2.99 case is clearly predatory: > ... they know some people will forget to cancel. That's the whole point ...
- diebeforei485 4y agoI don't think so. They probably got at least $1 - $2 of value during the trial, so even if they don't cancel they're probably ok paying $2.99 for it. This is called "breakage" and is commonly used in financial modeling. Obviously $59 is a different story.
- throwaway-blaze 4y agoLegitimate developers want this. It's not that Apple should "restrict the auto-charging aspect", it's that Apple should offer other models for developers to utilize! There is no other way in the App Store to offer a free trial than to have an auto-charged amount (one time pay or subscription) at the end of it. I'm not saying Apple doesn't deserve a slice of the pie. They make it possible to seamlessly sell our app in 193 countries with varying tax and regulatory regimes, all at the click of a button. But the app store brings in billions in revenue to them, offering functionality like giving developers the ability to refund customers or more creative ways to charge for our software seems like a no brainer at this point...
- Zetobal 4y agoSorry but people likt that are the reason why there are instructions on shampoo bottles and hot warning labels on coffee to go cups. There are so many reasons to be critical of apple but that's not it.
- lapcat 4y ago> people likt that What am I likt? > There are so many reasons to be critical of apple but that's not it. What are the reasons?
- Zetobal 4y agoYou are what you are. The pettiness of your response tells everyone what they need to know about you, without even shaking hands. I am still mad they killed the old final cut... :(
- lapcat 4y ago> without even shaking hands Who can argue with a handshake? Anyway, you completely misunderstand me, because I actually want to abolish the App Store. I think "protecting consumers" is just Apple's pretense for lockdown and predatory rent extraction.
- Zetobal 4y ago...and now the weather.