3 ms·
> ”Most of us,” she said, “are just making something slightly better than what already exists.” It occurred to me yesterday that Flyer (1903) to Viking (1976)
by 082349872349872 4y ago
> ”Most of us,” she said, “are just making something slightly better than what already exists.”
It occurred to me yesterday that Flyer (1903) to Viking (1976) was only ~7 decades, and we're currently at Eniac (1945) + 78.
That said, I think the aerospace people had a far, far better grasp of the underlying principles of their domains than we do of ours, so there's still hope for major advances in software.
(OTOH, judging by his published output, Luca Cardelli believes he had Von Neumann programming all figured out by the turn of the century — so that hope may be slim)
- danjac 4y agoMaybe, but how much advancement has been seen in aerospace 1977-2023 compared to 1903-1976?
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoI actually think we’ve done pretty well considering there are physical limits. Space we’ve obviously done really well. But even in commercial aviation we have planes carrying more passengers that use less fuel, less crew, and have far better safety records than 1976. And tickets are much cheaper as well.
- danjac 4y agoTrue, but the advancements seem incremental rather than revolutionary (i.e. compared to the first half of the 20th century)
- tsimionescu 4y agoWhile interesting to compare, I think ultimately progress can never be reflected to maintain some particular level. I think a better picture is that given some initial state X, and a new discovery D, there is another state Y that we can reach in some amount of time T by exploring all consequences of that discovery in the context of X. If no new discoveries arise before we reach state Y, progress will essentially halt entirely, until some random process happens to produce a new discovery. I believe we are now getting closer to finishing the exploration of a series of extraordinary discoveries that happened in the 1900s-1940s or so, and have so far been unlucky in making any completely new discovery, so our rate of progress as we get near to a state Y is slowing down. Edit: typos
- trimbo 4y agoMaybe the correct comparison for computing is ENIAC to Viking. We had a computer the size of a room and then sent one to Mars in just 31 years