4 ms·
The caller/sender always pays something, but in the US the recipient pays extra for their technology, and in most of Europe, the caller/sender pays and so the n
by toast0 4y ago
The caller/sender always pays something, but in the US the recipient pays extra for their technology, and in most of Europe, the caller/sender pays and so the numbering plan makes it easy to identify what calls will cost more. (Although, there are German sims setup to use landline numbers so that callers can pay landline rates, presumably the recipient pays for calls in both directions on those sims?)
The US environment led to prices trending to under a penny to send an sms or make a one minute phone call. IIRC, FCC rules say telephone carriers can no longer charge other telephone carriers for calls at all, the wholesale price is zero (+ connection costs).
On the other hand, in Europe, sending an SMS or calling a mobile phone for a minute is closer to 10-20 cents. That's a lot costlier, and then you've got a lot more languages to support, and different payment preferences per country. Easier to just target English and the US.
- lxgr 4y ago> there are German sims setup to use landline numbers so that callers can pay landline rates, presumably the recipient pays for calls in both directions on those sims? The interconnection rates used to be an important source of income for mobile operators (some of them would even pay their prepaid users, not paying any monthly fee, a bonus per incoming minute of calls!), but these days, mobile and landline interconnect rates have almost converged, as far as I can tell.
- toast0 4y agoIf you look at Twilio's pricing [1], because it's easy to link to and mostly reasonable, it's 0.0150 USD/min to landlines, and 0.2380 USD/min to mobile phones (calls to EPlus are higher). That's 15x the cost, far from converged. Although, I do see if you're calling from EEA, the price drops down to 0.04 USD/min, which is much closer, so that's close to convergence. [1] https://www.twilio.com/voice/pricing/de https://www.twilio.com/voice/pricing/de
- lxgr 4y agoMobile terminated calls have interconnection fees no higher than 0.4 cents per minute in Germany (i.e. 0.004 EUR!), with no distinction between the three networks. E-Plus also hasn't existed as an independent entity for quite some years now; they were acquired by Telefonica/O2 in 2014. Seems like Twilio is charging quite the margin there, based on vastly outdated pricing...
- loa_in_ 4y ago> in the US the recipient pays extra for their technology I don't understand what do you mean by that. If the sender and recipient are both in US how does this make sense?
- toast0 4y agoThe baseline is landline calling, for landline, caller pays (unless it's toll free, or other reversed charging). If you call outside your local area, that's a bigger charge, at least historically. But, cell phones are more expensive to run than landlines (historically, anyway), so the question becomes who pays that extra expense when someone calls a cell phone. You can do caller pays, and then typically have mobile numbers in a separate part of the numbering plan and cell phones receive free incoming calls; or you can do recipient pays and mobile numbers are usually mixed into the numbering plans and cell phones have to pay for incoming calls. As time goes by, costs go down, but caller pays carriers have an income stream from incoming calls that's harder to drive down with competition. Few people are going to switch carriers so it's less expensive for others to call them. Especially if retail plans tend to bundle things. But for recipient pays carriers, there is competition among carriers to make it less expensive for their customers to receive calls, and now most US carriers offer unlimited talk and text on retail plans on most plans, even low cost plans.
- detaro 4y ago> now most US carriers offer unlimited talk and text on retail plans on most plans, even low cost plans. But that's not something particularly unique to the US?
- toast0 4y agoNo, it's not. But the difference is in the caller pays model, there's no mechanism to reduce the inter-carrier cost. Retail cell phone carriers can hide that cost from their users, because balance of calling usually works out --- most users probably get about as many incoming call minutes from other carriers as outgoing call minutes to other carriers, so revenue from calls roughly matches costs from calls. For voip carriers it's different --- they can't charge other carriers a high rate for incoming calls (because voip is low cost), and they have to pay mobile carriers a high rate to terminate calls. So, retail cell phone users end up in the same boat of low cost "unlimited" calling, but business users have to pay 10-20 cents a minute (depending on the country and the tariffs allowed) High cost is an effective anti-spam technique, but it also raises costs for legitimate business uses.
- pshirshov 4y ago10-20 cents? I'm paying €8 for 10000 minutes, 10000 texts and 100Gb of traffic per month.
- toast0 4y agoThat's for bundled retail sim right? I'm talking unbundled wholesale.