4 ms·
I love Ars Technica. They fairly consistently have the best journalism of any mainstream-oriented tech news site, work hard to stay unbiased (though don't alway
by freehunter 15y ago
I love Ars Technica. They fairly consistently have the best journalism of any mainstream-oriented tech news site, work hard to stay unbiased (though don't always achieve that 100%), and hire quality writers.
That being said, I don't like this piece. It's emotional, and even as they admit, hyperbolic. Unless "crazy freetards" is a word the MPAA used in their posting, I don't see a legitimate reason for Ars to use it. The bill might be absolutely freaking insane, but I don't read Ars to be told that, I read Ars to be informed about the issue.
I understand their passion, their disgust, and their defensiveness. I share their sentiments exactly. I just don't understand why that should undermine their professionalism.
- Doches 15y agoI disagree. This comes across as a fantastic editorial, with just the right amount of frankness ("The thing is, we're really on the MPAA's side; they just don't realize it.") to make me sit up and take them seriously. My only quibble is that it's filed as a news piece, rather than the editorial it so clearly is. This isn't news; it's meta-news.
- chernevik 15y agoBut they might better have first ribbonized the complaining article: MPAA: "Sanchez’s main argument is that theft has a negligible economic impact – only some inefficiency – because theft is beneficial" Sanchez (http://www.cato-at-liberty.org/how-copyright-industries-con-congress/ http://www.cato-at-liberty.org/how-copyright-industries-con-...): "Does that mean online piracy is harmless? Of course not. But the harm is a dynamic loss in allocative efficiency, which is much harder to quantify. That is, in the cases where a consumer would have been willing to buy an illicitly downloaded movie, album, or software program, we want the market to be accurately signalling demand for the products people value, rather than whatever less-valued use that money gets spent on instead." MPAA: "Extending this argument, shoplifting has no economic impact since shoplifters can spend the money they “saved” on other products . . ." Sanchez: "In many cases—I’ve seen research suggesting it’s about 80 percent for music—a U.S. consumer would not have otherwise purchased an illicitly downloaded song or movie if piracy were not an option. Here, the result is actually pure consumer surplus: The downloader enjoys the benefit, and the producer loses nothing." (The problem with the shoplifting analogy: those pinched Mach 3 razor blades are gone, and must be restocked at some cost. And whomever uses the pinched razors, needs razors of some kind, so the theft does diminish revenue. Theft of copyright doesn't force restocking to enable a legit sale, and Sanchez is suggesting that the thief wouldn't have been a legit sale in the first place.) MPAA: "Sanchez argued against Congressional passage of the Stop Online Piracy Act, basing his reasoning on his own faulty logic that content theft and counterfeiting don’t cause widespread economic pain" Sanchez: "I’ve yet to encounter a technically clueful person who believes the Stop Online Piracy Act will actually do anything to meaningfully reduce—let alone “stop”—online piracy, and so I haven’t bothered writing much about the absurd numbers . . . . If the proposed solution just won’t work, after all, why bother quibbling about the magnitude of the problem? But . . . . I’m offended to see bad data invoked so routinely and brazenly, on general principle" MPAA: "Ars Technica, a tech blog with a long history of challenging efforts to curb content theft. . . . " In light of the above, we're content to let the reader consider the source. We do thank the MPAA for correcting their spelling of our name (see screenshot w/ 'Arts Technica'), and suggest their analysis is every bit as good as their proof reading.
- timwiseman 15y agoArsTechnica tends to classify itself as a professional blog. While it certainly reports the news, they have for a long time freely intermixed opinion, reviews, and political commentary with the news, though they generally go out of their way to make certain that it is easily distinguished from the facts. This was an excellent news piece with some editorializing both presenting facts that occurred along with the opinion of one of Ars' editors. I found it a highly interesting piece from an outstandin organization.