6 ms·
>You just have to convince the jury, regardless of what is actually true. More people need to understand that truth and fact are two seemingly similar but actu
by Dalewyn 4y ago
>You just have to convince the jury, regardless of what is actually true.
More people need to understand that truth and fact are two seemingly similar but actually very different things.
Truth is whatever the majority of people agree on.
Fact is whatever the universe declares and understood by us as best we can.
You can factually have two apples on a plate, but if the majority of people say there is only one apple on the plate the truth is there is only one apple on the plate.
- fsh 4y agoThat is a very unusual definition. Wikipedia defines truth as "the property of being in accord with fact or reality". In that sense truth exists independently of what people agree on.
- FireBeyond 4y agoWe're in civil court, where the balance of probability applies. It's also civil court that is being used to try this farcical "create a company with the intent of filing bankruptcy two days later to ... deflect ... liability". So civil court rules are good enough for the latter, but unacceptable for the former?
- anonuser123456 4y agoThat definition comes from someone that’s never been to the gulag or re-education camp.
- thfuran 4y agoThat isn't true.
- Dalewyn 4y agoThe fact of the matter is the Earth orbits around the Sun which orbits around the galactic core of the Milky Way which is hurtling through the universe. The truth of the matter is we have at various points in time considered: Earth being at the center of the universe as truth. Earth orbiting around the Sun as truth. The fact remains unchanged, regardless of our ability to understand or observe. The truth changes according to what the majority believes is true at a given point in time.
- chordalkeyboard 4y ago> The truth changes according to what the majority believes is true at a given point in time. benchmarking 'truth' to majority opinion is quite problematic. For one thing, you'd be asserting that a minority in possession of accurate facts had failed to grasp the truth of the matter, until their facts became common knowledge, meaning they weren't 'true' until they were believed.
- Dalewyn 4y agoI mean, isn't that precisely how "truth" works? The minority are branded heretics and crazies (especially in this age of division but also throughout history) unless it turns out they were on to something and the common consensus shifts. Truth might as well be synonymous with common consensus, it has nothing to do with facts. To use the Earth and Sun example again, when Galileo said "And yet [the Earth] moves."[1] he meant that truths and facts do not care for the other. The Church and the world-at-large might say the truth is the Sun orbits the Earth, but the fact is the Earth orbits the Sun. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_yet_it_moves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_yet_it_moves
- chordalkeyboard 4y ago> Truth might as well be synonymous with common consensus, it has nothing to do with facts. this isn't what normal people mean when they say 'truth', usually they mean what you're referring to as 'facts.' > he meant that truths and facts do not care for the other. The Church and the world-at-large might say the truth is the Sun orbits the Earth, but the fact is the Earth orbits the Sun. Galileo meant that the truth of the matter doesn't care for public opinion.
- Dalewyn 4y ago>this isn't what normal people mean when they say 'truth', usually they mean what you're referring to as 'facts.' The specific terms used aren't necessarily contrary to the point I am making. What people consider as "truths" or "facts" (not actual facts but so-called "facts") have nothing to do with actual facts or reality at large. >Galileo meant that the truth of the matter doesn't care for public opinion. That can just as easily be rephrased as: Facts of the matter don't care for truths of the matter.
- sideshowb 4y agoThat is wrong both in truth and fact