2 ms·
> We recommend that WHO, as part of the PHEIC assessment process, also decides on an optimal response strategy, for example elimination [e.g. Zero Covid], suppr
by walterbell 4y ago
> We recommend that WHO, as part of the PHEIC assessment process, also decides on an optimal response strategy, for example elimination [e.g. Zero Covid], suppression [e.g. mobility restrictions], or mitigation.
This would give WHO the power to unilaterally declare an emergency and a response that must be enforced by all countries globally, without regard to local context. This is the same WHO that ignored its own experts and declared a monkeypox PHEIC anyway, https://www.science.org/content/article/declaring-monkeypox-an-international-emergency-who-chief-rejects-expert-panels-advice https://www.science.org/content/article/declaring-monkeypox-...
> The World Health Organization (WHO) today declared the global spread of monkeypox a Public Health Emergency of International Concern (PHEIC), even though a special advisory committee again declined to recommend the action. This is the first time since the PHEIC system was created in 2005 that the agency has made such a declaration without the panel’s endorsement. “This is big, unprecedented decision-making by the director general,” says Clare Wenham, a global health expert at the London School of Economics who has studied the history of PHEICs.
If the Lancet recommendations were followed, countries would have spent 2022 responding to a "monkeypox emergency", including possible travel restrictions, lockdowns, etc.
> We declare no competing interests.
Other than advocating for W.H.O to override the elected officials and medical professionals of every nation-state?
The Lancet neglected to mention WHO negotiations in progress: (a) modification of existing (2005) international health regulations, and (b) new treaty to grant expanded powers to WHO. More details at http://StopTheWho.com http://StopTheWho.com, which is obviously biased, but objective coverage of this important topic is almost non-existent.
> The WHO is currently overseeing negotiations that are designed to convince its 194 member nations to adopt amendments to the International Health Regulations as well as to adopt a legally-binding “Pandemic Treaty.” These agreements, if adopted, would surrender health related sovereignty over to the WHO ... Agreement by a simple majority of the 194 member nations is all that is needed to adopt the amendments .. to an existing agreement.
The best primary sources are WHO videos on the treaty negotiations, which include testimony from the health ministers of every country. WHO site for new pandemic treaty: https://inb.who.int/ https://inb.who.int/
EU law journal with some objective analysis of the proposed amendments. https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-far-reaching-us-proposals-to-amend-the-international-health-regulations-at-the-upcoming-75th-world-health-assembly-a-call-for-attention/ https://www.ejiltalk.org/the-far-reaching-us-proposals-to-am...
> If WHO’s powers are extended in this way, is there a need to also answer the question quis custodiet ipsos custodes (who guards the guards?), and to thus set up mechanisms ensuring that WHO complies with its obligations under the IHR and its Constitution, as well as its responsibilities for human rights deriving from customary international human rights law?