6 ms·
You can get a lot more than 1kWh per day from solar charging. It’s really popular on motor homes and narrow boats etc because you can actually get significant
by Retric 4y ago
You can get a lot more than 1kWh per day from solar charging. It’s really popular on motor homes and narrow boats etc because you can actually get significant amounts of power.
Parking in full sun in an area with significant solar power isn’t something Everyone does, but for those who do a solar car could average 5kWh per day at 20+c/kWh for electricity and more for fast charging that’s ~1$/ day of electricity and 3600$ over 10 years. However EV’s can have significant discharge when parked, being able to trickle charge enough to offset this is worth vastly more than the value of the electricity you are supplying.
A solar powered EV isn’t a great investment, but with cars lasting 25 years the economics can work out. Especially if the car can directly use solar power and thus reduce the number of charge/discharge cycles.
PS: National average is currently 16c/kWh some states are much higher than this. Again people who have cheap electricity aren’t the target audience.
- SideQuark 4y ago>5kWh per day at 20c/kWh A standard perfectly installed 400W solar panel gets around 1.8 kWh a day [1]. Avg US electricity costs are 16c/kWh [2]. I think you vastly overstated the above. So some may get better, but ~half of people will get worse. So I'd guess this is actually under $0.30/day. >1$/ day of electricity and 3600$ over 10 years. ... i.e., if you park in perfect sun all day, every day, and there's no weather or seasonal changes, i.e., this is not possible. Picking a daily perfect value and assuming that value scales to all days is not a good estimate. Maybe, if someone is quite diligent and lucky, they will get 1/2 of the perfect value over time. So I'm at $0.30 per day at best, avg maybe $0.15 per day over 10 years, i.e., under $550 for 10 years. And of course now your solar panels are slightly degreaded, slightly less power generated, and, if you're lucky, you might get another 10 years out of them (they're on a car after all). So for a price of $2000, up front, for 20 years, you get $1k return. Of course, if you invested that $2K at 5% over 20 years you have $5300. So, not even close to being a good value. [1] https://www.solar.com/learn/how-much-energy-does-a-solar-panel-produce/ https://www.solar.com/learn/how-much-energy-does-a-solar-pan... [2] https://www.bls.gov/regions/midwest/data/averageenergyprices_selectedareas_table.htm https://www.bls.gov/regions/midwest/data/averageenergyprices...
- Retric 4y agoJustify why you think you can only stick a single 400W panel on a car. Cars are large 3D objects, you aren’t going to get nearly as much power from side panels or the dashboard as the roof, but solar panels are cheap. Also, Mount Signal Solar had a 29.7%(average 2015–2017) capacity factor from it’s solar panels. That’s averaging 2.85kWh per day across multiple years from a single 400W panel. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mount_Signal_Solar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mount_Signal_Solar Obviously most cars would never approach that but buyers are going to self select for better areas. How effective this would be in Alaska is irrelevant if nobody buys it in Alaska. California has both lots of sun, high electricity prices, and many people parking outside of shade. Hawaii doesn’t get quite as much sun, but is paying 45.4c/kWh right now.
- macspoofing 4y ago>Justify why you think you can only stick a single 400W panel on a car. Because a 400W solar panel is basically the size of a car (~1mX2m). And under IDEAL CONDITIONS, you're looking at a 150 to 250 hour charge [1] ... and you're not going to get ideal conditions most of the time. Maybe you can stick 5 of those panels on a trailer and have the EV haul that around, and now you've improved your charging time from 250 hours to 50 hours (still, under ideal conditions) ... congrats, you still made negligible difference in extending EV range or making it practical. >Cars are large 3D objects, you aren’t going to get nearly as much power from side panels or the dashboard as the roof ... You're guaranteed to get 0 power from the sides that aren't facing the sun. So now you're horribly complicating the manufacturing process and increasing the EV price, all for an approach that would provide, at best, miniscule improvement to range. >How effective this would be in Alaska is irrelevant if nobody buys it in Alaska. It won't work in California either. But let's try something else ... with EV manufacturers being obsessed with squeezing out every km of range, why do you think approximately 0 of them are actually building an EV with built-in solar panels? What do you know, that they don't? [1] Assuming a 60kWh-100kWh battery and dividing by 400W = 150h to 250h
- mattmaroon 4y agoHa, nobody's camper has 2kw solar on the roof. You've got a huge installation if you've got half that. Your roof has ACs, skylights, vents, ect to work around. I've got a 35' travel trailer I live in 4 months a year (and that's close to as bit as they get) and I think I could get 1,200w up there if I really squeezed. I took some measurements because I'm planning to. RVs are often parked in full sun at least, but even then. I think I'd be lucky to get more than 5kwhh a day. Which is great for me as long as I'm not running the ACs. But that would not even remotely account for the extra drag it put on an EV to trailer it ten miles. There've been attempts to make "solar paint" for cars, which would be lovely if possible, but even then I think the economic argument will essentially never work out when you factor in time value of money. As the original article said, the economics will likely always be much better for putting the solar panels on your house and charging at home.
- brigade 4y agoMotor homes and boats have a lot more surface area than a car roof. The 1kWh/day is based on the two actual cars with a solar roof, which have a ~200W capacity. Even a paper optimistic about solar cars estimates that doubling that to 2kWh/day needs 800W of solar panels installed on every available surface of a car, i.e. also on the hood and doors. [1] [1] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/349656294_Future_Options_for_Lightweight_Photovoltaic_Modules_in_Electrical_Passenger_Cars https://www.researchgate.net/publication/349656294_Future_Op...
- rightbyte 4y agoMotor homes and boats use the solar panels to charge the utility batteries not doing propulsion. > Especially if the car can directly use solar power and thus reduce the number of charge/discharge cycles. There is no way the extra weight won't offset that. Perpetual solar EVs look more like bikes than cars.
- Retric 4y ago> There is no way the extra weight won't offset that. Solar is surprisingly lightweight the 1kW per day Hyundi solar roof was installed in a 60 lb panel. That’s slightly heavier than a steel roof, but not by that much especially compared to a 4,414 lbs. car. Their next designs looks to be adding a solar front trunk and easily doubling output.
- rightbyte 4y agoI guess the steel has a purpose though? Like, the solar panel does not replace the structural strength of the steel sheet.
- mikestew 4y agoIt’s really popular on motor homes and narrow boats etc because you can actually get significant amounts of power. It's really popular because it's solar or nothing in a lot of cases. That, and those large, flat surfaces make for convenient mounting on a surface that otherwise isn't getting used. But it most certainly is not because it generates "significant amounts of power". I have to wonder how many RV and boat owners you've actually spoken with to come to that conclusion. but for those who do a solar car could average 5kWh per day I'm not even going to bother with doing the math to refute that, as that is laughable fantasy.
- fakedang 4y ago> A solar powered EV isn’t a great investment, but with cars lasting 25 years the economics can work out. Especially if the car can directly use solar power and thus reduce the number of charge/discharge cycles. I'm not going to retain my EV for 25 years, simply because I'm expecting more innovation to happen in the EV space. But I'll be damned if I'm not buying my motor home or boat to last for at least 2 decades. That's the key difference.
- jjav 4y ago> It’s really popular on motor homes and narrow boats etc because you can actually get significant amounts of power. Depends what you mean by significant I suppose, but unless you have tons of square footage for panels (like the whole roof of a house), you're not getting a lot of power from solar. Have you done solar installations and tried to live off the power they generate? It all sounds great until you do the math and realize how little power you have. I have both a boat and a travel trailer and spend occasional time living off the grid on both. You quickly learn to be very frugal on power. > a solar car could average 5kWh per day How much roof surface area you'd need for that? Is there a car large enough?