3 ms·
> it certainly didn't look useless, though it aimed for the stars and probably wouldn't have met them That one sentence pretty much sums up why w3c is a bad st
by bawolff 4y ago
> it certainly didn't look useless, though it aimed for the stars and probably wouldn't have met them
That one sentence pretty much sums up why w3c is a bad standards body.
A standards body is not a research group. If you are aiming for the stars you are doing it wrong. A standards body is supposed to be doing the boring work of formalizing what is known to work well, not try and invent new untested things.
- WorldMaker 4y agoI think there is a large spectrum of standards bodies and working to productize outside research and aspirations is a part of some good standards bodies. Not a lot of people are calling WHATWG a bad standards body, but it is even worse at taking stuff directly out of Blink research and labeling it a draft standard with only a single implementation with sometimes seemingly very little study into its safety or long-term viability. I suppose there is a small distinction between Ivory Tower academic aspirations and research versus Walled Garden corporate aspirations and research, but at the end of the day it certainly feels the same, and I have more reasons, myself, to admire the academic aspirations that aren't tied to corporate interests and profit motives, but I can understand why some feel what Google and WHATWG is doing is better for the web because they start with that first "implementation" of their research instead of a chalkboard and a hope for a better web.
- willseth 4y agoIn order for a standards body to be successful, it must be possible to attempt standards and fail them before they leave the standards body. Otherwise they would lose credibility by publishing recommendations that won't get wide acceptance. XHTML2 is an example of a W3C WG exercising restraint. That is a good thing. You seem to think standards should only be built in reverse, which is essentially the WHATWG philosophy: Browser vendors implement something they think is useful, then try to negotiate to get it standardized. That's not bad per se, but it's limited and it's a different system of accountability.