3 ms·
Scenario I: The too-badly-damaged-to-properly-detonate nuclear warhead is now a piece (or maybe lots of pieces) of dangerous radioactive junk. Bad. But many
by bell-cot 4y ago
Scenario I: The too-badly-damaged-to-properly-detonate nuclear warhead is now a piece (or maybe lots of pieces) of dangerous radioactive junk. Bad. But many orders of magnitude less bad than a successful nuclear detonation would have been.
Scenario II: Your defenses knocked out the warhead's delivery system, but did not damage the actual (small, tough) nuclear warhead or its control systems badly enough to disable those. My bet is that the standard design spec. is "when fully armed and near-ish to the target(s), if a critical failure occurs in the delivery system, then detonate immediately". Hopefully your missile defenses intercepted it far, far away from anything that you care much about.
- ergonaught 4y agoI have visions of nuclear weapons systems programmers reading Scenario II and going, "Ohhhh, damn, why didn't we think of that?" and, a year from now, that's what we'll have.
- atemerev 4y agoThis problem was discovered and taken care of from the start of the development of modern nuclear weapon designs. See “strong link / weak link” and “always/never problem”, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strong_link/weak_link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strong_link/weak_link (I believe the diagram here is wrong, but it doesn’t require much thinking to deduce how the correct diagram should look like).