3 ms·
> Structural racism is a vague idea No, its not, though like any term that enters wide use there is lots of sloppy use (and like most terms that are important
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> Structural racism is a vague idea
No, its not, though like any term that enters wide use there is lots of sloppy use (and like most terms that are important in politically-charged debates, a substantial portion of that sloppy use is deliberate and designed to undermine the concept.)
> to support race essentialist policies.
It is usually used, in the context of policy advocacy (it is used extensively outside that context, with the same meaning) in advocating policies which are contingent on current material conditions (which may be directly race-blind or race-conscious), rather than race-essentialist. (In fact, to describe the policies as race-essentialist is to impute the present difference in material conditions that structural racism attributes to socio-legal structures as instead being an inherent product of race, which is itself race-essentialist and, given the nature of the material difference, racist in the individual rather than structural sense.)
- peanutcrisis 4y agoPlease provide a definition for the term. From reading the positions on various advocates of this term, the use is indeed sloppy and often asserted without evidence. I do not understand your second paragraph, could you elaborately more concisely please?
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Please provide a definition for the term. The totality of mutually reinforcing systems of housing, education, employment, earnings, benefits, credit, media, health care, and criminal justice which reinforce racially/ethnically [0] discriminatory beliefs, values, and distribution of resources. [1] > I do not understand your second paragraph, could you elaborately more concisely please? “Race essentialism” is the belief that races are clearly genetically distinct groups with fundamental and essentially immutable differences in capacities between groups that are more significant than the differences within groups, such that (among other things) differences in outcomes under fair treatment between races are immutable. “Structural racism” is typically part of the argument for policies that address current unequal conditions that are reinforced by existing structures, particularly by removing those structures. It is, in a way, the polar opposite of race essentialism, and the strong reaction against it by active racists is because it both provides an alternative explanation to race essentialism as to why outcomes in a system without overt, direct discrimination, particularly one which had such discrimination in the past, could systematically and persistently differ by race that does not rely on race essentialism and a direction as to how to correct that. [0] consistent with the more general use of “racism” to describe discrimination and bigotry by either what is conventionally described as “race” or “ethnicity”, the distinction of which is artificial and itself, in origin, a product of race essentialist ideologies. [1] This definition is a slight rephrasing (to serve more as a definition than a description) from Bailey ZD, Krieger N, Agénor M, et al. “Structural racism and health inequities in the USA: evidence and interventions.” Lancet. 2017;389(10077):1453–1463.