3 ms·
You got a D-D fusion plant in your pocket, or are you just happy to see me? The way ITER is planning to get tritium is by bombarding a lithium lining with neut
by hinkley 4y ago
You got a D-D fusion plant in your pocket, or are you just happy to see me?
The way ITER is planning to get tritium is by bombarding a lithium lining with neutrons. But the neutrons tend to miss lithium and so they’re using a beryllium lining on top of that to multiply neutrons. So you’re making a tritium gas that’s on the wrong side of a very expensive barrier, how are you going to harvest that from a power plant that’s supposed to run 24 hours a day?
Slowing neutrons is one thing. You can do that with plentiful stuff. Creating new ones means donor material. You’re consuming the beryllium. Almost nobody produces beryllium, and I don’t think 400k tons of the ore - not beryllium, ore - is going to be sufficient for a consumable. A highly toxic, easily oxidized one at that.
ETA: the reaction for neutron multiplication using beryllium apparently splits the beryllium into a neutron and two helium. The lithium reaction produces tritium and more helium.
- ben_w 4y ago> You got a D-D fusion plant in your pocket, or are you just happy to see me? No, but it's (genuinely) been on my to-do list for while. But bigger than a pocket, more like very large rucksack at best, probably more like CRT monitor sized. > So you’re making a tritium gas that’s on the wrong side of a very expensive barrier, how are you going to harvest that from a power plant that’s supposed to run 24 hours a day? No idea, but I used to live in Cambridge, and IIRC one of locals did his PhD on neutron induced atom dislocation within metallic crystals specifically with regard to the engineering of fusion reactors, so I can say with a certain level of confidence both that (a) I wouldn't understand the answer and (b) that it wouldn't fit into this comment box.
- hinkley 4y agoI had a friend in college who worked with a physicist on femtosecond lasers. What’s a femtosecond, I said. It was about fifteen to twenty years before they were commercialized. If your friend did his PhD on something then the clock might have started ticking on that tech but many, many things that work in a lab never get used to make products or medicines. For everything else it takes around twenty years, which is a huge fraction of 30.
- ben_w 4y agoI moved there in 2007, and moved away in 2017. This would've been the earlier part of that period, given the geek pub didn't really recover that reputation after the fire in 2010.