2 ms·
> 19 Becquerel is quite weak. Isn't it just? I'm glad you picked that up as 1.9 MBq through up to 750 MBq is more of the range I would have expected for a min
by defrost 4y ago
> 19 Becquerel is quite weak.
Isn't it just?
I'm glad you picked that up as 1.9 MBq through up to 750 MBq is more of the range I would have expected for a mining instrumentation source [1].
I'm guessing both the The Guardian [2] and AAP [3] relied on the same reporter who missed fact checking and an M (and possibly a decimal place) when interviewing the W.Australian Health minister (who, of course, may have bumbled that himself).
The W.Australian official press release avoided details [4].
Take note when going forward in your career as there'll likely be some moment of unexpected public relations in the future.
Any thoughts on the "full quote" ?
Chief Health Officer Andrew Robertson said the small silver cylinder was a 19-becquerel caesium 137 ceramic source commonly used in radiation gauges.
“That may not mean a lot to people but probably more concerning is that it does emit a reasonable amount of radiation,” he said.
Dr Robertson said the unit emits about two millisieverts of radiation per hour, which is the equivalent of having 10 x-rays in an hour.
“Two millisieverts is also the amount of natural radiation we would receive in a year just by walking around,” he said.
“This is a source we have to be very careful of … It is quite a large radiation dose.”
It's one thing to drop an M in MBq, another to get x-ray equivilants incorrect, so does this sound about ballpark to you?
I confess to a distaste for Sieverts as a per kilo absorbed dose (or is that Grays) as its kind of subjective to target rather than source properties (as the source may be partially shielded by lead, water, etc.)
Moving on, 700 k counts / minute background (or 12 k counts/sec for those of us working in one second over lapped accumulation windows) sounds ballpark.
The interesting twist on the source, though, is it might be shaped in the sense of having a wrapper of lead (say) with an aperture of preference to direct the radiation preferentially.
> I neglected here that not all gamma rays that reach the detector actually will leave a signal in the detector.
For at least two reasons, 'eh?
* Not all gammas passing through the crystal will cause a flash (you covered by implication), AND
* Not all flashes will be counted (oft neglected) as the scintillation counters get saturated by single events and need to recover, they also fluff damn near simultaneous multiple events as singles (all this dependant on scintillation detection equipment).
> Hope that gives you an idea how you can estimate these types of questions.
I was very interested to hear your reasoning, I appreciate it and I hope your comment gets a few eyeballs, although HN moving on apace as it does, who knows?
> Forgot to mention the radon. Usually you do not measure much radon unless it rains. It is mostly a dessert there so I don't think that should be an issue
Hmm. You might want to look into this further I suspect.
My poor understanding is that rainstorm fronts drop the barometric pressure which draws radon gas from the cracks and crevasses in which the gas has already been expressed from the rock sources.
So, yes, there is an increase in radon gas where radon gas is normally expressed due to pressure drops.
However, in a hypothetical environment with no pressure changes .. radon continues to be expressed if it is being created.
I've found, in my humble experience, that even on clear days rain free days in Western Australia radon is thick on valley floors in those areas that have it in the still of the mornings, and gone later in the afternoon as the winds increase and clear the heavy ground hugging gases.
I would suggest that radon is a function more of geology and topography .. modified in variance by air pressure and wind conditions.
In any case, thank you for your response, I look forward to any further thoughts you may have, and, in closing, you may enjoy this entertaining A0 wall map [5] .. or perhaps the larger raw datasets (also available) [6]
[1] https://inis.iaea.org/collection/NCLCollectionStore/_Public/31/024/31024450.pdf https://inis.iaea.org/collection/NCLCollectionStore/_Public/...
[2] https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2023/jan/28/missing-radioactive-capsule-wa-officials-admit-it-was-weeks-before-anyone-realised-it-was-lost https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2023/jan/28/missi...
[3] https://www.aap.com.au/news/search-for-radioactive-capsule-in-outback/ https://www.aap.com.au/news/search-for-radioactive-capsule-i...
[4] https://ww2.health.wa.gov.au/Media-releases/2023/January/Search-underway-for-dangerous-material https://ww2.health.wa.gov.au/Media-releases/2023/January/Sea...
[5] https://ecat.ga.gov.au/geonetwork/srv/api/records/a05f7892-f8c2-7506-e044-00144fdd4fa6 https://ecat.ga.gov.au/geonetwork/srv/api/records/a05f7892-f...
[6] https://www.ga.gov.au/scientific-topics/disciplines/geophysics/radiometrics https://www.ga.gov.au/scientific-topics/disciplines/geophysi...
- cosama 4y agoTurns out the dropped a G not a M [1]. 0.5Ci is a very strong source, it should be observed by a plane at 100-200m above ground with sufficient detector volume. Considering they still haven't found it, it must have rolled somewhere, where there is considerable shielding upwards or towards the street, or been carried away. @defrost Great discussion and addition by the way. I only have one additional comment concerning radon. Radon is produced in a radioactive decay in the ground, and as it is gaseous it usually dissipates into the atmosphere rather quickly, so there is not too much of it near the detector at any given time. As you mention correctly, certain weather condition obviously can trap it near the ground. We usually study urban centers, with lots of asphalt covering the ground, affecting the amount released near the ground and near our detectors. We usually see it during rain, as then the radon in the atmosphere is washed down through the rain and accumulates on top of the ground for a while, which we often see as a strong uptick followed by an exponential decay. I have a coworker that just submitted a paper for review regards modeling this, sorry can't link the work yet. Overall, radon is quite tricky to understand and what you mention seem very reasonable. It would be quite interesting putting a detector for a while in these areas. Nevertheless, the measured amount of radon usually fluctuates on larger scales, maybe hundreds of meters, while the source will create a very localized signal, so it shouldn't cause too much troubles for a search like this. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Australian_radioactive_capsule_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Australian_radioactive...
- defrost 4y agoYeah, mind you the Giga is quite a jump over Mega (see the reference I gave above on mining applications), so I'm not entirely sure I trust the update. For context, Rio Tinto operations in Mt. Newman are mining iron ore from near surface open pit | mesa deposits; blasting rock with minimal crushing to fit in rail carriages for transport to the ocean ports where ore is crushed smaller, screened and graded (blended) for shipping overseas .. in total some 850 million tonne per annum of iron ore from that region (not just Newman alone). I'm guessing the guage is for estimating ore density | grade on the fly as rocks tumble through the load out (from the remote operated semi autonomous near robot trucks) into kilometre+ long robot trains. > Considering they still haven't found it Yeah, I'm very surprised the search is still on, I'm leaning towards it's well off route in a tire in a truck (or already fallen free) OR some heavily tatted FiFo worker (fly in | fly out) nicked it as a souvenir for the local bikkie clubhouse and hasn't came home from a holiday in Thailand yet .. . Radon: IIRC there are additions in the Australian AGSO radiometric processing guidelines re: radon removal that derived from work I did levelling out radon smearing back in the 1990s - somewhat out of date these days, but hey, that's the world for you. There are also potential modifications to the work by Brian Minty | Jens Hovgaard | Bob Grasty using an NASVD to firstly highlight the use of Radon eigenvectors and then to rotate them out of the signal space in the processing pipeline. I'm guessing (completely w/out context) that perhaps your friend is moving down that path (or perhaps well past and elsewhere, as I said, it's been a while).