3 ms·
No low that advertisers won't stoop to, apparently. Incredible that they thought this was a good idea and that nobody put a stop to it. Maybe they figured that
by jacquesm 4y ago
No low that advertisers won't stoop to, apparently. Incredible that they thought this was a good idea and that nobody put a stop to it. Maybe they figured that whatever the penalty they'll make it up in sales?
- Waterluvian 4y agoI think it’s more thoughtlessness than anything. The ad contractor probably thought it was a cool campaign theme. Like when they throw sirens and car horns on radio ads. It’s not like those times that Hanes Underwear played the “brown noise” on AM radio. What a commute that was.
- bagels 4y agoIs this a joke?
- Waterluvian 4y agoThe brown noise is just an urban legend. But I’m confident that FOX isn’t calculating the trade-off for a fine. I think they just had an advertising contractor who didn’t know any better. Thought it was a cool angle for an ad.
- ibejoeb 4y agoI'm not even sure if there's a car audio system that could reproduce that range.
- jacquesm 4y agoIt's just DTMF I don't see why not. The base frequencies are all around the 1 KHz band which even the most boneheaded amp + speaker implementation should be able to reproduce.
- throwanem 4y agoI think the question is whether a car stereo could reproduce the so-called "brown note", which as I recall is supposedly somewhere around 12Hz. SAME BFSK uses frequencies iirc between 1 and 2 kHz, and the attention signal is an equal mix of 853 and 960 hertz.
- jacquesm 4y agoAh yes, you are right. Indeed, that's way lower than any stereo other than the weird ones that some kids build into the backs of their cars (note to self: do not lend your car out to junior employees that like subsonics, hi R. I know you're reading HN). Besides that, those would be filtered out on the transmitter end long before they were allowed to modulate the signal. Especially AM transmitters may do some pretty wild stuff when you drive them with frequencies that low, fair chance that you'll find that you hold them 'on' long enough that you're going to find the limits of either the power supply or the cooling system. Both on the high end (5KHz and up in theory, but more like 3KHz in practice) and on the low end (100Hz in theory, but you can go as low as 50 Hz in practice). So I highly doubt that story is true.
- antiterra 4y agoIt seems incredibly boneheaded like some production team possibly didn’t even know these tones were still a real & serious thing. Whatever oversight existed around content also completely failed. If there was evidence that the creators actually did a calculation to determine that the base fine of $144,000 was worth it, that’d be a nightmare for them
- duxup 4y agoYeah there had to be an adult along the line who said "guys this is a bad idea, these tones are for real emergencies".
- ryandrake 4y agoYou'd be surprised at what happens in a lot of companies, totally open loop, with no adult in the room to advise caution. Especially when all you're thinking about is "Lumbergh said this is my last chance--I gotta hit my marketing numbers this quarter or I'm out of a job!"
- scotty79 4y ago> ... didn’t even know these tones were still a real & serious thing. Why are they though?
- Retric 4y agoMany people have a TV or radio on as background noise. Even a minute warning for things tornadoes etc can save lives, but this only works if people associated these sounds with significant issues and start paying attention.