3 ms·
Then, on June 9, 2020, Anderson came across a tweet from Milton. His truck company, Nikola, had gone public on NASDAQ five days before: “I’ve wanted to say this
by paulpauper 4y ago
Then, on June 9, 2020, Anderson came across a tweet from Milton. His truck company, Nikola, had gone public on NASDAQ five days before: “I’ve wanted to say this my whole adult life; $NKLA is now worth more than Ford and [Fiat Chrysler]. Nipping on the heels of GM …”
Given that Ford and GM trade at very low multiple and have not done much in a long time, even decades, this is not that undoable.
I think the survivorship bias with shorting is huge. So many people and firms try and fail. The risks seem to be glossed over by the article. Seeing a few big winners like Nikola one may be under mistaken impression this is a good strategy.
Having a big win is seldom enough to beat the market. If you allocate 5% of your capital for a short and it goes bankrupt, you only increased your total capital by 5%. Making the historical 10% average (including dividends) with an index fund is less risky and more consistent, probably.
- 2020aj 4y agoThe full article indeed discusses these shortcomings and does not make it appear that short selling is more effective. It portrays it almost as a form of activism
- bbor 4y agoI hope it’s not too rude for HN to say that you’re missing the whole point of the article. 1. Presumably that discussion took place pre-FTX. 2. I don’t think he said “1000% in a day”, just in general. 3. The article goes into repeated, extensive detail about how short selling is financially dubious and extremely risky. 4. It goes into his childhood because it’s a profile piece. I mean this with no offense, only because I’ve been there many times: did you feel personally attacked by this guys takes on crypto/stocks/our world at large?
- paulpauper 4y agoGood points, agree. Short selling needs to be weighed with risks vs. reward. Unlimited downside is a major risk. Would not recommend it.
- rhaway84773 4y agoThe article goes on and on about how risky shorting is and how many firms have failed. No one thinks of shorting as a good business strategy. That’s why when Elon Musk goes on about how shorts are these shadowy super powerful figures you know he’s completely bullshitting because shorts are among the few (only?) actors interested in downward price discovery, while the rest of the world, including governments all over, would much prefer constant price growth with the correction to be suffered by a future generation/government.