9 ms·
The end of founder worship, and a reset of toxic startup values
- mocko 4y agohttps://archive.ph/sPPXn https://archive.ph/sPPXn
- jmeister 4y agoThe opposing case: >..the incentives of a managerial class are not the same as the incentives of the lone entrepreneur. They have different timelines, risk profiles, and diversification/skin in the game. The managerial class is often motivated by a huge salary, so they’re more likely to play it safe to preserve their job. Even if the companies fail, they’ll get extremely rich. They’re just trying to hang on for as long as they can. Owners however are often motivated by their equity, so they’re more likely to think in the long-term interests of the company. https://eriktorenberg.substack.com/p/burnham-elon-and-the-revenge-of-entrepreneurial https://eriktorenberg.substack.com/p/burnham-elon-and-the-re...
- ShamelessC 4y agoSeems logical, also doesn't reflect reality in my experience. Founders want to piss off an incumbent enough to be bought or IPO. Founders also seek social reward. Once you're in the one percent, your motivations are completely detached from the rest of us. You're encouraged to consider yourself as a wunderkind playing high stakes poker in order to raise money, as this is the only real signal investors latch onto. Disruption itself is a game of usurper; not one of business fundamentals. The agents still act "rationally" (in their own best interests, supposedly), but those interests are defined differently than suggested.
- monero-xmr 4y agoPlenty of founders go public early and raise large capital. Biotech, energy firms, and electric car companies recently. Tech startups are pretty unique in that they need huge amounts of capital from private markets for a long time. It requires a higher risk-reward story to be told leading to moonshots.
- ShamelessC 4y agoSorry I didn't qualify that we're talking about tech founders on the technology forum.
- fallingknife 4y agoTech companies actually need much less capital to scale than other industries. Which is why VC focuses on software, and why tech founders are so much richer than founders in other industries. The problem is that once the VC industry reached its peak, the capital itself became a competitive weapon. If startup 1 only really needs $10 million in capital to reach profitability, the VCs can't make that much money off of it. So they will fund startup 2 with $100 million over several rounds, and almost certainly knock startup 1 out of the market just by scaling faster. That means startup 1 essentially has to raise and burn massive amounts to grow as rapidly as possible, even if they would prefer to go with the $10 million to profitability plan that would be considered the only sane route in any other industry. And it leads to the almost unbelievable to anyone in finance outside of VC situation of investors being pissed that a company isn't burning cash fast enough.
- rqtwteye 4y agoI think founders thought about the long term when companies were growing slowly by earning money and then reinvesting it. At least in SV with the amounts of available investor money they are incentivized to make a company look good for a few years and then cash out enormous amounts of money. There doesn’t seem to be long term thinking of the company as a sustainable business.
- efitz 4y agoExactly. I think that the problem is the “constant growth at any cost” model.
- horns4lyfe 4y agoTwice now I’ve watched up close as founders mismanaged companies into oblivion while chasing Silicon Valley clout. Those companies crashed and burned while the founders still got rich. That quote might apply to normal entrepreneurs, but not to the VC funded nonsense we see now.
- SamoyedFurFluff 4y agoNothing in this article describes the additional layer of anti-startup thinking: the idea you the employee can make a ton of money off of the equity issued to you is slowly being less and less true. Your equity is diluted, deferred, or otherwise rendered functionally worthless such that it’s no longer worth joining an early startup with a compensation package involving equity. More and more employees just demand cash.
- hprotagonist 4y agoslowly? It’s ever been thus except in very rare anomalous situations. My default position has been that equity is monopoly money, and it’s been that position since the Simpsons mocked the dot com crash. “Oh, Bart: it’s not about how much stock you have, it’s about how much copper wire you can rip out of the wall before they catch you!”
- nowherebeen 4y agoI think employees treat startups more and more like a jumping pad to get to their ultimate goal of work for Fang. There's no point staying at startups when working at a big tech will yield more money in the long term. I don't blame them though. Look at how startups are run nowadays, all the potential upside has been sucked dry by VCs.
- whstl 4y agoYeah, that's something I noticed as well. Smaller companies have become a mere rite of passage. I now see a lot of young candidates intending to only stay one or two years on a small startup to get experience before quitting, some of them confiding that right after signing the contract. And older developers historically already prefer jumping ship rather than negotiating salaries or facing situations they can't win.
- bgribble 4y agoThat’s true for some people but not everybody. I like little companies and am willing to take less salary for the enjoyment of building the product from the beginning, knowing every single person you work with, and playing different roles in the team. I have worked for mega-companies via acqui-hire and I feel like my preference is based in solid experience. I’ve never hired into a company with more than 30 employees in my 30+ years as a developer and probably never will. My current gig is now grown well into the size range where I frequently am reminded why I don’t like bigger companies :(
- ergonaught 4y ago> And in the aftermath, a much healthier ecosystem may emerge [...] Seems to have missed the lesson of its immediately previous paragraph: > The 1980s were dominated by junk bond specialists, the nineties by investment bankers, the aughts by hedge fund mangers. Nothing was learned about the 80s, or the 90s, or the 00s (or or or ad infinitum). The parasites merely adapted to the changing environment and found new host expressions.
- neilv 4y agoI wonder how many people driving the scams and schemes of each generation consider themselves the baddies. And what about the people at various degrees of distance, but still riding the coattails of that.
- doctorwho42 4y agoProbably even fewer than the small % you think. In my experience most of them have adopted a philosophy that promotes the behavior. Think on the simplistic lines of "if not me, then somebody else will do it", "without me the technology/etc. Would never exist", or my favorite variant: the true believer.
- plussed_reader 4y agoDon't forget the perennial, "If it were wrong it would be illegal."
- 082349872349872 4y ago> ”Most of us,” she said, “are just making something slightly better than what already exists.” It occurred to me yesterday that Flyer (1903) to Viking (1976) was only ~7 decades, and we're currently at Eniac (1945) + 78. That said, I think the aerospace people had a far, far better grasp of the underlying principles of their domains than we do of ours, so there's still hope for major advances in software. (OTOH, judging by his published output, Luca Cardelli believes he had Von Neumann programming all figured out by the turn of the century — so that hope may be slim)
- danjac 4y agoMaybe, but how much advancement has been seen in aerospace 1977-2023 compared to 1903-1976?
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoI actually think we’ve done pretty well considering there are physical limits. Space we’ve obviously done really well. But even in commercial aviation we have planes carrying more passengers that use less fuel, less crew, and have far better safety records than 1976. And tickets are much cheaper as well.
- danjac 4y agoTrue, but the advancements seem incremental rather than revolutionary (i.e. compared to the first half of the 20th century)
- tsimionescu 4y agoWhile interesting to compare, I think ultimately progress can never be reflected to maintain some particular level. I think a better picture is that given some initial state X, and a new discovery D, there is another state Y that we can reach in some amount of time T by exploring all consequences of that discovery in the context of X. If no new discoveries arise before we reach state Y, progress will essentially halt entirely, until some random process happens to produce a new discovery. I believe we are now getting closer to finishing the exploration of a series of extraordinary discoveries that happened in the 1900s-1940s or so, and have so far been unlucky in making any completely new discovery, so our rate of progress as we get near to a state Y is slowing down. Edit: typos
- rcshubhadeep 4y agoI did not read the entire article but the first couple of paragraphs are a good take on what, I think, is called "Start-up porn". I am tired of listening how good Jobs is and only some mentioning what Wozniak did for Apple (Personal computing in general). Engineers deserve equal respect as so-called "Founders". At least I believe so. Please let us be worthy of recognizing the hard work of people.
- anonyme-honteux 4y agoFounder worship is a straightforward evolution of a general US/protestant (See Max Weber) worship of rich people. It's here to stay because that permeates US culture completely. Most don't even notice it. I do because I was raised in a roman-catholic country rich people are not supposed to be worshipped - straightforward interpretation of the Bible. On the other hand when I read stories of Elon Musk the real-life Tony Spark whose by the sheer force of its genius brain is going to save Humanity by making it multi-galactic, that does remind me of the hagiographies I had to read when I was young - those unbelievable but nonetheless believed biographies of the saints of the catholic pantheon.
- rabuse 4y agoYou think it's only the U.S. who worship rich people?
- anonyme-honteux 4y agoFor example Bernard Arnault is currently the richest man on earth and the cult of Bernard Arnault in France is pretty much inexistant.
- luckylion 4y agoThat's an interesting point. I'm from Germany and we definitely have founder worship here (but we have fewer founders, and these days a lot of the 'startups' are just projects by students looking for state subsidies, not private money) but we also have a lot of protestants. Is it not the same in Spain or Italy?
- anonyme-honteux 4y agoMax Weber's "Protestant Ethic" did not refer to the teaching of Luther that are mainstream in Germany but specifically to the Calvinists and Pietists that brought their value to the US. --- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Protestant_Ethic_and_the_Spirit_of_Capitalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Protestant_Ethic_and_the_S... When he discussed it in the Protestant Ethic, he used Lutheranism as the chief example of the unio mystica that contrasted sharply with the ascetic posture. Later he would associate "Luther, the symbolic exponent of bureaucratic despotism, with the ascetic hostility to Eros — an example of Weber's sporadic tendency to link together bureaucratic and ascetic modes of life and to oppose both from mystical and aristocratic perspectives." However, Weber saw the fulfillment of the Protestant ethic not in Lutheranism, which was too concerned with the reception of divine spirit in the soul, but in Calvinistic forms of Christianity.[6]: 32–33 The trend was carried further still in Pietism.
- bgribble 4y ago> “I got this wrong and I take responsibility for that,” This has always bugged me. Yes I get it you don’t want to put it in some passive-voiced “mistakes were made” kind of thing. But what does it mean to “take responsibility” if there are no consequences? It would be meaningful if the “take responsibility” statement was followed up with “and I’m submitting my resignation effective immediately.” But “I take full responsibility… and y’all are fired” is just a way to get the good feels of “owning it” without actually owning it.
- blululu 4y agoNot the only one but it is a highly bogus catchphrase: https://www.itakefullresponsibility.fyi/ https://www.itakefullresponsibility.fyi/
- luckylion 4y agoThe cliche response to that is "why would you want to let someone go in the moment that he's learned this valuable lesson?". The "learnings" they discuss in their "retro" are always very specific, they're never that "you suck as a CEO and shouldn't lead a company because you have no clue what you're doing".
- whstl 4y ago"I take responsibility" is a coded way of saying "the discussion is over". This is a very old management trick to avoid further arguments and discussion. You wanna avoid telling someone they're incompetent? Just say "it was my mistake to have hired you, we weren't ready to have someone in your position". You wanna rescind a job offer because you got cold feet? Just say "our HR made a mistake, and this offer shouldn't have been made". It also means you're not willing to work together to solve the problem. The reason for those mass-layoffs are not "mistakes" by founders, and they're happening at the same time for a specific reason: to put employees collectively at a disadvantage in terms of salary and negotiations. They successfully shifted the discussion from this to "Why are they taking responsibility without any consequence?".
- rchaud 4y agoI interpret the term as "I have to have a lot of inconvenient conversations with the board and large shareholders about this". > The reason for those mass-layoffs are not "mistakes" by founders, and they're happening at the same time for a specific reason: to put employees collectively at a disadvantage in terms of salary and negotiations. See, I think they're all happening at the same time because these companies are publicly traded, so executives are primarily concerned about shoring up the stock price ahead of an expected recession.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jasoneckert 4y agoSilicon Valley - and the tech industry in general - have always operated on optimism and hype. And while I understand the point that the author of this article is trying to make, I don't think that there will be any significant value reset (of any kind) in the industry that will be remembered in a few years. Moreover, the industry will likely always have sycophants, as they are the objects that drive this optimism and hype for those aspiring to achieve greatness.
- throwawayboqt 4y agoIs not it Chinese funded news outlet?
- mitthrowaway2 4y agoIt is not. What makes you think it is?
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> Instead of solely focusing on revenue – something many founders did because financing rounds or exits are based on a multiple of sales – Jane emphasized keeping customer churn low. This is a weird thing to write, because keeping custom churn low is one of the key points of increasing revenue. Startups don’t really choose one or the other. They need both. I think the author may have been in such a rush to sort startups into “good” and “bad” examples that they bought into one startup’s positive spin on their own constrained growth. I do agree with the general point that a return to focus on sustainable business is good for the industry. The easy money of the past several years has produced some weird distortions in the industry. I’ve been involved with startups where shipping product seemed like it was the lowest priority. They were so busy hiring credentialed managers and building out elaborate org charts and planning unnecessarily complicated off-sites and events. It felt like the infinite funding created an environment where they felt financially successful despite barely having customers yet, and they turned themselves into big company excess because that was the cargo cult thing to do.
- aqme28 4y agoIn practice I do not think you are correct. I don’t want to name names, but revenue and growth over churn was one of the explicit directions of a startup I worked at. I agree with you that churn is important, but don’t think that’s a rule that all managers follow.
- manxman 4y ago[dead]
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y ago[flagged]
- ttul 4y agoThis article misses the mark. Shopify etc. are not stupid companies. During the good times, it made sense to take cheap money and expand headcount. Growing fast when the growth is available is a good idea. During a downturn, you make layoffs. Big deal. That’s how it works.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoI kind of agree but on the other hand it’s not so simple. Layoffs aren’t instant and their negative effects on morale and employee work can last a long time. It can also be hard to identify the right people to lay off so companies are likely to make the wrong choice in many cases. So on one hand yes it makes sense to splurge when money is cheap and then cut back when it isn’t, on the other you may cause long term damage to your business doing this too much. I think tech companies probably overdid it the past few years.
- Waterluvian 4y agoI agree. There is a qualitative cost to this grow/contract strategy. And I’m not sure companies are able to recognize or react to it because it can’t be measured easily.
- taveras 4y agoThis is “how it works” because founders are better rewarded when quick growth happens over a short time window. Perhaps that incentive is the problem?
- crazygringo 4y agoWell, in markets where there's only space for 1, 2, or 3 companies to succeed, then it makes sense to be rewarded for quick growth, so that you can end up in one of the 1-3 "winning" slots instead of going out of business. The incentive isn't something artificial, it's just how certain markets work. E.g. a city might be able to support hundreds of pizzerias, but only 2-3 ride hailing companies.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoNo shit Sherlock ! We have been pointing this out for more than a decade : antitrust has been asleep at the wheel ! "World domination" is not something to be encouraged in a company ! If the worst offenders like Facebook and Uber had been made an example of and shut down then (including by pressure from other countries), we would have had a much less insane funding environment.
- lamontcg 4y ago(asserted without any proof)