3 ms·
I support an HN blackout, a Reddit blackout, and I would even be happy, if somewhat hesitant, about a Wikipedia blackout. But I absolutely do not support the c
by kevinalexbrown 15y ago
I support an HN blackout, a Reddit blackout, and I would even be happy, if somewhat hesitant, about a Wikipedia blackout.
But I absolutely do not support the conditional donation (excuse me, payment) to Wikipedia to get it to take a particular political stance, even if that stance concerns its long term survival. This is worse than "donate to a politician, hope they vote your way" -- this is "pay Wikipedia money if and only if it performs a specific action on a specific date and time." That goes so far against why I love Wikipedia, and why it performs such a unique service. Small, tight teams, no strings attached donations, unfettered public input. Those are things worth preserving and fighting for, but not at the cost of those things themselves.
I would hope Wikipedia returns the money or donates it to some other worthy cause in the event of a blackout. Culture of an institution is a delicate thing, and where and, perhaps more importantly, why you get your money can dramatically shift that culture one way or another. Wikipedia has a great culture. Is that really worth risking?
- studentrob 15y agoI agree. Money should not be required for an org to do the right thing, esp when it costs $0 (this probably saves them money!)
- Joakal 15y agoI believe they have already allowed restricted donations for years, yet discourage it due to overhead. They can not retake restricted donations and give it to a worthy cause. They can only use it as specified or refund it.
- sliverstorm 15y agoYea, this string of "give cash to Wikipedia to motivate them" is starting to leave a sour taste in my mouth. How long before they refuse to do things just to stimulate a new wave of cash?
- redthrowaway 15y agoAgreed. I made my donation to the WMF during their last fundraising round, and I'm participating in the discussions about a blackout. That's the extent of the influence I feel comfortable attempting to exert. The proposal comes from the right place, but it goes against everything Wikipedia stands for.