3 ms·
Does the entire ownership just switch over to the litigants? This should happen more often imho (albeit in a more thoughtful fashion that I have time to addres
by anigbrowl 4y ago
Does the entire ownership just switch over to the litigants?
This should happen more often imho (albeit in a more thoughtful fashion that I have time to address in this HN comment). If you choose to invest in a company that profits from negative externalities and those later catch up with the firm, your cash cow may get confiscated.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoYou can argue negative externalities for every business though.
- anigbrowl 4y agoYou can, but you won't necessarily win in court.
- henriquez 4y agoI guess it really boils down to whether you can argue and _prove_ negative externalities with a preponderance of evidence in court.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoYou can never prove negative externalities though, since there are too many confounding variables. Justice in this area is challenging, because so many are incentivized to use the law to rob others.
- sidewndr46 4y agoI've always felt it made more sense to just print up a bunch of new shares. Basically all Delaware incorporated businesses have shares (even those not publicly traded) in their charter. Just print up 99x the current number of shares and hand them out appropriately to settle claims. The existing shareholders wind up with around 1% of their value, which seems more than fair enough in all cases.
- elefanten 4y agoWhy should investors be “punished” for having made a bad investment? Are the fines (which directly impair financial performance), reputation damage (indirectly impairs) and operational obstacles (directly and indirectly), not sufficient? The value of the investment falls compared to a world where the bad behavior never took place. Investors will be incentivized to move their investment elsewhere. Everyone is disincentivized from said behavior and others are deterred from investing in ventures that seem likely to repeat that behavior. What if you meticulously invest in the most pro-social / low-externality businesses, but it turns out management were egregiously comically evil and lied about everything? Should you be “punished” (again, beyond the financial damage to your investment) for the bad luck? Or because you had limited time / information for due diligence?