5 ms·
Like the car tax idea, but free attracts the destitute and mentally ill. Offer the working poor and looking a transit pass instead.
by mixmastamyk 4y ago
Like the car tax idea, but free attracts the destitute and mentally ill. Offer the working poor and looking a transit pass instead.
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoOh, no, poor people might share the bus with me. Wouldn't want poor or mentally ill folks to do things like get to a doctors appointment, buy food, or visit family if they can't get there invisibly. /s. Now is when I'd like to remind you that you share spaces with mentally ill folks every single day and you don't notice a thing: A lot of destitute folks are disable and being destitute shouldn't mean that you have to have a lonely and hard life. And I'd also like to mention that you can both be destitute and have a job. You can be mentally ill and have a job.
- supersour 4y agoI think the parent comment is referring the homeless population which is violent or too public in their drug use/paraphernalia. Pick the right bus line in Vancouver. You will notice mentally ill, violent people, and it certainly discourages the public from using public transit. Now, will waiving a $2 fee change this meaningfully? Hard to day. But it's not helpful to ignore the problem.
- mixmastamyk 4y ago[dead]
- FormerBandmate 4y agoDC has a lot of dangerous homeless lunatics and criminals. Poor and mentally ill are euphemisms that also include many people who don’t fall into those categories
- mixmastamyk 4y agoYou’ve obviously never taken the LA metro episode of the walking dead. And the ignorance shows.
- Broken_Hippo 4y ago1. Of course I'm not going to reference a TV show. They aren't exactly known for realism. I've seen how they think poor people live, after all. 2. One line, a city, or a few riders isn't an issue with busses, be they with or without fares. That's society not taking care of folks. Plus, it would be ridiculous to think that it would be like this everywhere.. because it isn't like this everywhere now.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoIf you really want to help folks, get them a home and treatment first. Before inflicting your "utopia" on us transit riders.
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoHow are they supposed to get to treatment if there isn't a transit system to help them with that? And of course folks should have housing and treatment. The reason we have issues in some areas is because they aren't doing that. It doesn't meant that we shouldn't provide public transport to everyone that wants it, though. It is quite possible to do more than one thing at the same time.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoNo, some things are prerequisites to others. See project management. They are not going to inpatient treatment and housing voluntarily on the bus. Is the guy screaming obscenities at the air even aware of all his treatment options? They often need to be coerced, so trained individuals need to bring them there humanely. If they are just having bad luck, they will mostly likely need their belongings brought with them. Both these things point to van transportation with trained drivers. Not the city bus. You might spend some time thinking through the problem rather than casting aspersions. But one of those is easier, isn't it?
- mixmastamyk 4y ago
- dools 4y agoIf free attracts the "destitute and mentally ill", then probably we should be: 1) Not allowing anyone to be destitute and; 2) Also providing free and comprehensive mental health care
- Rebelgecko 4y agoIn my state there are both moral and legal roadblocks preventing that - except in extreme cases you can't force someone into treatment. You can write tickets for people who urinate or smoke on the trains but if someone has no assets there's really no point.
- supersour 4y agoI love this idea in theory, but recognize that you are moving the discussion from providing effective, safe, and equitable transportation towards solving homelessness. Both issues are important, but in the context of this article one must ask, "what is best for the majority of public transit users?". It's certainly possible that a $2 rate improves quality or security meaningful ways. The problem of "sketchy homeless and mentally ill people" is large enough that I personally prefer cycling over public transport when possible.
- dools 4y ago> I love this idea in theory, but recognize that you are moving the discussion from providing effective, safe, and equitable transportation towards solving homelessness. Sure, but if the objection to "public transport should be free" is "then there will be a bunch of scary homeless people there" shouldn't be "let's charge enough so they can't ride the bus" it should be "hey let's fix that too!" We can fix two things. More even!
- mixmastamyk 4y agoYou would think, but obviously not happening. This quarter measure (enacted before prerequisites) makes it worse for the working poor. And anyone who is in favor of transit, tourists too, who are important for the economy.