3 ms·
Eh, they're in a tough spot, at least at the middle school level. My kids' school gave every student a Chromebook upon return to in-person school, and the resu
by ceejayoz 4y ago
Eh, they're in a tough spot, at least at the middle school level.
My kids' school gave every student a Chromebook upon return to in-person school, and the result thus far has been massive amounts of distraction as half the class winds up on YouTube or something instead of getting work done. I wish they'd ditch them entirely, but the school went all-in on Teams.
- yamtaddle 4y agoOurs have had school ipads or macbooks since Kindergarten(!) and agreed, it's awful. They should drop the tech until high school. It's not helping anything and is a huge distraction. All the online homework shit's so very much worse than when they just had workbooks full of tear-out sheets, for the lower grades. You can probably buy a hundred or more of those books for a reasonable subject-curriculum for a year, bulk, for the cost of one low-end iPad. Just go back to that stuff. It was fine. This isn't better. Worse, I can't put my own parental controls on it. Any devices of ours our kids use have strict ScreenTime limitations on hours of use, total amount of use in a day, which programs can be used at all, which sites can be reached—meanwhile, the school devices have few restrictions and they can reach all kind of garbage sites on them, and I can't tighten that down.
- xwolfi 4y agoYou can with a smart router like the Synology RT2600: it can do mac-adress level site firewalls so say ban youtube between such and such for all your kids' devices (it can assign a persona to a bunch of mac addresses).
- yamtaddle 4y agoYeah, I know I can get more hardware to fix it (or set up a BSD router again like I did way back in '04 or whenever) but it sucks that I already have a good system that works perfectly for my needs and required no tech horse-shit on my part (I'm just... so over doing that stuff when someone's not paying me to) and the schools are punching holes in it. Got this great smoothly-running machine here, and they're tossing a wrench in the works. I did try that already with Google's router (we have Fiber) but of course it doesn't have mac-level blocking. I could swear it used to, but if it did, it doesn't now.
- pixl97 4y agoThis could possibly end up problematic as I've seen videos embedded in kids homework. Not sure if that was just something that particular teacher did or what.
- heavyset_go 4y agoI'm pretty sure that Apple, Google and Microsoft all have education programs where they offer school districts free or discounted hardware and services. Not that it makes it any better, it actually makes it worse because it illustrates the lengths they're going to invade kids' privacy and mine their data.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xwolfi 4y agoSo funny, at work in my company we do have computers, since we re an investment bank doing electronic trading, but no youtube, nor even mobile phone allowed. If they catch us with a mobile phone on the trading floor, it's reported to compliance. Why are school allowing kids to have youtube during class, they could at least firewall it like companies do.
- yamtaddle 4y agoBlocking certain sites can make having the Internet at all far less useful to teachers. Youtube's one of those. Unfortunately, Youtube doesn't have allow-list capabilities that'd allow blocking YouTube proper but allowing some subdomain that required login and displayed only permitted videos (parents have only been begging for it since, IDK, forever—YouTube Kids is a cesspool, all we want is allow-lists, but nooooo). Youtube was especially vital during remote learning (what's a better way for a teacher to distribute a video lesson?) and some schools are still trying to use similar schemes for snow days and such. Plus there's just a ton of useful material on Youtube and teachers don't always think of some video they might want to show when they're at home and can snag it on their own connection, or maybe they want the kids to watch them individually at their own pace (being able to pause or rewind is so nice!) (for the record, I'd rather they just ditch the tech entirely until at least high school, but if they're gonna have it, they probably ought to have YouTube access or else it's far less useful. I'm also not sure why schools started letting kids carry phones to class, what a fucking terrible idea)
- whatshisface 4y agoDifferent YouTube videos are at different URLs.
- contravariant 4y agoYou can't really block URLs at a network level though, you'd need access to the device. If you own the device you could of course install the required root certificates to interfere with HTTPS traffic, but arguably that's more intrusive, and a massive security hole if you make a mistake (like Lenovo did, for example).
- bdw5204 4y agoThe idea of giving kids laptops with unsupervised internet access to use for in-person school sounds really weird to me. At the very least you'd think the teacher would be able to see and control their screen to stop them from misusing the computers during class. I remember that functionality was available in a computer lab when I was in high school and the teachers would absolutely use it if you were off task (but if you finished your work early they generally didn't care if you browsed Wikipedia). That does explain who the target audience for Chromebooks is though. Most tech illiterate adults seem to prefer Windows or Mac for their own machine, in my experience.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThey have the ability to view the students' screens, but they're probably 80% of the time instructing or walking from desk to desk. Very little time sitting on their computer during a class period, so little opportunity to monitor.