4 ms·
> As an Op-Ed columnist, Mr. Krugman clearly has the freedom to call out what he thinks is a lie. My question for readers is: should news reporters do the same?
by pavel_lishin 15y ago
> As an Op-Ed columnist, Mr. Krugman clearly has the freedom to call out what he thinks is a lie. My question for readers is: should news reporters do the same?
It's not just a lie, it's a provably false statement. In fact, it might not even be an intentional lie - if Romney truly believed that he heard Obama apologizing for America, he wouldn't be lying, but he would be making a false statement.
If a newspaper is printing lies and provably false statements, isn't that just fiction?
- sliverstorm 15y agoOnly if the newspaper is asserting those lies or statements. There is nothing wrong with a newspaper reporting someone as saying X, even if X is untrue, imo.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoSure, but at that point they're effectively a library of press releases, and offer no added value, other than aggregating all the press releases in one place, I guess.
- Cadsby 15y agoPerhaps, but if their statements are demonstrably false then the Newspaper has, as a basic principle of journalistic integrity, an obligation to point that what was quoted is factual untrue. Being a mouthpiece for self-serving falsehoods is exactly why so many people have little to no respect for Newspapers anymore.
- GFKjunior 15y agoThe line about Krugman made me laugh. Just a year ago when I was a finance and econ student there was a big controversy because Krugman would publish an article on the NYT and within minutes there would be several comments refuting all his points. Many even provided PHD-like citations that clearly showed Krugman lied. That was one of the first times the NYT limited comments to less than 100 words, that way arguments could not be made.
- hindsightbias 15y agoYou are a liar. I just checked both his op-ed and blog posts and there are several comments of several 100 words.
- glhaynes 15y agoCan you provide any citation for this?