3 ms·
The GP was clearly talking about whole networks, not just the hardware vendors, if I read that different than the GP intended I'll wait for their correction. O
by jacquesm 4y ago
The GP was clearly talking about whole networks, not just the hardware vendors, if I read that different than the GP intended I'll wait for their correction.
One of the problems that I've seen in practice that with the degree of virtualization at play that it has at the same time become much more easy to in principle be guaranteed 100% independence and in practice it has become much harder to verify that this is the case because of all of the abstraction layers underneath the topology. One of my customers specializes in software that allows one to make such guarantees and this is a non-trivial problem, to put it mildly, especially when the situation becomes more dynamic due to outages from various causes.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoSounds like a great place for a specialized insurance company to be the middle man
- iso1631 4y agoIn London I can literally follow the map from manhole to manhole, exchange to exchange. It's dark fibre so I can flash a light down it and a colleague can see it emerge at the other end. Now it's possible they don't follow the map and still make it to the other end, but it's pretty unlikely. Sometimes of course you have to make judgement calls. From one location near Slough I have a BT EAD2 back to my building a few miles away. I know the route into my building, I can see the cables with my own eyes going in different directions. BT tell me which exchanges those cables goto, and provide me with a map into the field at a 1000:1 scale showing the cables coming in down a shared path. Sure it's possible BT are lying, but it's unlikely. Only use that location sporadically, and when I do it's a managed location, so I can accept the risk of a digger on the ground. Another location in Norfolk, two BTNet lines, going to two different exchanges. They meet at the edge of the farm and go up the same trunk. That's fine, I can physically control the single point of failure there too, although if peering between BT and my network fails then I'm screwed, but I have a separate pinnacom circuit in a crunch. Now obviously some failure become far harder to mitigate. A failure of the Thames Barrier would cause a hell of a lot of problems in Docklands, I'm not sure if any circuits in/out of places like telehouse, sovhouse, etc will remain. Cross that bridge etc. Whether my electricity provider will remain with a loss of the internet is another matter, so then it comes down to how much oil there in in the generators, and the generators of any repeaters on the routes of my network. However the much easier to avoid is the problem of some shitty stacked switch the salesman says will always work.
- oarsinsync 4y ago> One of the problems that I've seen in practice that with the degree of virtualization at play If you’re buying SDN WAN solutions, you get what you get. If you’re buying specific paths, you get what you pay for.