4 ms·
> Just so folks are aware: this kind of behavior doesn’t constitute a good faith purchase. If you suspect something is wrong, you aren’t allowed to push the ris
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> Just so folks are aware: this kind of behavior doesn’t constitute a good faith purchase. If you suspect something is wrong, you aren’t allowed to push the risk management off onto a retailer just because they aren’t as clued in as you are.
Based on what law? This seems to be importing the concept of good faith purchase that has relevance to the transfer of title (if the buyer doesn’t have a reasonable good-faith belief that the seller has good title to the goods being sold, and the seller only has voidable title, the buyer will receive only a title voidable by whomever the seller’s title was voidable by), but outside of its domain.
There is, that I am aware of, no generally-applicable rule (e.g., under the UCC) applicable to the sale of goods in the United States where the purchaser’s doubts about the seller’s representation as to the description of the item that they were selling would prevent the formation of a sale contract and the buyer’s right to inspect, reject, and return nonconforming goods under that contract. You may be confusing reasonable belief that the seller is actually offering the goods with reasonable belief that the seller actually intends to fulfill the contract, which are different issues.
Could you cite statute or case law on point, or reference a work which does?
- ajross 4y agoI defer to your jargon, but point out that you aren't, in fact, contradicting my point. So I'll flip the technique around: if Amazon were to read the upthread comment and refuse to honor the refund request, do you genuinely believe a court would compel them to? That's just silly, and you know it. If you order something you know is junk, that's on you, not Amazon.
- tomalpha 4y agoI’m guessing you’re referring to a jurisdiction within the US? In the UK the law is clear and explicit: it’s on the retailer (and not the manufacturer or wholesaler) to make sure the goods are “Fit for purpose”, “As described”, and of “Satisfactory quality”. There’s no wiggle room for “consumer guessed the goods might not be as described”. https://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/regulation/consumer-rights-act-aKJYx8n5KiSl https://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/regulation/consumer-... I can imagine there are some US jurisdictions where something similar is also true.
- kahnclusions 4y agoYou are making the statement that this is “fraud” and the commenter above has asked for legal references. The burden of proof is on you, because at this point you’re just making stuff up. But you can’t provide references. You haven’t even explained why you think this fits into the legal definition of fraud (hint: it doesn’t).
- dragonwriter 4y ago> if Amazon were to read the upthread comment and refuse to honor the refund request, do you genuinely believe a court would compel them to? Probably in most US jurisdictions; to my knowledge generally Amazon has failed in court where they have tried to escape obligations of sellers by pretending not to be retailer but a marketplace facilitator, and generally sellers are going to be obligated to refund if they accept money and don’t deliver the product represented. Under the UCC, for instance, the buyer would not only be entitled to refund, would also be entitled to make a good faith purchase of substitute goods matching what the seller represented, and also recover the difference between the purchase price of the substitute goods and the purchase price of the original goods (the latter already covered by the refund) or, even if they don’t “cover” with a substitute, recover the amount by which fair market price of a substitute at the time the buyer learned the goods were not as described exceeds the refund. (See, UCC Sections 2-711 through 2-713.) [0] > If you order something you know is junk Suspecting and actual knowledge are…different things. [0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/ucc/2 https://www.law.cornell.edu/ucc/2